43 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Lakshmi starts her personal narrative by saying, “Independence changed everything. Independence changed nothing” (18). This comment encapsulates the struggle of India to define itself after the British returned control to the natives in the late 1940s. The novel itself takes place in 1955 while the country is still struggling with the concept of democracy rather than hereditary rule.
The novel shows these struggles on a personal and national scale. Economically, India faced the challenge of modernizing its economy while resisting the imposition of Western capitalist models. India opted for a mixed economy with strong state intervention, which was inspired by socialist principles rather than Western capitalism. However, the need for modernization meant that India had to engage with Western nations economically, leading to a complex relationship where the country sought to adopt modern technology and industrial practices without fully embracing Western economic ideologies. Lakshmi exemplifies these large-scale issues in her own life with her dream of owning a luxurious house and living a prestigious lifestyle. These are capitalist goals that would have been difficult for many to achieve at the time, especially a woman.
The tension between traditional cultural values and Western influence plays out in a variety of other ways in the story. Lakshmi herself is a walking contradiction. She makes her living through one of the most traditional forms of Indian folk art—henna painting. While this skill allows her to create an independent life for herself, she is consumed by guilt over her abandonment of her parents. Her entire family is shamed by her misdeeds and made to suffer by the narrow-minded villagers of Ajar, to whom filial piety is the ultimate virtue.
Lakshmi’s sister also embodies the contradiction between past and present, East and West. She was born in a rural area but quickly adapts to life in the big city with its new Western tastes in food, clothing, and entertainment. She reads European novels and watches American films. These movies tend to emphasize spunky heroines who epitomize the value of romantic love. This perspective is completely at odds with Indian values that place obedience to one’s family above all else.
The social elite in Jaipur embrace Western tastes unabashedly. They send their sons to English universities, engage French cooks, and teach their daughters the foxtrot. At the same time, they hire Lakshmi to create mandalas in their courtyards for Hindu religious festivals. It appears that their adoption of all things European is only skin deep since the customs and values of the country remain unchanged at the core.
Lakshmi’s life story examines the changing role of women in Indian society in the 1950s. She lives at a time when women’s independence is an uneasy notion for most. She begins her adventure by running away from an abusive husband. This action would be unthinkable to most Indian women of her generation, especially those from a rural background like hers. This is due to the collective sense of identity that pervades traditional culture, especially as it concerns women. As mothers and caretakers, women were seen to belong entirely to those in their families, including their parents, children, and husbands. Any personal choice that challenges one of those categories could ruin the entire family’s reputation.
Lakshmi compounds her rebellion by setting herself up in business and succeeding. Financial independence is yet another violation of Indian traditions, and though Lakshmi is independent, she isn’t immune to the psychological repercussions of stepping out of a traditional female role. She is overcome with guilt for turning her back on her parents. In effect, she is turning her back on her entire culture and seeks to make amends by building a fine new house for her family to expunge her shame.
Perhaps the greatest violation of the traditional female role is to claim ownership of one’s own body. As Lakshmi herself explicitly states at more than one point in the novel, a woman becomes her husband’s property: “But I also knew that as soon as I married, I would become jaaya—my husband taking birth in my womb in the form of future children. And once there were children, there would be no more I or me, only we and them” (162). Lakshmi decides to forgo motherhood, which is one of the foundational aspects of female identity in patriarchal societies. Women in such societies who do not have children are seen as violating the social order and are stigmatized if not outcast. Lakshmi knows what she is risking by leaving her husband, but her sense of self-preservation is too strong to submit to a situation she knows could destroy her.
Because she learned herbalism from her mother-in-law, Lakshmi knows how to prevent pregnancies as well as to encourage them. She has seen firsthand the physical and emotional toll that too many pregnancies can take on a woman. Her contraceptive sachets give women some control over when they conceive and when to avoid conception. Despite the fact that Samir buys these sachets of cotton root bark for his mistresses to avoid complications while pursuing his amorous activities, they still provide a safety measure for women whom society would otherwise label immoral. Lakshmi is thus able to share a limited measure of her hard-won independence with her fellow women.
Because Indian society in the 1950s was highly structured and stratified, the individual was expected to suppress any desire for personal freedom in favor of the will of the family and larger culture. This set of values was in place for centuries, and Indian independence did not immediately transform the citizens of the country into free, self-actualizing agents. British colonization compounded traditional Indian values, infusing Indian society with Victorian morals that reinforced the moral constraints surrounding women’s behavior and social roles. Both Indian and British societies were patriarchal, empowering men to live relatively free from social judgment, especially in matters of sexuality, as long as heteronormative standards were maintained.
The Henna Artist explores the concept of personal choice when it collides with tradition. Both Lakshmi and Radha are rebels. Ironically, they are rebelling from opposite ends of the spectrum over the same issue: having children. While still living in her village, Lakshmi saw firsthand the horrors of unwanted pregnancies. She administered contraceptives to herself to prevent having any of Hari’s children. Later, she helps other women avoid being forced into motherhood. The choice she granted herself, she now extends to others.
In contrast, Radha is very young and holds a romanticized notion of motherhood and a happy nuclear family. These ideas come from the West. In India, if one marries a man, one marries his entire family as well. Because she doesn’t understand how difficult life would be for a 13-year-old mother, she glosses over the hardships and insists that she should be allowed to choose motherhood.
Lakshmi is old enough to understand that all choices come with consequences and that Radha’s choice of motherhood would have disastrous repercussions for her future. In the case of both women, the choices they make only carry hard consequences because of the restrictive conditions of their culture. Women are viewed as the property of a man and the means to increase his progeny. To choose pregnancy freely is a threat to that power structure. Lakshmi is beaten by Hari because she remains unable to conceive. Seeing this as a natural failing (Hari does not know she uses contraceptives), he blames her for being a flawed woman. Radha would be ostracized and likely forced to live as a sex worker if she became pregnant without a lawful husband. For both sisters, making an independent choice proves that motherhood should be a woman’s choice rather than her destiny.



Unlock every key theme and why it matters
Get in-depth breakdowns of the book’s main ideas and how they connect and evolve.