52 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of graphic violence, death, and racism.
A few weeks later, Weybridge and Libby collect apples from a grove near the house. He feels physically improved and is happy to be up and about on the crutches Joseph made him. At one point, he feels soft ground underfoot; immediately, Libby is there for support. The romantic tension between them increases as she touches his arm.
Later, a Confederate lieutenant, Darcy Sears, arrives and addresses Sally, wanting to search the premises. He claims there is a rumor in the neighborhood that a Yankee officer was left behind in the area and may be in hiding. Sally runs to fetch Libby from the mill. Weybridge hears Sears from the bedroom and quickly plots how to best strike the man with the water pitcher.
Libby comes quickly from the mill and cheerfully introduces herself to Sears. She graciously shows him through every room. Weybridge hides behind the bedroom door, ready to hit the man and fight for his gun, but Libby insists Sears stay in the doorway, since it is her private bedroom. Sears looks into the room and leaves, since the search has come up dry. Before he goes, Libby wants to know who implicated her, but Sears will not say.
Weybridge and Libby sit on the porch in the evening. Their subtle flirtation and discussion turn to the topic of guns, and Libby admits she has a Colt. She will not tell him where it came from; he agrees to show her how to load it.
The next day, Norton checks on Weybridge. Weybridge mentions the visit from Sears and wonders if Norton knows anything about the rumor of a Yankee officer. Norton, offended, insists he is a trustworthy man, unlike all Yankees, including Weybridge, who are “a people without honor” (205).
Weybridge shows Libby how to load the Colt, and she convinces him that she is ready for target practice on barrel staves. He coaches her through firing; she insists on emptying the chamber. Some are a direct hit, and Libby is pleased with her “natural” talent.
Weybridge begins to feel a more distracting infatuation with Libby. He loves his wife deeply, though, and understands himself well enough to know that just weeks ago, an interest in someone else would have been “beneath him.” He wants to keep himself busy on the farm by helping Joseph, and they decide he will help with the firewood for winter.
While helping Joseph, Weybridge mentions his distrust of Doc Norton. Joseph does not think the culprit is Norton and suggests there are others in the area who might be Libby’s enemies, resenting her influence on her husband’s freeing the people enslaved by his father. Joseph shares that Peter’s father sold one of his (Joseph’s) sons. Joseph also suggests that if Weybridge has any intention of “coming between” Libby and Peter, Joseph will chase Weybridge away himself. Weybridge is mortified and offers a “croaked” rebuttal that he is married.
Weybridge and Joseph approach the house in the wagon and see two uniformed soldiers talking to Sally. Weybridge hides in the woods, and Joseph continues towards the house. Lieutenant Henry Morgan and a corporal are rude to Sally and Joseph, insisting they are lying about not knowing of any Yankees hiding nearby.
They tell Joseph to stay in the wagon while they search the mill and Joseph and Sally’s home. Sally asks to get her bread from the oven, and when Morgan permits her to do so, she races upstairs and hides evidence of Weybridge. Downstairs, she fetches Weybridge’s papers from the top of the cabinet where Libby hid them. She is shocked to discover the guns and powder Libby has been hoarding. The search turns up nothing, and Morgan and the man leave, disgusted.
That evening, Weybridge and Libby sit out on the porch again. Libby is enjoying their discussion until Weybridge brings up leaving. He does not want to endanger them any longer. The prospect of Weybridge leaving dims Libby’s spirits. She insists Peter is dead, admits she murdered three men, and reveals she has more guns. She loses control emotionally and allows herself to be embraced by Weybridge.
The next morning, Libby regains control. She announces to Joseph, Sally, and Jubilee that Weybridge thinks he should leave. Joseph shares his idea for safely getting Weybridge to Harper’s Ferry and the Yankee garrison there: Joseph will build a coffin to hide Weybridge in. Weybridge will take one of the Colts, and Libby will travel in the wagon with another Colt. Like Libby, Jubilee is dejected that the Jackal is leaving. Sally asks who the dead person will be. Libby cynically says she will kill someone.
Weybridge helps Joseph build the coffin. He asks Joseph what will happen to them once he is gone. Joseph says he thinks the Yankees will burn the Valley. He believes they will survive, but no one in Berryville will take kindly to Libby again, even if she is a widow, because they think she prompted her husband to free enslaved people. Joseph also explains he tends to the mill and helps feed the Confederacy because he thinks those actions are helping to keep them all safe.
Smoke in the air alerts them. They start for the house and discover Libby burning all Peter’s clothes. She says that she is certain he is dead and tells them to finish the coffin.
Libby wakes to lightning and thunder and looks outside. She sees a man knock on Sally and Joseph’s door. She thinks he is an escaping enslaved person; this shocks her, as she had always thought “she knew what occurred on this property. Her property” (250). Jubilee wakes, sees the man, and heads out to investigate. Libby follows, and Weybridge goes too.
The man is Clark, an enslaved man at Leveritt Covington’s farm. He is there to warn them that Henry Morgan is bringing some of Mosby’s men within the hour to find the Yankee and hang him, then lynch Sally and Joseph. Covington told them not to hurt Libby. Libby is grateful to Clark and sends him away. She tells Weybridge she is sick of being bullied, that it is her property, and that she “will not go quietly” (254). She reminds them of the guns and tells Weybridge, “Deploy your troops” (254).
Notable juxtapositions in this section serve to highlight the increasing pace of Libby’s and Weybridge’s changing character arcs. The section opens with several victories for Libby and Weybridge—there are enough apples for pies, Weybridge can navigate on his crutches, and Libby’s quick thinking outdoes Sears’s intentions. These are juxtaposed, however, against misses and missteps in the latter half of the section, including a closer call with Morgan’s intrusion, Weybridge’s incorrect assumption about Norton’s trustworthiness, and Libby’s drastic decision to burn her husband’s clothes. Whereas the celebratory moments early in the chapter seem to offer a brief reprieve from their worries and the weariness of war, the later ones demonstrate an inability to control their fates: Weybridge is stranded in the woods when Morgan comes, and Libby is not home; Weybridge still doubts Norton’s honesty but realizes he has no choice but to let the man slander his honor; Libby is weary of wondering about Peter and feels the only respite is to declare him dead herself. These defeats stand out in contrast to their earlier victories and mark the onset of the influence of desperation in their decision-making, which will impact each character’s actions, revelations, and outcomes in the rest of the novel.
These chapters also develop the increasingly soft and private side of Libby, who is, at the beginning of the novel, all business. Some of her happiest moments come in this section, when she is alone with Weybridge on the porch after the others go to bed; their conversations represent to her not only a distracting flirtation but also a reminder that her life may not be forever devoid of romance and a relief that she is not the only decision-maker in the house. Libby is a solid authority figure and wisely and considerately evaluates decisions for Jubilee, Sally, Joseph, the mill, the animals, and everyone’s future. Once Weybridge arrives, though, she allows him to be a sounding board and a confidante. In these roles, he helps to alleviate her stress, and her mind and emotions are lightened enough to enjoy their late-night moments together. How deeply she has come to depend on his companionship is revealed when he says he must leave, and her ensuing dark mood contrasts sharply with her previous lightheartedness as she snaps back into her former stoicism.
This scene is the first and only time that Libby loses emotional control. She spills her secrets and lets Weybridge embrace her. This moment forces a brief battle in Libby in which she must decide how Weybridge’s presence and her own decision to harbor him will impact her identity. Having never doubted her own Moral Decisions Amid Societal Collapse, she does not doubt them now; she chooses strength, and the next morning, she spearheads the plan to get him to Harper’s Ferry, once more serving as the general of her household.
However, Libby also illustrates how she has grown through her willingness to share the decision-making with Weybridge, recognizing his expertise in planning and strategy. She directs him to plot the fast strategy for battle as Morgan descends upon them. Her short speech in that moment is significant: When Libby says she is tired of being bullied, it is not the Union to whom she refers but the Confederate soldiers, those supposedly on her own side. Her rebellious uprising against Morgan is the strongest example of Civilian Resilience Under Military Authority in the novel, as her own small force goes into battle against a military group.
The section includes a significant moment of foreshadowing as well. As Libby and the others devise their plan for the trip to get Weybridge safely away—a scene that develops the theme of Humanizing the Enemy Through Shared Vulnerability since his escape jeopardizes them all—Sally pointedly asks two times who they will say is dead if they are stopped, but no one actually offers a realistic answer. The unanswered question foreshadows Sally’s death in the last section.



Unlock all 52 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.