62 pages 2-hour read

The Fisherman

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2016

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 2, Chapters 11-21Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes mentions of graphic violence, murder, and suicide.

Part 2: “Der Fischer: A Tale of Terror”

Part 2, Chapter 11 Summary

Lottie much prefers the camp’s bakery to her aunt’s bakery in the Bronx, mainly because her mother is much more relaxed now because she is free from the harsh supervision of Lottie’s aunt. However, the recent supernatural events have shattered Lottie’s worldview and eroded her concentration, and she makes constant mistakes. To keep her out of trouble, her mother sends her on frequent errands. It is when Lottie is on her way to a storage closet to fetch almonds that she has her “encounter” with Helen, who traps her in the closet and closes the door. Alone with Helen’s “spoiled flesh” smell and “blank, pitiless” gold eyes, Lottie feels on the verge of panic. Then she hears Helen’s voice, a hideous, “chuckling” noise that sounds like the language of the dead.


Rather than deciphering it, Lottie “sees” what Helen is describing: a vast black sea without end, which seems to run “under” the world she knows. Lottie also perceives that the black water is “crowded” with human bodies, and one in particular seizes her notice: a corpselike female face, staring, unblinking, “alabaster-white,” with blue lips gasping words out in a “low monotone.” As Lottie listens in horror, the bobbing head describes “the most pornographic of fantasies” (104) about one of her father’s friends. Then the creature moves on to other atrocities: a jealous loathing of her younger sisters, breathless fantasies of hurting and killing them, and of killing herself. With a jolt, Lottie realizes that the floating creature is herself, its sexual fantasies about Italo, her own sisters Gretchen and Christina the objects of its festering hatred.


Peering about, she recognizes her parents, sisters, and other relatives, as well as friends, neighbors, strangers all clustered tightly about her in this rancid sea. They all spew “secret depravities” as egregious as her own, or worse. In this vision, Clara states that she bitterly regrets not sleeping with a tinker who came to call, and Rainer bemoans the “idiots” who surround him. Christina longs to set fire to an irritating dog and its elderly owner. Lottie realizes that “the roar of the ocean […] is the accumulated voices of this multitude, of who knows how many monologues of rage, pain, and frustration” (105). Then she sees a colossal beast coursing through the waves, higher and bigger than the Brooklyn Bridge, its gaping maw lined with teeth as big as houses. Thousands of the floating, murmuring bodies vanish down its titanic throat.


Shocked out of her trance, Lottie fights back against Helen, punching and kicking her and striking her face with a bag of almonds. As Lottie’s mother and others hear her screams and come running, Helen tells the girl gloatingly that “he” is waiting for her. As the women force their way into the closet, Helen vanishes.

Part 2, Chapter 12 Summary

As Rainer rushes home, he wonders if his recent “experiments” with his secret books may have been responsible for Helen’s attack on his daughter Lottie. As he sits on Lottie’s bed, she does not awaken, and her forehead is scorching hot. He tells Clara that Helen has “done violence to a part of Lottie we cannot see or touch” (110). He murmurs a “blessing” to her, which he says will do her some good, but he cautions that the “connections” between Lottie, Helen, and the evil man at the root of it are all vastly complex. Clara tells him coldly that he must do whatever it takes to protect their family, adding that he has wasted too much time already. Rainer fumes at this slight on his knowledge and abilities, which are all-important to him, reflecting, “For her to attack him here, the last bastion of his pride and self-respect, is the kind of betrayal of which only someone you love is capable” (111).

Part 2, Chapter 13 Summary

After his anger calms, Rainer takes his books from their hiding place. Back in Germany, Lottie once spied on her father as he read from one of these: a tall, gray volume secured with a lock. As he opened it, the air in the room darkened, and the book “appeared to be giving off a black light, dimming her father’s face” (112-13). For years afterward, she had nightmares of her father with a “black emptiness” where his face should be.


Now, in her trance, Lottie’s dreams are much worse, trapping her in a claustrophobic darkness with the maggoty face of her “other self” and its litany of hideous fantasies, many of which involve her parents. She is most horrified by the “recognition” that the creature’s words are all true, and that she really has harbored all of these desires. She now feels them with such an intensity that it seems to her as if she has actually acted on them. By this point in her fugue state, her other, normal thoughts and feelings have begun to shut down, and if things do not change, there may soon be nothing left of her but the “horror.”

Part 2, Chapter 14 Summary

The next day, Clara is frightened to notice that Rainer has a strange light in his eyes, an intense but “dead” radiance, like the “cold glare” of lightning. Without a word, he takes a silver dinner knife from the kitchen, goes outside, and carves strange symbols (“swirling arabesques”) on the door of Helen’s house. When Clara looks at the symbols, they writhe like living things. Rainer goes to the rear of the house and repeats the ritual, then throws the knife point-first into the ground in front of the house. His face glowing with an “unearthly light,” he tells Clara that he has made a “box” around Helen, trapping her. This, he says, will help Lottie by throwing a “cloth” over the “mirror” that torments her. He says that he will eventually destroy Helen, but the true source of evil lies elsewhere; Helen was merely a “water thing,” but “the man in the big house” (118) may be a Schwartzkunstler (black magician), in which case he will be difficult to defeat. Clara scoffs at the idea that a sorcerer would be interested in wielding power over an obscure community like theirs. She argues that the man must be just a “dabbler,” like Rainer himself, but her husband cautions her that supernatural beings are often drawn to remote locales for mysterious reasons of their own. Meanwhile, Lottie’s sleep grows more restful. Her father’s incantations have drawn a fog-like curtain over her, protecting her from the worst of the black ocean’s terrors.

Part 2, Chapter 15 Summary

Rainer gathers a group of neighbors to aid him in his mission. Among them are his Italian friend, Italo, and a pair of brothers, Angelo and Andrea. Also accompanying them is a shy young Austrian named Jacob Schmidt, who harbors a romantic interest in Lottie, for which Clara often teases her. After that day’s events, Rainer resolves to overlook his bias against Austrians and accept Jacob into the family.


(Jacob and Lottie will share a long life together, and it is from Jacob that Lottie will learn, decades later, the full truth of the Fisherman, particularly the horrific events of this day. By that time, her father, after a long mental decline due to Alzheimer’s, will be five years dead.)

Part 2, Chapter 16 Summary

Rainer leads his group, armed with axes, up the street to Helen and George’s house. With a pocket knife, he carves three marks into the wooden handle of his axe, then does the same to the other men’s axes. Then he draws the still-vibrating silver dinner knife from the ground in front of the house. Before entering, he warns the men to close their ears to whatever Helen says, as her knowledge of their secrets is her last remaining weapon.


Inside, a thick, black mold covers the floor, walls, and ceiling. Helen stands in the middle of the room in a puddle of dark water that seeps from her skin. Rainer asks Helen who her master is, but she refuses to say, instead telling him to ask “Wilhelm Vanderwort.” Rainer repeats his question, and finally she says, “The Fisherman.” As Rainer continues to question her, Helen says the Fisherman casts his line for “Apep” and that his work is almost done. His ropes, she says, are woven from “the hairs of ten thousand dead men,” and the hooks forged from “the swords of a hundred dead kings” (126). As for whether the Fisherman has “set the lines,” she says, “the near ones” (126), and Rainer looks relieved. He makes a small gesture with his hand, and Helen dissolves into a “fall” of foul water. The men emerge from the house, gasping for air. Rainer says that Helen is “gone” and that it would a “good thing” if her house were burned. The next morning, it bursts into flames, releasing hideous plumes of smoke. A boy who stands too close to the fire dies horribly as toadstool-like lesions burst from his skin. He is the “last fatality” connected with Helen and George.

Part 2, Chapter 17 Summary

As Helen’s house burns, Rainer and his group, having completed their mission to Dort House, stagger back to their homes. After sleeping soundly for a day or two, they rise and tell their families that the danger is now past. However, Andrea soon leaves for parts unknown, while rumor has it that his brother Angelo ran off into the night with a handful of axes, never to be seen again. However, if the villagers were ever told the truth about what happened to Angelo, they likely wouldn’t believe it.

Part 2, Chapter 18 Summary

The narrative backtracks to reveal that immediately after dealing with Helen, Rainer and the others follow the moonlit road to the Station and thence to the big Dort House. On the way, Rainer tells them what he knows of the Fisherman, explaining that in the late 1500s, a young Hungarian left his home in Budapest and traveled much of Europe, seeking arcane knowledge. This young man had married a beautiful Turkish woman, but during his country’s uprising against the Ottomans, his wife and children were slaughtered, reputedly by Hungarian soldiers. In Hamburg, the young Hungarian sought out a scholar of the occult named Heinrich Khunrath, who owned a volume of hermetic lore known as The Secret Words of Osiris. The Hungarian was very interested in this book, thinking it might help him to catch one of the universe’s “Great Powers”—namely, the serpent-like behemoth known in the Bible as the Leviathan. Rainer explains to his companions that this primordial monster is “closer to a god than it is to a devil” (134). Somehow, the Hungarian “won” this magical book from Khunrath. With its help, he now fishes for the Leviathan, hoping to harness some of its vast power and restore his slain family to life. Rainer states that the ocean where the Leviathan lives lies under the skin of the earth, and in some places, “the earth is thinner, the distance to the ocean not so great” (134). Rainer explains that The Fisherman is centuries old and wields the power of Osiris’s book, but this alone cannot make him a full Schwarzkunstler; he can still be defeated.

Part 2, Chapter 19 Summary

As Rainer and his group approach the woods surrounding the Dort House over barren ground stripped and denuded to serve as the floor of the great reservoir, Jacob glimpses a deathly white figure that floats in midair. Aside from its gold eyes and scaled skin, it resembles a human. Impossibly, the space between the trees ripples like dark water, as if the men are staring downward into a lake instead of into a forest. Rainer tells them that here, the “dark ocean” is seeping through. The five of them proceed between the blocks of water, and with a flash of “black light,” Rainer breaks down the door of Dort House with his axe. Making a strange gesture with his outstretched hand, he leads them inside as the “weird radiance” on his face grows stronger.

Part 2, Chapter 20 Summary

The interior of the Dort House is thick with evergreen trees, and the floor seems to be of dirt. Soon they reach a clearing, where a stream of white water gushes through a ravine. As they follow the slope of the ground into the trees, the stream gathers in force, and Jacob fights against panic. His legs weaken like taffy, and he feels “as if there’s a weight hung from his neck, pulling him on” (144). Finally, he falls to his knees, and a strange but oddly familiar noise makes him raise his head. What he sees “chases all thought […] from his mind” (144).

Part 2, Chapter 21 Summary

In the distance, an impossible ocean crashes on a rocky shore. The ocean is dark, as if “made of night” (145). In the midst of the violent waves, something looms: a creature so vast that at first Jacob mistakes it for an island. Darkening the beach are rivulets of blood, dripping from three gigantic golden-skinned animals resembling bulls. The beasts have been decapitated, and their heads are impaled on giant hooks the size of a ship’s anchors. Everywhere on the beach are great coils and stacks of ropes. Close by are massive tree stumps that have been bored with holes and strung with ropes that stretch out to sea. The ropes strum like guitar strings, and Jacob can see many other ropes on the far side of the stream, most of them taut, as if hooked into some titanic beast. Then someone calls to Jacob in German, asking him what he wants. The man has a stringy beard and a boyish face and wears a “rugged apron” drenched in gore. Jacob knows he must be the Fisherman.


At a command from Rainer, Angelo plies his axe against one of the taut ropes. Jacob joins him and feels a tremendous jolt, as if from a lightning bolt, as the rope snaps apart. As he and his companions attack other ropes, making slow but steady progress, the Fisherman dips his bloody knife into the stream, then snaps his arm. A “ball” of water whips into the air and lances toward Angelo, striking him in the throat. As Andrea screams his brother’s name, the water “invades” Angelo’s form, vanishing into him. His body goes rigid, and the eyes bulge from his face.

Part 2, Chapters 11-21 Analysis

The Fisherman’s supernatural “resurrection” of Helen ironically apes Jesus’s raising of Lazarus in the Bible but offers no apotheosis of divine love. Instead, the decayed “water thing” that takes Helen’s form brings only the blackest of revelations, stripping away the consolations of funerals, prayers, and memory itself with the eternal stench of the grave. Insubstantial as water itself, she can vanish into thin air, as if she’s merely a crack in the mask of the world, and her grotesque presence among the living turns The Quiet Horror of Grief into a supernatural abomination. When she corners Lottie in the bakery closet, casting the innocent girl into a volcanic slurry of the dark, unexpressed desires, the reanimated Helen essentially strips away the rational, social “mask” that all humans wear to ensure the continuation of a rational society. Thus, “Helen’s” primal assault on Lottie, a vulnerable child, vastly raises the stakes of the Fisherman’s demonic menace. His malevolent flood of “truth,” which he uses to feed off of his victims, threatens to drown the Ashokan camp far more deeply than the imminent reservoir ever could.


Now, lost in Helen’s black ocean, Lottie sees the fetid underbelly of everyday inner-life, experiencing a virulent, undiluted form of sibling rivalries and hatreds that would otherwise remain suppressed and largely unexpressed. With these darker urges stoked to a lethal level, she also perceives other aspects of her existence corrupted by the Fisherman’s foul visions, as when her mother’s warmth is twisted into adulterous lust. Lottie’s harrowing glimpse behind the “masks” of polite society will ultimately leave her wiser but much sadder, like Coleridge’s “wedding guest” In keeping with Langan’s folkloric theme, Rainer compares Lottie’s trancelike state to Snow White’s, but in this case, the metaphorical poison apple lodged in her throat is more like the biblical Eve’s, as the girl is forced to reckon with truths far beyond her comprehension. Crucially, however, her glimpse of the “truth” is not the full truth but a distorted one in which only the most vile, shameful feelings rise to the top. Lottie’s resiliency in surviving this terrible knowledge, and then going on to live a long, wholesome life makes her one of the novel’s strongest-willed characters.


As a result of Helen’s perpetuation of dark “truths,” Rainer’s own haunted past and his dabbling in the occult now taint his American life, for in order to destroy Helen, he must once again resort to his grimoires and succumb, at least in part, to The Corrupting Allure of Forbidden Knowledge. In his final confrontation with Helen, she invokes the name of Wilhelm Vanderwort, a name that will later be revealed to be freighted with guilt for Rainer. Although the significance of this name is not yet clear, Helen’s invocation of it suggests that there is no escaping one’s past, since the black ocean of human frailty is the same everywhere. Significantly, Helen refers to the biblical Leviathan as “Apep,” the ancient Egyptian god of chaos, and this connection hints at the synchronicity of human beliefs and terrors across multiple cultures and eras.


Notably, the novel also implies that both history and mythology repeat themselves. When Rainer tells his companions about the violent deaths of the Fisherman’s wife and children, it is clear that this tragedy bears a significant resemblance to Dan’s own family catastrophe in the present-day narrative. This parallel foreshadows developments in later chapters, when Dan will undertake his own guilt-fueled quest to “restore” his family by colluding with the Fisherman at Dutchman’s Creek. Additional thematic parallels can be found in the fact that Abe, too, has lost a wife, and in this context, his nightmare of hooking Marie’s golden-eyed double bears significant similarities to the fish-eyed “water things” of Howard’s tale. However, “Marie’s” words to him in his dream—“What’s lost is lost” (33)—suggest Abe’s acceptance of a stoical wisdom that his friend Dan chooses to ignore, and Abe’s willingness to accept the inevitability of death thus foretells a kinder, less Ahab-esque fate for him at Dutchman’s Creek.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 62 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs