50 pages 1-hour read

The Conditions of Will

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2025

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

Confronting Personal Trauma and the Past

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussions of rape, sexual violence, emotional abuse, anti-gay bias, cursing, and child abandonment.


Georgia Carter’s return to her hometown compels her to finally confront her past and begin to heal from her trauma. Ten years before the narrative present, Georgia’s parents Margaret and Will send her away to London, England, because they believe she had sex with her sister’s boyfriend, Beckett. In reality, Beckett sexually assaulted Georgia repeatedly for a year—abuse Maryanne knew about and did nothing. This past trauma establishes the stakes for Georgia’s return to Okatie, South Carolina, for her father’s funeral. Just driving up to her childhood home forces her to face the pain she’s been compartmentalizing throughout her life in London. Through Georgia’s first-person perspective, Hastings emphasizes that when she ignores her past trauma it “lodges itself in the corners of our memories, hangs off tree branches on Callawassie Drive [or] hides under the pews in the back row of the church” (17), explicitly tying Georgia’s psychological and emotional pain to the physical spaces of her childhood. Because she hasn’t confronted the past, she can’t fully move beyond her trauma.


Hastings shifts between the narrative present and Georgia’s childhood flashbacks to illustrate the ways the trauma of Georgia’s past informs her perspectives and relationships in the present. These temporal shifts demonstrate the ways that returning to Okatie and interacting with her estranged family bring Georgia’s traumatic memories to the fore of her mind. While remembering the abuse she suffered remains painful for Georgia, the act of remembering gradually leads her to understanding, reconciliation, and renewal over the course of her arc. Surrounded by the sights, sounds, and faces that defined her past life, Georgia finds herself revisiting her trauma and making sense of it in a concerted manner. Her reflections on Beckett’s sexual abuse capture her attempts to process her trauma:


This all of course took place during that horrible age where expressed and/or obvious consent was really emphasized, and I think what happened to me dwelled in neither the black nor the white. There wasn’t language for that at the time—but I believe now ‘gray rape’ is the umbrella term—to help us wade through nuances and conversationally facilitate the complexities of what Ashley C. Ford so aptly refers to as the ‘spectrum of harm’ (154).


In this passage, Georgia exhibits her interrogative and reflective tendencies, characterizing her as thoughtful and self-aware. She considers the circumstances of her past, incorporates its social context, and applies what she’s learned since to her trauma to actively understand her experiences. Georgia’s journey from avoidance to healing requires her to first acknowledge the abuse she suffered and then own the truth of her experience to her family. By telling her siblings and mother what happened to her, she takes a step toward reclaiming control of her narrative even though doing so forces her to own her pain as well.


Hastings frames the trauma of Georgia’s abuse as inherently entangled with her complicated grief over her father’s death. As Georgia internally processes her past rape, she’s also on an external mission to uncover the secrets her father kept. As a result, she experiences “a curious form of grief […] emerging within [her]” as she mourns the father she didn’t have, the father she didn’t know, and the relationship they might have had under different circumstances (451). Mourning her father in the present becomes inextricably connected to mourning the family and childhood she was forced to leave behind all those years prior. This grief is vital to Georgia’s healing process. Once she fully confronts her pain she can let go of her past and create a new future for herself.

The Intersection of Love and Loyalty

Georgia’s relationships with Sam and Oliver complicate her understanding of love, intimacy, and loyalty. Sam represents a future Georgia wants to build, while Oliver represents the shared trauma of their childhood. Since she was a little girl, Georgia has regarded her brother Oliver as her best friend and felt responsible for Oliver’s physical, emotional, and mental safety. Just as their conservative, Protestant family judged Georgia for her perceived promiscuity, they made Oliver a pariah because they disapproved of his sexuality, rooting their bond, in part, in their shared trauma. Hastings frames Georgia and Oliver’s relationship as defined by an established pattern in which Georgia constantly steps between him and their parents to ensure that Oliver feels seen, loved, and cared for—a dynamic complicated by Oliver’s addiction to alcohol.


Georgia and Sam’s immediate attraction to each other disrupts this pattern. Georgia internally acknowledges the inexplicable nature of her and Sam’s connection, saying: “It’s been seven days today since I first met Sam Penny and I can confirm with absolute certainty that I am completely in love with him. Ridiculous, I know. It’s fucking insane, actually” (252). For both Georgia and Sam’s romantic connection complicates their relationship with Oliver. For Sam, being with Georgia compels him to hide the truth from Oliver to avoid compromising his role as his AA sponsor. This tension between Sam and Georgia’s desires and their sense of loyalty and responsibility amplify the narrative suspense and challenge them to reexamine their understanding of love.


Hastings places Georgia’s desire to pursue love and happiness directly in conflict with her loyalty to Oliver. Pursuing a romantic relationship with Sam means breaking her long-held pattern of protecting her brother at all costs. As Georgia notes, Oliver has always loved her “a dysfunctional amount, and love and dysfunction are a peculiar pairing that flavor everything with a specific brand of contradiction” (145-46). Desperate to keep Oliver from emotional harm but unwilling to deny her feelings for Sam, Georgia attempts to keep their relationship a secret in an attempt to preserve both her connection with Sam and her loyalty to Oliver. Oliver’s discovery of their hidden romance forces Georgia to realize that playing this role (and regarding love and protection as synonymous) compromises her ability to make her own choices and pursue happiness on her own terms.


Throughout the novel, Georgia and Sam’s attempts to hide their relationship to protect Oliver capture the complexities that arise when love and loyalty intersect. Georgia and Sam convince themselves that their love represents an inherent betrayal of their loyalty to Oliver. Ultimately, they learn that their deception and dishonesty pose the greater threat to their bond with him. Once they reveal the truth to Oliver, they’re able to establish healthier forms of intimacy and connection.

Complexities of Familial Relationships

Will’s death acts as the novel’s inciting incident, compelling the Carter family members back into their childhood home and forcing them to confront their complicated interpersonal dynamics. For example, Georgia’s complex family situation is defined by her parents’ favoritism of Maryanne and Tennyson and their mistreatment of her and Oliver. Margaret and Will regarded Georgia and Oliver as such profound threats to their reputation that they sent both their children away when they were still teenagers. Even before Georgia and Oliver left home, the two relied on each other for support and safety. Georgia describes their relationship as a “complicated parentification relationship […] developed between us because we didn’t have anyone else so we had to be everything to each other” (15). The narrative parameters of The Conditions of Will capture the intricacies that define family life and the hard work it takes to navigate, confront, and heal these tensions.


Georgia’s character arc sees her both confronting and accepting her family members’ complexity and her own with honesty, allowing her to gain a more expansive perspective on her past. Even as adults, Margaret and Maryanne still regard Georgia as a pariah for her alleged sexual affair as a teenager—a perspective perpetuated by lies and deception. Ever since Will and Maryanne found Georgia and Beckett together, the entire family has deemed Georgia an embarrassment and a disgrace. Although 10 years have passed since these events, returning home to South Carolina reignites old tensions between the family members. Amidst their funeral proceedings for Will, the Carters must either confront and heal their differences, or let each other go.


Georgia finds peace of mind when she stops letting her family’s misconceptions of her determine her self-regard. When she chooses to tell the truth about Beckett’s assault, she also lets go of the need for her family’s validation or contrition. For example, Georgia confronts her mom and sister for their abuse, but when they prove incapable of changing, Georgia chooses to stop letting them hurt her. By refusing to be complicit in Maryanne’s lies, she takes control of her own story and feels pride in her life and identity. In contrast, hearing the truth alters Tennyson’s perspective and behavior, creating an opportunity for him and Georgia to reinvent their relationship. Although Georgia is unaccustomed to seeing Tennyson as a confidante, he takes active steps to regain her trust so they can establish a healthier connection. In turn, Georgia feels “a tiny bit happy to have someone to talk to” (105). Similarly, once Georgia and Oliver confront their dependency on each other, they learn how to respect and love each other as individuals.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock every key theme and why it matters

Get in-depth breakdowns of the book’s main ideas and how they connect and evolve.

  • Explore how themes develop throughout the text
  • Connect themes to characters, events, and symbols
  • Support essays and discussions with thematic evidence