The Icebound Land

John Flanagan

57 pages 1-hour read

John Flanagan

The Icebound Land

Fiction | Novel | Middle Grade | Published in 2005

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

The Tension Between Personal Loyalty and Loyalty to Country

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of physical abuse, emotional abuse, and addiction.


While little of the narrative takes place in Araluen as a setting, the country still forms a vital component of each protagonist’s identity, shaping their actions and choices both negatively and positively. Halt’s choice to betray his king to save Will demonstrates a dramatic change in his character: Prior to this point, he has been characterized as non-traditional but deeply loyal to the throne, but his love for Will leads him to value his protégé’s life and safety over his duties to his country. The novel argues that individual loyalty, motivated by love, is far more valuable than loyalty to one’s country, although the latter is still necessary to create a functioning system in which to keep people safe in the first place.


Halt’s love for Will is strong enough to cause him to risk permanent banishment. Tellingly, all of Halt’s friends in powerful positions, including Crowley and King Duncan, are confused about why Halt would betray everything he has been loyal to for years seemingly without cause. Their refusal to acknowledge Halt’s obvious reasoning demonstrates that they have suppressed individual love in favor of loyalty to their positions. Although dramatic, Halt’s actions are direct and deliberate throughout the opening of the novel; he tries all methods to free himself from his obligations without betraying his loyalty to the kingdom, and he only resorts to treason when the King refuses to acknowledge his desire to save Will at all. In choosing his loyalty to Will over his loyalty to Araluen, Halt refuses to be dehumanized by the system he serves. King Duncan’s refusal to treat Halt as a friend—since the King needs Halt to be a cog in the machine of the Ranger Corps—spells the end of Halt’s loyal obedience. Halt is still internally loyal to his country, despite his actions, but he refuses to allow his personal love and loyalty to Will to go unnoticed.


The novel does not condemn Crowley’s and Duncan’s choices, although they are shown to be somewhat unfeeling toward Will and Evanlyn’s desperate plight. In contrast to Deparnieux, a warlord who prioritizes his own power above all, these leaders are loyal to the greater good of the kingdom. Crowley and Duncan wish to protect the entire country, even if it comes at the expense of individuals like Will and Evanlyn. By contrast, Halt’s willingness to throw everything away to protect Will demonstrates the strength of his personal loyalty. Prior to Will, Halt had given everything he had to protecting Araluen; after Will entered his life, however, his priorities changed. Halt’s loyalty to Araluen is now contingent on Will’s safety, but his capacity for loyalty remains unchanged.

The Dehumanizing Effects of Power

There are three major centers of power in the novel, each based in a different country: Araluen’s king, Skandia’s system of jarls and the Oberjarl, and Gallica’s cruel baronies, with Deparnieux serving as their representative. These power centers all serve as generalized antagonists to the protagonists: Halt faces off against Araluen to save Will, Will and Evanlyn suffer under the system of slavery in Skandia, and Lord Deparnieux threatens Halt, Horace, and everyone in his barony. Each of these systems of government casually dehumanizes those under it, no matter how good any intentions are, demonstrating that systemic power has a dehumanizing effect on both the powerful and those they rule.


The settings of Gallica and Skandia parallel each other, demonstrating how power operates in similarly dehumanizing ways across superficially different systems. Skandians rely on enslaved labor to run their society; it is unclear how widespread the practice is, but most of the enslaved people appear to have been claimed through raids or warfare and forced into service. Gallica, meanwhile, does not have slavery in a formal sense, but Halt describes how farmers are pressed into military service at random, and the servants in Deparnieux’s household have no freedom to leave or seek other employment even though their lives are at constant risk to his cruel whims. In both situations, the ruling class (the Skandians or the barons) benefits from the suffering of an oppressed class (the enslaved people or the peasants). Those with the power to change the system have no motivation to do so, while those who are motivated to change the system are deprived of power. By conceptualizing those they oppress as less than fully human, the ruling classes maintain their power without guilt.


This dehumanization, however, takes many different forms throughout the book. Araluen’s system is the least oppressive: The King treats the Rangers as pieces on his chessboard, but he still deals with them fairly and justly, even if he does not recognize their individual needs and desires against the needs of the kingdom. At the other end of the spectrum, Deparnieux is deliberately cruel and vindictive, dehumanizing and torturing his victims for no reason other than his own satisfaction. While oppressive systems in Araluen and even in Skandia can be justified as necessary for social cohesion, Deparnieux has no values beyond his own personal power. As such, he embodies the danger of power for its own sake. He dehumanizes others without purpose or meaning, and he is thus presented as the most violent and malevolent figure in the book. Despite this apparent difference, Deparnieux is not meaningfully distinct from the book’s other rulers—he simply shows what power looks like without the fig leaf of an ideology to cover its violence. No matter how theoretically “positive” these systems are intended to be, they all rely on the sacrifice and suffering of others to function, even if they protect others in the process.

Community as a Resource for Survival

The strength and power of the individual is extremely important to the novel’s thematic development, as all four characters—but Will and Evanlyn in particular—are put through survival situations that test their ability to withstand suffering, pain, and harsh conditions. Will and Evanlyn are foils to each other in the development of this theme: Both are tough and stubborn, but Will eventually goes through too much and cracks under the pressure, while Evanlyn learns to be stronger than she thought possible and keeps them both alive. This demonstrates that while people have an immense capacity to survive situations far beyond what they might think is possible, survival depends on community.


Will’s capacity to survive is first presented as stronger than Evanlyn’s; as a Ranger, he is resourceful by training and spends the first few chapters trying to find a way to escape and ensure their survival and freedom. Evanlyn resists these attempts, preferring to rely on her position as the Princess to save her. While neither approach is condemned as a method of survival, neither character is thinking communally. By focusing on their survival as individuals, they damage their chances. When the situation changes due to the Vallasvow, they have to rely on each other again, but once more, Will takes charge of the situation and fails. While Evanlyn might not have known about the skiff’s missing bung, Will’s reluctance to involve Evanlyn in his planning—and his assumption that his skills are superior—puts them both at risk. Will’s independence and determination leads to his downfall since the system of slavery must break him to make him useful, resulting in his addiction to warmweed, which is deliberately imposed on him by his captors. Will’s isolation from community directly contributes to the dire situation: Once captured, he has no support except from people who want to enslave him further by destroying his health and personality.


Evanlyn’s capacity to survive shines when she must support Will instead of relying on him for support. Evanlyn’s escape through the snow and subsequent survival through the winter in the remote cabin in the mountains demonstrates that community and the desire to help others is key to finding the strength to go on. Evanlyn’s determination to save Will’s life when he is incapable of returning the favor creates community between them, contrasting with Will’s single-minded determination to escape at the book’s opening. Evanlyn survives because she is thinking of them both; Will’s attempt fails because he is too reliant on his own abilities. While the book never portrays Will as a bad or selfish person for this, it is clear through the development of the plot that Evanlyn succeeds because she sees herself and Will as a team rather than two people incidentally thrown together by tragedy.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock every key theme and why it matters

Get in-depth breakdowns of the book’s main ideas and how they connect and evolve.

  • Explore how themes develop throughout the text
  • Connect themes to characters, events, and symbols
  • Support essays and discussions with thematic evidence