The Family Game

Thrillers and mysteries often explore interlocked themes of old-money families, largely innocent outsiders, and dangerous games. Two film examples include Ready or Not and Knives Out. In the former film, a new bride plays a deadly game of hide and seek with her new husband and his wealthy family; in the latter, a kind-hearted caregiver is caught in the middle of the family dynamics of her late wealthy employer as the mystery of his death is revealed. Watch one of these films and compare and contrast plot, characters, and themes.

How does Harriet’s role as a thriller author help her navigate her own thrilling story? Could a non-thriller author have navigated the task laid out by Robert so effectively? Why or why not?

Why is Harriet so attracted to Robert? What larger message is this communicating about legacy and the allure of power? Does Harriet’s attraction speak to Robert’s charm, Harriet’s innate desires, or both?

How does Harriet’s pregnancy impact her characterization? What does a child represent to her, particularly as a person who grew up without a family? How essential, if at all, is Edward to her idea of her new family, both at the beginning and end of the novel?

What does Krampusnacht reveal about the Holbeck family? In your opinion, did Harriet overreact about the game itself, or did she feel in it a warning of what was to come within the Holbeck family? Give evidence to support your claim.

What differences, if any, are there in the kind of murder committed by Harriet and the murders committed by Edward? Consider motivation, execution and premeditation, and guilt. Further, can Robert be considered as aiding in murder by covering up Edward’s crimes, or do you feel he had no choice?

In what specific ways does Steadman use narrative structure to increase tension and urgency throughout the novel? Consider all aspects of form, like chapter structure and notation, and literary elements, like setting.

How does Steadman use red herrings and plot twists to increase tension and urgency throughout the novel? At any point in the novel, did you guess that Edward could be the murderer? If so, what tipped you off, and was this something planned by Steadman? Retrace your thought process and give examples.