51 pages 1-hour read

The Case of the Missing Marquess

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2006

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 8-11Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of racism and graphic violence.

Chapter 8 Summary

Enola rides through the countryside, elated at her escape. She encounters a nomadic community of Roma people and recalls how, unlike most people of her class, Eudoria was always friendly toward the Roma and admired their way of life. Enola waves to them and is pleased when some of the women and children wave back. She knows that Mrs. Lane would accuse the Roma of being dirty thieves; she herself thinks this might be true, but it does not make her feel less generous toward them. Later, she encounters a traveling peddler and buys a carpetbag from him.


That night, Enola finds a tree-covered hill to sleep on. She takes off the uncomfortable corset and transfers some of her possessions from their hiding spots into the carpet-bag. She leaves her stash of money hidden in the corset’s bustle. In the distance, she can see the lights of a town and hear the whistle of an approaching train. She decides that, in the morning, she will get a train to London.


The next day, she dresses in Eudoria’s mourning clothes, noting with satisfaction how well-disguised she is by the dark veil. She feels a little sad about having to abandon her bicycle as she enters the bustling village. From a newsboy’s cries, she learns that a local nobleman, the young Viscount Tewksbury, Marquess of Basilwether, has been kidnapped. At the train station, a group of plainclothes detectives from Scotland Yard is just arriving, causing great excitement. Enola overhears someone commenting that Sherlock Holmes has refused to take the case, as he is currently occupied with some family matter. She also learns that no ransom demand has yet been made of the distraught parents. Enola is intrigued. Instead of buying a train ticket, she buys a newspaper to read about the kidnapping.

Chapter 9 Summary

Enola is surprised by the picture of Viscount Tewksbury she sees in the newspaper. He’s dressed like a very young child, with long curls and a frilly velvet suit, despite being 12 years old. She learns that an outer door at his home was forced open and his room was found in disarray, but that nothing has been stolen from the house. Instantly, Enola knows what has happened to the young marquess. She heads for Basilwether Park.


At the gate, Enola gives her real name without thinking. She instantly regrets not giving the pseudonym she has already chosen for her new life: Ivy Meshle. Still, she sees that she can turn this to her advantage by pretending that Sherlock has sent her to investigate. The lodge-keeper is impressed and admits her to the estate. Enola heads for some woodlands near the house, but she is intercepted by the marquess’s mother. The duchess has heard about her arrival and has come to beg Enola to find her missing child. Enola gently assures the woman that she will find the marquess.


Their conversation is interrupted by a strange, tall woman with wiry red hair, wearing a loud red dress. The woman announces that she is Madame Laelia Sibyl de Papaver, Astral Perditorian, and that she will use her psychic powers to find the missing boy. Enola dismisses this talk of supernatural forces, but she is riveted by the word “perditorian,” which she understands to mean a finder of lost things. She immediately decides that she will become the world’s first “professional, logical, scientific perditorian” (120).


The duchess and Laelia return to the house, and Enola continues toward the woods. As she searches for the hideaway she is sure the young marquess must have built there, she thinks about her own escape plan. When she gets to London, she intends to place an encrypted message in the periodicals her mother reads, hoping to contact Eudoria. Now, having decided to become a professional perditorian, she also imagines working in this field and associating with other professional women—perhaps even women who know her mother. She finds a treehouse the marquess has constructed and climbs up into it. There, she discovers that the marquess has cut off all of his long curls and shredded his fancy, childish clothing. She also finds many pictures of ships and knotted cords.

Chapter 10 Summary

On her way back to the Basilwether house, Enola runs into Inspector Lestrade, a detective from Scotland Yard who has worked on several cases with Sherlock. He questions her about her relationship to Sherlock, but she deflects his questions skillfully and instead directs the conversation to the missing marquess. She hands him a lock of the boy’s hair she gathered in the treehouse and suggests that the marquess has run away, likely to the London docks, where he will be trying to get work aboard a ship. Their conversation is overheard by Laelia, who is standing atop a nearby staircase.


Having delivered the information to Lestrade, Enola decides it is time to get away while she still can, and she heads for the train station. On the train, she reflects that she will have to abandon her widow disguise because Sherlock will hear about it from Lestrade. She is startled when a man’s large face appears in her compartment window. He is obviously searching for someone, but he goes away and does not bother Enola again. An elderly woman in Enola’s compartment notices her widow’s garb and, assuming she is a young and recently widowed woman who might need extra money, she tries to persuade Enola to visit a particular used-clothing store to sell some of her petticoats. Enola has no interest in selling these, but she realizes that she can obtain a new disguise by visiting such a shop.

Chapter 11 Summary

Enola’s first sight of London shocks her. She’s unprepared for its size and darkness, thinking of it as a “grotesque brick-and-stone parody” (141). Crowds of people brush by her, seeming indifferent to her. She takes a deep breath and heads east, toward the used-clothing stores she learned about on the train. The city around her grows progressively more impoverished, dirty, and dangerous. She is shocked at the living conditions of the poor and feels pity for them. She pauses for a moment, horrified at a woman crawling along the pavement, and too late she realizes that she herself is in danger.


A man rushes up and grabs Enola. He clamps a hand over her mouth and tells her that if she struggles or makes any noise, he will kill her. He shows her a long knife and demands to know where Lord Tewksbury is. Enola protests that she has no idea, but the man calls her a liar and moves as if to cut her throat. She hits him with her carpetbag, and it flies out of her hands. He stabs at her waist, but the knife is blocked by her corset. She twists away from him and runs. As she cries out for help, another man calls to her and guides her into an alleyway. She becomes alarmed when the second man leads her onto an unsteady, narrow wooden walkway. When Enola questions him, he grabs her and tells her to do what he says. She struggles and cries out, and he knocks her unconscious. When Enola wakes, she finds herself tied hand and foot in the hold of a boat. She is not alone: the Marquess of Basilwether is her fellow prisoner.

Chapters 8-11 Analysis

The action of Chapters 8-11 accelerates the pace of the novel as Enola goes on the run from her brothers, stumbles into another mysterious disappearance, discovers her true calling, arrives in London, and is attacked and kidnapped in the space of these four chapters. Her shocking discovery that she is being held captive with the Marquess of Basilwether creates suspense and ends the section on a cliffhanger, creating questions about what will happen next.


In this section, Springer incorporates another classic element of a coming-of-age story—a journey that presents the protagonist with new challenges and learning opportunities. She showcases Enola’s cleverness and determination as she calculates how to escape from her brothers and always manages to stay one step ahead of them, intuiting where they will look for her and how they will expect her to behave. She grows more confident as her plans succeed, proving that she is Mycroft’s and Sherlock’s equal, not their inferior, as they imagine, highlighting the novel’s thematic focus on The Underestimated Strengths of Women. In Chapter 9, Enola takes on an investigation of her own and discovers her true calling. Her encounter with Madame Laelia inspires Enola to devote her life to being a “perditorian” and gives her a sense of pride in her own “professional, logical, scientific” approach to finding what is lost (120).


Enola’s encounter with Madame Laelia creates a contrast between the novel’s three “detective” characters. Where Sherlock and Laelia are cold and self-centered in their approach to solving mysteries, Enola is compassionate and humble. She relies on her own experiences exploring the woods to deduce that Viscount Tewksbury has his own hideout in the trees. Enola’s instinctive understanding of others’ feelings and motivations is part of what allows her to so quickly deduce what has happened to the young marquess: “I knew where Lord Tewksbury might be. I just knew, although I did not know how to prove it” (114). She shows daring and intelligence when she strides onto the Basilwether estate, pretends Sherlock sent her, and proceeds to deduce Tewksbury’s whereabouts—but her first concern is the feelings of the people around her rather than her own goals and her own ego.


Enola’s travels and her first encounter with London introduce the novel’s thematic exploration of The Impact of Structural Inequality. Enola’s encounter with the Roma community traveling through the countryside illustrates how racial prejudices of her time have contaminated even Enola’s compassionate and logical mind: She romanticizes their lifestyle despite knowing nothing about them as individual people, regrets not having pennies on hand to throw to them, and reluctantly admits that Mrs. Lane’s stereotypes about the Roma—that they are a “Shameless, dirty, thieving lot”—are probably true (101). Her thoughts are unintentionally condescending and prejudiced, even though she sees herself as open-minded and accepting, reinforcing the deep prejudices against the Roma during Enola’s time. Her initial experiences also force her to confront how inequality impacts people in the city. She has been naively dreaming of London as a place of wealth, glamor, and excitement, and is shocked at the poverty and filth she sees there. The images of rats, impoverished elderly women crawling in the streets, drunk and disreputable men hiding in the shadows, and hungry, ragged children convey Enola’s disillusionment.


Enola’s descriptions of London underscore the potential danger she faces as a young woman traveling alone. She compares the tall buildings all around her to the “candles on the Devil’s birthday cake,” conveying a sense that even London’s attractive features are omens of impending doom (141). Her walk through the darkness into East London in Chapter 11 returns to the action sequence first covered in the novel’s prologue, contextualizing the prologue’s warnings about Enola being “hunted” and heightening the atmosphere of danger (2).


Springer uses the symbolism of Enola’s corset to transform the restrictive garment from an emblem of restrictive gender norms to a tool of resistance. At the beginning of her journey, she uses the corset as a hiding place for her valuables, making it instrumental in her escape. During her attack, her corset—an item of clothing she never wanted to wear and has uprooted her entire life to avoid—ends up saving her life when it blocks the blow intended to kill her. Rather than being forced to wear the corset, Enola dons it as a part of her disguise—something she can take off and put on at will rather than an inherent part of her. Accepting that the performance of gender expectations can be a useful tool in her arsenal is yet another step on Enola’s road to maturity.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 51 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs