61 pages • 2-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of death by suicide.
After a troubled night, “mercifully free of dreams” (253), Magda waits for news. Emerence has visibly improved, but the doctors don’t think she’ll work again. Magda is exhausted and feels immense guilt. Viola refuses to eat. At the same time, Magda prepares for a trip to Athens, having been invited by the Greek writers’ union. Magda thinks about cancelling but worries that the nonappearance of a famous writer will cause international outcry and prompt accusations of censorship. In Greece, however, she feels unable to concentrate or contribute. She spends the trip in a daze. Returning to Hungary, she visits the hospital and finds Emerence surrounded by visitors. When Magda enters, however, Emerence covers her face with a veil. Magda is angry at being so demonstrably rebuked. She leaves and, on the way out, speaks to a nurse who warns that Emerence’s recovery is only “superficial.” Magda feels exasperated; she tells the nurse not to contact her, as Emerence won’t accept anything from her.
Magda is surprised when her husband sympathizes with Emerence. He helps her realize that Emerence is ashamed and is pretending to have amnesia. He suggests that Emerence thinks Magda “betrayed” her by not respecting her wish to die alone. Sutu brings news that Emerence is acting strangely. Everyone has maintained the pretense that Emerence’s home is fine, she explains, and that the cats are waiting for her. She doesn’t know that her possessions have been burned and her cats have gone. Magda knows that Emerence’s behavior stems from believing that she can “battle her way through” (265) her predicament. Magda goes to the hospital to speak to Emerence, assuring her that she “meant well.” Emerence begins to cry. Quietly, she says Magda betrayed her by not leaving her to die and then honoring her after her death. As Magda leaves, Emerence asks about her apartment. Magda decides to lie, assuring Emerence that she has “seen to everything” (268). Emerence seems changed. She holds Magda close to her in an expression of thanks. However, because she has lied, Magda is filled with “horror and ecstasy” (270).
Emerence’s recovery continues smoothly, as though she’s relieved. The better Emerence seems, the more Magda’s anxiety grows, knowing that her lies will be exposed. The Lieutenant Colonel assures Magda that Emerence will survive, but Magda is convinced that he doesn’t truly know Emerence. Everyone in the neighborhood looks for the cats but can’t find them. Meanwhile, the community gathers, seemingly organized by Sutu. Since Emerence’s illness, the neighborhood has divided up Emerence’s responsibilities among themselves, but Sutu insists that this can’t go on forever. Magda thinks Sutu is betraying Emerence by conspiring against her to become the “new caretaker” since Emerence will never recover to her previous strength.
Magda disputes Sutu’s version of events, insisting that Emerence can move into her house. Sutu points out that Emerence will never allow this to transpire. She doesn’t want any kind of life, Sutu says, because “she needs her own life, and she doesn’t have that any more” (276). Magda knows this is true, but views Sutu as a traitor. As the community resolves to continue covering for Emerence, Magda visits the doctor. He pushes for Emerence to be sent home from the hospital. Magda protests, but the doctor insists. He urges Magda to prepare Emerence’s home and assures her that, had she not intervened, Emerence would have died within 48 hours. The Lieutenant Colonel organizes for Emerence’s home to be redecorated and refurnished. Magda hopes that Emerence will move in with her and her husband, but she fears that Sutu is right.
Tension grips Magda. She wants to see Emerence, but Emerence refuses visitors. Magda ignores the sign on the door of Emerence’s hospital room. She enters and finds Emerence already veiled; she realizes that the woman recognized her footsteps. Emerence asks about her cats. They’re all gone, Magda says. Then, she tells the truth about what happened to Emerence’s apartment. She refers to it as a “tragedy.” Learning that Magda went to Athens in the aftermath of the incident, Emerence is enraged. Magda tries to make excuses, but Emerence cuts through them. She dismisses Magda, criticizing her again for not allowing her to die, as she had “made up [her] mind to” (288) when she realized that she would never work again.
Now, she can’t stand to have Magda around her. Magda is upset. She runs home through the rain. She frets at home. Her husband is also anxious. Unexpectedly, Viola becomes erratic, so they call the vet, who finds nothing wrong with the dog. Then, Viola begins to howl. Magda’s husband marks the time. Quietly, knowing what this means, Magda takes her raincoat and goes to the hospital. The doctor explains to her that Emerence demanded to leave, almost crawling out of bed despite her condition, and experienced another embolism. She died at the moment when Viola began to howl. Magda again feels guilty for having robbed Emerence of “a dignified finale in death” (292). When Magda sees Emerence’s dead body, she collapses and is hospitalized for a week. Many people visit, but only her husband’s face never loses “its expression of pity and overwhelming grief” (293).
In the end, Magda is surprised by “how simply it all [goes]” (294). The Lieutenant Colonel makes arrangements for Emerence’s preliminary burial; after the construction of her crypt, she and her family will be exhumed and reburied. Viola seems “supremely indifferent” to events around her. He never barks again after Emerence’s death. The probate hearing is held, and Emerence’s estate is divided as per her wishes, without any dispute. Seemingly, everyone in the neighborhood attends the funeral. All small businesses are closed. Though Emerence was openly antagonistic toward organized religion, Magda convinces the priest to speak at her funeral. She’s “deeply moved” by his eulogy. Many people come out to mourn, a sign of how many lives Emerence touched.
Afterward, the Lieutenant Colonel and Magda prepare to enter Emerence’s home. Magda seems tense; the Lieutenant Colonel is surprised, since Emerence “loved [her].” He has glimpsed inside the apartment once before, he says, and Magda will likely inherit a set of expensive, ornate furniture. They enter the apartment and move the safe. They reveal the “most beautifully furnished room” (302) that Magda has ever seen. When they enter, however, they discover that the furniture has been destroyed by woodworm. Anything that Magda touches collapses into dust. The reward Emerence received for saving Eva Grossman is ruined, save for a single clock. Magda doesn’t want the clock but takes it home. By the time the cleaners arrive, no furniture is left. By this time, however, Magda is “no longer interested” (304).
Magda notices that Sutu seems to be ostracized from the local community. Magda visits the priest to thank him. When he remarks on the silence, Magda explains that “the silence is a country custom” (305). No one is watching television out of respect for Emerence. Everyone, from every religion, is mourning her, Magda says. The next time Magda goes to church, she notices that Sutu is missing. In the following weeks, Magda learns that the villa will need to hire a caretaker to replace Emerence. Magda speaks to her husband, and he thinks the choice is obvious. Magda is appalled by the idea of hiring Sutu, but her husband points out that Adélka is the natural choice.
Adélka replaces Emerence in the apartment. Magda can’t help but feel that they’re “traitors” for replacing Emerence. She’s tired, depressed, and behind with her work. Her husband encourages her to move through this period of mourning. He points out that she’ll need another housekeeper to help her work. He suggests that she hire Sutu, precisely because (unlike Magda and Emerence) she and Sutu don’t love one another. Sutu will “help [Magda] for the rest of her life” (310) and has no secrets.
In a short final chapter, Magda writes that her dreams are always the same. In her recurring vision, she’s trying to unlock a door while an ambulance waits outside. The key turns, but her “efforts are in vain” (311).
After Magda experiences the emotional high of being permitted to enter Emerence’s home, a spiral of rapidly escalating events occurs. While shoveling snow, Emerence becomes ill. Since she refuses to rest properly, this illness worsens. Eventually, Emerence has a stroke and is stuck inside her house. Emerence’s stubbornness sets other events into motion. She refuses to let anyone else do her work or to show any signs of weakness. Her escalating illness results from the same determination and iron will that have defined her life. Emerence never wants to allow herself to be vulnerable, as she has been hurt too many times. In a tragic coincidence, her most vulnerable moment (allowing Magda into her house) is followed by the unraveling of her world. She’s made vulnerable, the exact condition in which she doesn’t want to be seen, and the exact reason that she feels so betrayed by Magda. Emerence believes that Magda should have “allowed [her] to die” (288), as she would rather be dead than vulnerable. She would rather choose to be dead than be forced to allow the world into her house. In a life that so many people have controlled and affected, resulting in Emerence choosing to harden herself to any form of vulnerability, Magda’s removal of this choice is the greatest betrayal of all. It’s a fate worse than death for Emerence.
For Magda, the problem is equally pronounced. She assures Emerence that she “meant well” by letting the people into her house. She couldn’t let Emerence die alone. Magda gradually comes to understand the reasoning behind Emerence’s desire to die, a frank approach to life and death that mirrors her earlier reaction to Polett’s death by suicide. However, Magda also knows that she isn’t Emerence. She can’t simply allow her friend to die. This realization is terrible for Magda, as it dooms her to inevitable betrayal. She knows that she can’t honor Emerence’s desires, as she lacks the capacity to treat human life with such little concern. Emerence seems to have foreseen this in Magda: Her instruction to euthanize the cats wasn’t only a practical matter but also a reminder to Magda that she must adopt Emerence’s view of the world and harden herself to such sentimentality. Magda doesn’t euthanize the cats; they scatter before she can even consider it, and they likely die anyway, just as she becomes lost to Emerence, who then eventually dies. Events spiral beyond Magda’s control, and the symbolic importance of the door (which once represented the closeness between the two women) becomes a symbol of how different they are, of how Magda betrayed Emerence, and of how death permanently closes the door to forgiveness.
Emerence’s funeral is well-attended, demonstrating the community’s reverence and affection for her. In addition, the turnout underscores the theme of Guilt as Collective Inheritance by signifying the community’s guilt over not finding ways to show their appreciation for Emerence (despite her dogged resistance) while she was alive. Old customs, such as the silence that falls over the neighborhood, are another tribute to the woman. These displays of sentimentality and affection, however, dramatically differ from what Emerence herself might have done, as she was motivated by practical concerns rather than sentimentality. Old traditions and rituals held little sway in her life; the priest’s eulogy was moving for the mourners but ironic in the context of Emerence’s utter contempt for organized religion. This act of community mourning is another illustration of how the community didn’t understand Emerence. For Magda, the one person who might have been able to claim that she knew Emerence, the presumptions and precepts of the past fall away. What she knew about Emerence (and about herself) now seems inconsequential. She can do nothing to atone for her actions, so Emerence’s memory will haunt her for the rest of her life. The dramatically spiraling events altered her life forever, and now, those cherished memories have crumbled away like the woodworm-riddled furniture that Magda inherited from Emerence.



Unlock all 61 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.