62 pages • 2-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Background
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Book Club Questions
Tools
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of death and child death.
The Dy-Dee doll is a symbol of transferred trauma and the violent destruction of innocence. Far more than a simple clue, the doll acts as a physical incarnation of Iris Stafford’s physical and psychological pain, becoming a key that links Walter Wilkinson’s murder in 1944 directly to the tragedy at the Claremont Hotel in 1930. The doll’s symbolic weight is established early through Isabella’s fragmented memory: “My Dy-Dee doll died twice. Once when I snapped her head off…and once under the sun lamp trying to get warm, she melted” (7). This childhood recollection foreshadows the dual tragedies of the novel. The doll’s first “death” represents a simple act of childish anger, but the second, a melting under intense heat, evokes the immense pressure that destroyed the Bainbridge family from within. The doll found in Wilkinson’s closet is not just any toy; it is a meticulously altered effigy of Iris. Its melted left foot mirrors Iris’s own foot since she had polio as a child, and a deep groove carved into its arm matches the location of bruises on Iris’s body, suggesting a deliberate and sinister transference of pain. The doll becomes a vessel for Iris’s identity and trauma, and it is a relic that Wilkinson kept for 14 years. Its presence in his closet hints that his murder was likely not a political assassination but a deeply personal reckoning, proving that the secrets of the past do not stay buried and that trauma, like the doll itself, can be inherited.
The Claremont Hotel is the novel’s central symbol, representing the glamorous, shimmering façade of high society that conceals deep-seated corruption, violence, and moral decay. Described as an “alabaster palace,” the hotel seems to float above the grit and poverty of the Berkeley flatlands, a world unto itself reserved for the privileged. For characters like Al Sullivan, who grew up in the “unsightly spots” across the bay, the hotel embodies the social and racial “suspicion line” that he must cross to succeed (97).
However, the novel reveals that the world inside the Claremont is far more rotten than the one outside. It is a place where wealth and status provide a cover for the darkest human impulses. The narrative underscores that the economic devastation of the Depression was not an “equal opportunity wrecking ball,” as the California rich “packed into luxurious hotels like the shimmering white Claremont, hobnobbing with Barrymore and Garbo, dancing to Count Basie’s orchestra and Louis Armstrong’s trumpet” (10). This image of a lavish escape is sharply contrasted with the brutal realities that the hotel conceals: Sadie’s adulterous affair with Wilkinson, the violent death of their daughter Iris, and Wilkinson’s own gruesome murder 14 years later. The novel reveals that the hotel’s gleaming white exterior is a lie. It is a carefully constructed illusion of purity and order that hides the tragic, messy secrets of the families, like the Bainbridges, who treat it as their playground.
The recurring motif of hooded figures reinforces the theme of The Unreliability of History and Memory by highlighting concealed identities and the deceptive nature of appearances. Danger and guilt, the novel suggests, often lurk beneath a disguise of piety or normalcy. The motif first appears in Isabella’s childhood memory of the day Iris died, when she recalls seeing a mysterious “hooded man who delivered honey” in the hotel basement (6), a detail that infuses the traumatic event with a sense of hidden menace. This image of a disguised threat echoes throughout the investigation into Wilkinson’s murder. Witnesses report seeing a man in a monk’s habit leaving the Claremont around the time of the killing, leading Sullivan to the Abbey of St. Andrew and the unsettling, silent Brother Gratian. This connection between a religious disguise and the crime scene suggests that evil can masquerade as holiness. The motif culminates in Mrs. Bainbridge’s confession, when she reveals her own disguise: “As I had so many years ago, I slipped in that night through a back door of the Claremont Hotel, in my monk’s cassock” (356). By donning the monk’s habit to commit murder, Mrs. Bainbridge became the ultimate embodiment of the motif. The source of the novel’s violence is not an external villain but the family matriarch herself, cloaked in a costume of religious devotion that allowed her to move through the world unseen and unsuspected.



Unlock the meaning behind every key symbol & motif
See how recurring imagery, objects, and ideas shape the narrative.