63 pages 2-hour read

The Dangers of Smoking in Bed

Fiction | Short Story Collection | Adult | Published in 2009

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Stories 7-9Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of child sexual abuse, graphic violence, sexual violence, mental illness, emotional abuse, self-harm, sexual content, illness, and death.

Story 7 Summary: “Where Are You, Dear Heart?”

The unnamed female narrator remembers how her friend’s father sat naked on a sofa watching television, his penis and the scar down his chest on full display. In another memory, he is naked again, being led to the bedroom by his wife. In the third memory, his face is close to the narrator’s, and he smiles at her. She can’t remember if he molested her, but she doesn’t feel fear when she thinks of him, just the first stirrings of desire. After he died, the narrator began using her fingernails to recreate the shape of the man’s scar down the center of her own chest.


As a girl, the narrator falls “hopelessly in love” (88) with the “consumptive, moribund, and […] beautiful” Helen Burns from Jane Eyre (89). She commits the chapter describing Helen’s death to memory and spends every night imagining Helen dying as she holds her hand. At 14, the narrator learns that an ex-classmate’s brother is dying. She is anxious to meet the boy, sure she will fall in love with him. However, she is surprised to discover that she isn’t attracted to him, and she quickly realizes that she “didn’t like real sick people” (90). Instead, the narrator begins collecting medical books, which help her satisfy her obsession and “specify [her] fetishes” (91). She isn’t interested in diseases that seem “vulgar” or “filthy,” like cancer or gastrointestinal illnesses, but diseases of the heart or lungs are endlessly appealing. She finds young sufferers particularly attractive because the diseases generally aren’t apparent from the outside. She acquires a CD of abnormal heartbeats from a medical bookstore and spends hours masturbating while listening to this with her headphones on. Eventually, she gets rid of the CD, afraid it will “drive [her] crazy” (92), but her obsession soon finds another outlet.


When the narrator discovers an online community of other heartbeat fetishists, things begin to spiral out of control. She downloads audio clips of all kinds of heartbeats, isolates herself, and masturbates until she bleeds. She becomes enamored with one particular heartbeat and invites its owner to chat with her. Despite meeting in an international online community, they discover that they live in the same city and decide to meet in person. The man is “very sick,” but “he liked to have his heart listened to,” so the two “dove into pleasure” despite the possible consequences (94).


The narrator gives the man different substances to alter his heartbeat and lies on his chest for hours, listening to the effects. Sometimes, her enthusiasm borders on violence, and she worries she might lose control and actually harm him. She longs “to open him up, [and] play with his organs like hidden trophies” but tries to contain herself by “impos[ing] little punishments on [her]self” (95), like going without food or sleep. Eventually, she begins “hating” the man in what could be a reflection of her hate for her friend’s father, “[t]he man who’d ruined [her]” (96). She begins subjecting her lover to “games” that are increasingly extreme and dangerous. Sometimes he begs her to stop, but he never refuses her when she “asked for more” (96). When the narrator tells him she is “bored” and “want[s] to see it” (97), he doesn’t protest. He just tells her they will “need a saw” (97).

Story 8 Summary: “Meat”

The “shocking case of teenage fanaticism” (100) involving 16-year-old Julieta and 17-year-old Mariela quickly becomes international news. Reporters camp outside their families’ houses and the psychiatric clinic where the girls are being treated, but no one will speak to them. In the absence of comments from the girls or their families, the media is consumed by “an extreme hysteria” (100), and newspapers, tabloids, and talk shows discuss nothing else.


Julieta and Mariela were fans of Santiago Espina, an Argentinian rockstar with legions of both “worshipers” and “detractors.” After his second album, Meat, was a runaway success in Argentina, his label began considering an international release and promo tour; however, Espina disappeared just days before his first sold-out show in Buenos Aires. His fans, most of whom were teenage girls, were devastated and gathered publicly to mourn and create monuments “as if praying to a moribund god” (100).


Eventually, Espina’s body was found in a hotel room near the Once train station in Buenos Aires. He had skinned his own arms, legs, and stomach, then slit his throat. He left a note reading: “Meat is food. Meat is death. You all know what the future holds” (101). The air conditioning was on full blast, making the place feel like “a walk-in freezer” (101). The nation braced for “an epidemic of teenage suicides” (102), but Espina’s fans, “Espinosas” as they were known, largely went back to their lives, listening “to Meat as their idol’s last will and testament” (102). However, two of Espina’s fans were obsessing over their idol’s suicide note as they played Meat over and over.


Mariela was one of Espina’s early fans, following him around the city for a year to see all his shows. She was a familiar face at his concerts, and Espina would sometimes offer her a small token, even though he rarely addressed his fans. One night, in a club bathroom, Mariela met Julieta, who was famous among Espinosas for tattooing the star’s name on her neck. The girls were neighbors, and their idol’s death brought them together. They began to look so much alike that the caretaker who caught them trying to climb over the cemetery wall thought they were twins. The girls were “dazed” when the caretaker found them. He asked for their parents’ phone numbers, but when he saw they were covered in dirt and blood, he called the police instead.


The girls had snuck into the cemetery, exhumed Espino’s body, and “[fed] on Espina’s remains with devotion and disgust” (104). The girls were then taken to a private clinic. They just whispered to one another and held hands the whole way. No one would speak to the press. Espina’s mother was “overloaded on tranquilizers” (104), his band members were “disgusted” and “in shock,” and the girls and their families remained silent. The media interviewed other Espinosas and invited them to roundtable discussions. They mostly answered in monosyllables or giggles, but one girl sobbed and shouted that she was jealous of Mariela and Julieta, who “were closer to Espina than any of the rest of them” (105).


When Mariela and Julieta returned home, their families kept them home from school and did not allow them to speak to one another. Many of their neighbors moved away, frightened of “[t]he girls’ smiles, frozen on their TV screens and on front pages of newspapers” (106). However, all across Argentina, Espinosas began to receive mysterious emails. Everyone assumed they were from Mariela and Julieta, although there was no proof. Soon, the two girls would be 18 and would be able to do what they liked. The emails spoke of “an unstoppable underground cult, about They Who Have Espina in their bodies” (106), and the other girls waited eagerly for this day. They played Meat over and over, lingering on the last song, where Espina sings, “If you are hungry, eat of my flesh. If you are thirsty, drink from my eyes” (106).

Story 9 Summary: “No Birthdays or Baptisms”

The female narrator makes friends with Nico the “summer when all [her] other friends decided to become assholes” (107). Both are nocturnal, and they bond by conversing in chat rooms late at night. Soon, they begin meeting up in bars, where they “sip [their] whiskeys slowly and criticize everyone else” (108). Nico has dropped out of film school, but he has saved enough money to buy a camera of his own and places an ad in the paper offering his services for “weird film projects” (108). Sure enough, “weird or disturbed people” begin to seek him out (108).


Once Nico has completed the first few projects, he invites the narrator over to watch the videos. He smokes continually, and the narrator smokes almost as much, despite her attempts to cut back. She has given up on most of her attempts to get her life together and struggles “to meet goals as simple as sleeping at night and eating at least twice a day” (108). Most of Nico’s videos portray couples who hired him to be their private “porn director.” Another man hired him to film women in high heels walking down “specific” city streets. The next film is a tour of the city for a phobic girl who couldn’t leave her house. Nico calls the last one “the most interesting one” (110): A man hired him to film blond girls between the ages of six and 12. Nico went to a playground where he “stealthily” filmed children playing; however, when he gave the work to his client, the man was dissatisfied, telling Nico after some hesitation, “that the video didn’t have enough skin” (110). Nico tried again, this time visiting a pool that was holding a swim class for young girls. He tells the narrator that the man was so pleased with his work that he paid him double, plus an extra tip.


One day, a woman invites Nico over to discuss a job that is different from the “erotic videos” he usually films. The woman’s daughter, Marcela, suffers from hallucinations. All treatments have failed, and the girl refuses to accept that her hallucinations aren’t real. Her parents want to hire Nico to film her during one of her episodes to prove to the girl that she is alone. Nico agrees, and Marcela’s mother escorts him upstairs to meet her daughter. Marcela is dressed in an oversized sweatshirt, and her head is shaved to prevent her from tearing out her own hair. She smiles at Nico, telling him that her hallucinations are real and she “never [lies].” As she approaches, he notices her hands “[stink] of vaginal fluids, blood, sex, dead fish rotting in the sun” (112).


Nico and the narrator are fascinated by Marcela. They spend the day trying to piece together clues about Marcela’s mysterious illness, and when the mother calls, Nico goes alone to Marcela’s house while the narrator waits anxiously. Afterward, they watch the footage together as the girl, naked and covered in scars, masturbates compulsively, then goes to sleep. Although the episode ends, Nico’s tape continues, showing a half-hour-long “filmed tour of Marcela’s naked body” (115), which takes in her many scars but also her beauty. He explains that he cut that part of the tape before delivering the film to her parents. There is no sign of “the thing” that Marcela claims to see, and Nico is somewhat disappointed.


Marcela refuses to accept that Nico’s tape is true and insists that he film her again. Her mother tells Nico they cannot afford another session, but he offers to do the work for free. The next time he visits, Marcela’s father receives him. He tells Nico that his daughter “always had a lot of imagination” (116), but she was a normal child until the hallucinations started. Nico notices how Marcela’s parents treat her episodes like “a minor problem,” never explicitly discussing “the mutilations or the masturbation” (116). The second video is similar to the first, ending with a long exploration of Marcela’s body and failing to capture any sign of what is haunting her.


After the second video, Marcela asks to see Nico. She tells him that she thought Nico was the “chosen one” who would be able to see what she saw, and she is disappointed to be wrong. She also wants to see the videos he took of her while she was sleeping because she has “never seen [her] body” (118). This request surprises and unsettles Nico, but Marcela assures him she isn’t upset that he recorded her. Nico wonders how she doesn’t look at herself when she cuts herself, but she insists that “[he] cuts [her]” while she is sleeping. Nico leaves, sure he will not give Marcela the video. He and the narrator stop discussing Marcela, but they continue to sense her “between [them], naked and ravaged” (118), and they begin spending less time together. The narrator suspects that Nico fell in love with Marcela. When she asks him if he kept the videos of her, he admits that he did, but he assures her that he plans to throw them away. She doesn’t know if he follows through.

Stories 7-9 Analysis

The three stories in this section of the collection—“Where Are You, Dear Heart?,” “Meat,” and “No Birthdays or Baptisms”—are three of the darker and more disturbing stories in The Dangers of Smoking in Bed. However, they are also three of the most realistic. The horror that the stories draw on is entirely human; there is nothing supernatural or ghostly in them. Rather, the horror comes from the exploration of taboos and transgressions. These stories explore cannibalism, the eroticism of illness, and voyeurism, and they challenge the boundaries between fascination and revulsion.


In “Where Are You, Dear Heart?,” the narrator develops a sexual fetish for abnormal heartbeats, developing the theme of The Manifestation of the Grotesque in Everyday Life. The story is a coming-of-age story focusing on a sexual awakening, but it has a morbid twist. For much of the story, the narrator’s fetish is relatively harmless. She finds an online community of other heartbeat fetishists, and even when she meets her lover, both are consenting adults who are eager to take their sexual play to extremes. In fact, many people in the heartbeat fetish community think that her lover is “too extreme” and that he goes “too far” with tempting the limits of his illness (94), indicating the extent to which he is also an active and willing participant in the increasingly extreme nature of their erotic experiments. However, as they become more intimate, the narrator’s desire grows into an all-consuming obsession that takes over her life. She begins to lose control of her ability to regulate the violence of her desire. The depth of her obsession fuels a sense of hatred for her lover, linking him to the man from her childhood who first kindled her desire by possibly raping her, though the story doesn’t state this explicitly. The narrator feels “abnormal” and “sick,” as if she has been “ruined,” but she is compelled to continue sating her desire at all costs as she prepares to saw her lover’s chest open at the story’s conclusion.


Like “Our Lady of the Quarry,” “Meat” is largely about the frightening power of teenage girls and their frenetic collective energy when they work together. Enriquez has worked extensively as a journalist covering rock music, and her interest in music, pop culture, and goth culture is on full display in this story. Santiago Espina is a Marilyn Manson-esque figure who inspires a cult-like following in teenage girls across Argentina. Decked out “with their eyes lined in mortuary black, cheap feather boas around their necks, and leopard-print pants” (102), girls like Julieta and Mariela journey across Buenos Aires, night after night, in a kind of sacred pilgrimage to attend Espina’s shows. The story illustrates how celebrities are often elevated to a god-like status. It is common to describe a star’s cult-like following or the way fans worship celebrities, but Espinosas take this devotion to literal extremes. In one song, Espina sings, “If you are hungry, eat of my flesh. If you are thirsty, drink from my eyes,” invoking Eucharistic imagery as his fans patiently await “the second coming” (106). The girls’ eventual act of cannibalism literalizes this metaphor of worship.


“Meat” is unique in the collection because of the distance of its narrative voice. Most of the stories have a first-person narrator or a third-person limited narrator. “Meat,” however, is more objective. The details of Julieta and Mariela’s thoughts and feelings are never discussed, leaving the reader in the same situation as the media and the public in the story. However, their silence becomes a kind of power as it strips the story of a moral framework: It is unclear if the girls regret their actions at all. 


“No Birthdays or Baptisms” is primarily about Nico, who is one of the few prominent male characters in The Dangers of Smoking in Bed, but the story is filtered through a woman’s voice, the first-person female narrator. Nico and the narrator become best friends over the course of a summer as they bond over their shared apathy and disillusionment. They spend the summer smoking, drinking, and complaining about “boring” and “pathetic” people. However, when Nico begins filming Marcela, they both become obsessed with the girl, seeing her as the antithesis of the dull and predictable world they despise. They take pleasure in voyeuristically consuming her pain.


Like many of the other stories, Marcela’s parents deal with their daughter’s dangerous behavior by attempting to ignore it. They refuse to address her violent masturbation and self-harm directly, acting instead “as if they were talking about a minor problem” (116). Instead, Marcela is a figure of isolation as she suffers by herself in her room, linking this story to the theme of Isolation and the Loss of Human Connection. At the end of each session, Nico continues filming Marcela after her hallucinations end, as she sleeps naked in bed. Although she appears to be asleep, she later asks Nico for these videos, explaining that she has “never seen [her] body” (118). Marcela’s illness has taken away her agency and sense of control over her body and her life. Watching the videos would be a way for her to reclaim her own narrative, but Nico denies her this opportunity, deliberately withholding what she can and cannot see. Marcela’s experience mirrors that of other women in the collection who are forced to suffer in silence.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 63 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs