The First Time I Saw Him

Laura Dave

51 pages 1-hour read

Laura Dave

The First Time I Saw Him

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2026

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 2, Chapter 19-Part 3, Chapter 27Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of death and graphic violence.

Part 2, Chapter 19 Summary: “The Big Island”

During the five years Owen spends in hiding, he only leaves New Zealand six times. The first time, he goes to the Big Island in Hawaii to send Nicholas an anonymous letter from his favorite hotel, reminding him that it would go against the Organization’s interests for Nicholas to come to harm. The second time, Owen goes to San Francisco on the eve of Bailey’s high school graduation so that he can be near her during this milestone and plant an envelope containing incriminating information on the Organization in Nicholas’s suitcase. Owen intends to entice Nicholas into arranging a meeting with him.


Six months later, Nicholas takes Charlie’s family, Hannah, and Bailey to the hotel on the Big Island. Owen interprets this as an invitation to meet. He calls Nicholas at the hotel from Queen Charlotte Sound to accept the invitation. Nicholas stresses that he is doing it because his love for Hannah and Bailey is greater than his hatred of Owen. He gives Owen instructions to meet in two months.


The meeting takes place at the Big Island hotel. The location evokes Owen’s memories of Kate, who always hoped to take him there. Owen settles into his room and then uses the connecting door to signal to Nicholas that he is ready to meet. Nicholas initially holds Owen at gunpoint, though both of them realize at the same time that if Owen dies, it means that the Organization can kill Hannah and Bailey without fear of repercussions. They start working on their plan together.

Part 2, Chapter 20 Summary: “Someone’s Safe Harbor, Just Not His”

Owen and Nicholas compile every piece of evidence connecting Nicholas to the Organization, including his witness testimony of his interactions with Frank from the very beginning of their collaboration. They also discuss Frank’s six children and the different lives they lead. Quinn and Teddy are their biggest concern because they are poised to succeed Frank when he steps down. Quinn had no interest in joining the Organization until her husband, Wesley, was incarcerated, having been identified in Owen’s testimony as one of Frank’s top lieutenants. She is the most likely to use Hannah and Bailey to take revenge on Owen, though she will rely on Teddy’s heightened cruelty to exact that revenge.


On their last night of planning, Nicholas posits that Hannah may never forgive Owen for disrupting their lives. Owen accepts this; he only cares for her and Bailey’s safety. Nicholas reminds him that the biggest obstacle to their plan is that Frank knows how Nicholas thinks, implying that he might anticipate what Nicholas and Owen have planned.

Part 2, Chapter 21 Summary: “Twenty Years Ago”

The novel flashes back to Quinn’s engagement party. That night, Nicholas informed Frank he would be stepping back from his role as the Organization’s legal counsel, which would give Quinn’s fiancé, Wesley, an opportunity to take his place as a competent early career lawyer. Frank accepted Nicholas’s request out of respect for their friendship, much to the latter’s surprise.

Part 2, Chapter 22 Summary: “Some Secrets Need to Stay Secrets”

Nicholas and Owen brief each other on the plans for Owen’s final trips out of New Zealand. The penultimate trip requires him to pass through several cities in the United States. The final trip will see him visiting Hannah to give her the flash drive before going to see Nicholas.


Nicholas considers it unlikely that both of them will survive their plan. Owen accepts this as well, and the two men part ways.

Part 3, Chapter 23 Summary: “The View from the Eiffel Tower Can Make You Forget”

Back in the present, Nicholas admits that he agreed to work with Owen out of the shared fear that after Nicholas’s death, the Organization would harm Hannah and Bailey to draw out Owen. Though Nicholas does have a heart condition, it offered them a pretext to test whether the Organization would really act on the news of Nicholas’s death. By choosing not to warn Hannah and Bailey of his plan, Nicholas could monitor the Organization for any enforcers dispatched to abduct them.


Nicholas reveals the next phase of his plan: Since Frank is retiring in the French town of Èze, Nicholas plans to surprise him at his next birthday party that weekend. Hannah and Bailey are to remain somewhere safe, but Hannah protests, indicating that it won’t be safe for Nicholas to confront Frank, Quinn, and Teddy alone. She urges Nicholas to let her accompany him to guarantee that everything goes according to plan.


It is then that Nicholas reveals that the man who was following them from the airport was his bodyguard, Seth. Hannah insists on accompanying Nicholas, who looks to Bailey for support. When Bailey does not protest Hannah’s participation, Nicholas relents.

Part 3, Chapter 24 Summary: “Sixteen Years Ago”

The novel flashes back to a dinner meeting between Nicholas and Frank, over a year after Kate was killed by a speeding car. Frank thanked Nicholas for not giving Frank up to the FBI despite Nicholas’s own incarceration. Frank promised Nicholas that he owed him any favor he asked. Nicholas dismissed the idea, believing that Frank was trying to console him over Kate’s death. This felt empty to him given the rumor that Kate’s death was connected to Nicholas’s decision to withdraw from the Organization.


Frank reminded Nicholas that when Jenny died, Nicholas told him to look for purpose instead of joy. That was enough to help Frank through his grief. Nicholas then identified Kristin (Bailey’s given name) as his purpose and asked Frank to recover her from Owen.

Part 3, Chapter 25 Summary: “The Lights Stay On in Paris”

Hannah stays awake that night and reexamines Owen’s flash drive. She reflects on the image of the marine compass, which is supposed to point steadily north when everything else spins out of control. Nicholas gets up and asks Hannah what is on her mind. Hannah believes that something is missing from their plan. She wonders what makes Nicholas sure that the Organization will agree to leave her and Bailey alone. Nicholas indicates that when he confronts the syndicate, it won’t have any other choice. He then promises to tell her something that Owen understood better than anyone else.

Part 3, Chapter 26 Summary: “The Provençal Market Doesn’t Take a Day Off”

Owen bikes from Antibes to Old Town, anticipating a message from Nicholas as he travels. He navigates the busy Provençal market, worried that a police officer may be following him. When Owen stops at a coffee shop, a woman and a man call his attention, asking him to take their photo. Owen indulges them and foregoes coffee. He proceeds to Port Vauban in order to reach a boat.

Part 3, Chapter 27 Summary: “If You Should Lose Your Way…”

Seth drives Nicholas, Hannah, and Bailey to Èze. Hannah reviews the files on Quinn and understands that Quinn blames Owen for Wesley’s incarceration. Nicholas confirms that Wesley was not granted parole during his last hearing, which means he will remain in prison for at least another two years. Nicholas assures her that he and Owen have planned with Quinn in mind, but Hannah believes that they are discounting the fact that Quinn is a wife and mother who wants to protect her family.


Upon reaching Antibes, the group drops Bailey and Seth off at the Musée Picasso. Seth will watch over Bailey from a distance. Bailey bids Nicholas farewell, urging him to take care. Hannah reassures Bailey as they say goodbye.

Part 2, Chapter 19-Part 3, Chapter 27 Analysis

The second part of the novel reveals that Nicholas’s decision to work with Owen is predicated on their shared concern for Bailey and Hannah. Though Owen’s actions resulted in Nicholas’s incarceration, Nicholas stresses that he is willing to overlook his grudge against Owen for Bailey’s sake: “Turns out I love her more than I hate you” (132). This admission implies that love of the same person can drive people to set aside their differences.


Dave echoes this sentiment in Part 3, Chapter 24, as the novel continues its exposition regarding Nicholas and Frank’s friendship. After Kate’s death, Frank reminds Nicholas of what Nicholas told him after Jenny’s death: “You said stop looking for joy anymore because you’re not going to find it. Look for purpose. That will get you through” (163). By identifying Bailey as the purpose at the center of his life, Nicholas inadvertently creates common ground to stand on with Owen. Both of them know that by getting involved with the Organization, they have ruined their chances of any semblance of normalcy in life. What they can both work for, however, is normalcy for Bailey, whom they both love. Dave’s explanation of the marine compass’s purpose—to point the direction when everything goes awry—makes it a symbol of Finding Purpose in Family; it reminds Nicholas, Owen, Frank, and Hannah that they are not living simply for their own joy, but for someone else.


The fact that Frank reiterates this advice points to his sympathy for Nicholas, which implies that he is not the novel’s principal antagonist or threat. The revelation that Frank owes Nicholas a favor introduces the possibility of resolution, as does Nicholas’s plan to confront Frank at the latter’s birthday party. Since it is unlikely that Frank fulfilled Nicholas’s request, it is possible that Nicholas could invoke the favor as a last resort to ensure his granddaughter’s safety. Simultaneously, Dave maintains the narrative tension and conflict by developing Quinn as an antagonist, incorporating exposition that explains her motives for acting against Hannah and her family. These motives frame Quinn as a mirror to Hannah, who believes that she can understand Quinn as a wife and mother: “It’s impossible to consider the lengths a woman will go if she thinks she’s protecting her family” (175). Where Nicholas is confident in his plan, Hannah therefore worries that Quinn is the element he hasn’t accounted for. Even though Nicholas may succeed in appealing to Frank’s mercy, he does not have the experience or the perspective to appeal to Quinn. This drives Hannah’s desire to accompany him to Frank’s birthday party, setting up the elements for the novel’s climax.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 51 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs