54 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of substance use, death by suicide, graphic violence, child abuse, child death, and death.
During her years of planning, Carolyn daydreamed about how she and Steve would spend their time together. However, he’s been in the Library dormitories for over a month now and mostly just gets drunk, plays video games, and plays with Naga. He tries to convince her to make the new sun give off light, but she says she can’t. Steve went on a hunting trip in the Serengeti with Naga and is learning to speak the language of lions. Naga addresses Steve as “My Lord Hunter” and says it’s been foreseen that he’ll save them all (324).
News reports from Earth show a huge object spinning in the sky that appears to be the shadow of a pyramid. Carolyn tells Steve she projected the Library into normal space with the command “project and defend” (327). The military is preparing to bomb the pyramid, but Carolyn says it can’t harm them. She makes the Library walls transparent, and she and Steve watch the bombing like it’s a fireworks show. Steve admits he knew about the bombing plan from Erwin. He feels like he conspired to murder her, but Carolyn already knew this and isn’t angry.
Steve describes all the horrible things happening on Earth because of her—earthquakes, famine, riots, mass killings, and more, all of which she hasn’t noticed. He says that he’s been trying to get through to her, but things like “fear, hope, [and] compassion” don’t seem to register (331). He acknowledges that Carolyn had to close herself off to survive her childhood and says there’s only one part of her heart that isn’t frozen, her heart coal. He douses himself in alcohol, begs Carolyn to have compassion on the world, and lights himself on fire. Naga keeps Carolyn from intervening, and Steve dies quickly.
Carolyn resurrects Steve, but he keeps dying by suicide. Eventually, she gives up and leaves him dead. A month later, she happens upon a note Father left, directing her to a text in the Library called “An Assortment of Useful Elixirs,” specifically its chapter titled “The Font of Perfect Memory” (339). Carolyn makes and uses the elixir to remember the details of “Adoption Day.”
It was Labor Day, 1977, and everyone in Garrison Oaks thought Father was a regular man named Adam Black. On their way to the neighborhood picnic, Carolyn and her parents stop to socialize with Adam as he grills in his backyard. In their conversation, which Carolyn hadn’t understood at the time and had since forgotten, Adam indicates that he’s chosen her as his successor.
At the picnic, Carolyn catches up with her good friend, Steve. His father recently died in a car accident, but his mother survived. Steve gives Carolyn his copy of Black Beauty. Suddenly, they see a bomb dropping from above. Adam invokes alshaq shabboleth, which makes him and the children move so fast that time seems to slow down.
In the children’s minds, Father’s voice says to take shelter behind him at the top of the hill and live. Their speed causes so much friction, however, that running is unbearably painful and creates flames. Steve makes it to safety in time, but Carolyn falls. Steve goes back and saves her but must move fast to do so and gets severely burned. The bomb kills everyone except Father and 13 children.
The children don’t yet know Pelapi, but Father uses the language to tell David that he will make him a monster, the thing Carolyn will fear and conquer. Also, in Pelapi, he says Margaret will serve as Carolyn’s final warning. He tells Steve that he must send him away, then adds in Pelapi that he will be the coal of Carolyn’s heart so that she can be sustained by the memory of him. As the children follow Father into the Library, he says to Carolyn, in Pelapi, that he’ll make her into a god.
Carolyn works for three weeks to resurrect Father. She apologizes for murdering him. He says he’s proud of her and acknowledges that she’s in charge now, not him. She asks what she should do about Steve, because although he has compassion for her, he doesn’t care for her like he did when they were children.
Father summarizes three options, two of which are ways for Carolyn and Steve to be together. She could change the past so that Steve is Pelapi, along with her, from the beginning. He would have to suffer everything that she and the other librarians did. She could also change the past so that she and Steve both grew up together as normal Americans. This would mean abdicating power. The third option is to let go of the idea of her and Steve being together.
Father tells Carolyn that he didn’t create the universe, and after studying it all this time, he is no closer to understanding it. He’s decided to start his own universe with his own rules. He’ll take Nobununga and Mithraganhi, whom he’s resurrected, with him. He also reveals that David is his biological son and had been his intended heir.
Father then gives Carolyn a text with instructions for altering the past. In nine other versions of the past, Carolyn learns, she studied the catalog of murder and war, and she was the one burned alive in the bull. Father made her into a monster to test David, but David never defeated her. Finally, Father chose Carolyn to succeed him instead. Now, Father declares the fourth age officially over and says that he and Carolyn will never see each other again.
Carolyn resurrects Steve and tells him she’s going to put everything back the way it was—she had already let David die a few hours ago. She says Steve is the reason she’s fixing everything, meaning that he saved everyone. She speaks the word that suspends Steve outside of time and places him in the sky as the new sun, one that burns bright because of his connection to the plane of joy.
Carolyn leaves the Library and goes to a farmhouse in Oregon. There, she finds Michael, who secretly escaped Mrs. McGillicutty’s house. He and his wolves join Carolyn inside, and together, they all watch the new sun rising. The sun’s angle means that it’s spring, but in the librarian’s calendar, it’s the time of the second moon, which is also called the moon of kindled hope.
Erwin has been in prison for 10 years because he wanted the government to bomb Garrison Oaks, and he took the president hostage to make it happen. He doesn’t mind prison. Many of the guards are fans of his, and Dashaen, now wealthy, puts money in his commissary account every month.
One night, Carolyn appears in his cell, accompanied by Michael. She tells Erwin that he blew up Mount Char, then explains that was what she and Steve nicknamed Father’s house when they were kids, and he lived in Garrison Oaks as Adam Black. Carolyn wants Erwin to work for her. She’ll get him out of prison either way, she says, but if he works for her, she can teach him very interesting things.
They hear a commotion and screams outside his cell. Carolyn says Father’s enemies are now her enemies; they are coming for her, so she has to get going. Erwin agrees to go with her and take the job. He asks how dangerous her enemies are, and Carolyn urges him not to worry, saying she has a plan.
Irony is prevalent in the text’s final chapters, especially in the revelations from Carolyn’s “Adoption Day” memory. The fact that Father intended for Carolyn to succeed him and even set her on the path to overthrow him exactly as she did is a major plot twist. It significantly changes how Carolyn views herself, Father, the knowledge and power she’s attained, and her responsibilities in her new position. This information recontextualizes everything that has occurred in the narrative thus far, further complicating The Succession Conflict and Parallels to Greek Mythology. The irony of this revelation lies in how the narrative, until this point, has emphasized the idea of Carolyn being in total control. Her meticulous planning for 10 years seemed to be her agenda, driven by ambition, suffering, and a desire for revenge. However, her plan is shown to be merely a part of Father’s larger plan. He prepared things with such precision and manipulated every detail so deftly that Carolyn believed the plan was her own. He even spoke to the children in Pelapi on “Adoption Day,” though they didn’t know the language, because he knew Carolyn would one day review the memory and understand. Father’s actions reflect a high level of intelligence and foresight, reinforcing his known character traits. What this reveals about his intentions, however, profoundly complicates his characterization.
Smaller details from this scene also use irony to develop thematic ideas. Michael is almost always portrayed in the nude because he’s adopted the ways of animals. On “Adoption Day,” however, when each child is allowed to retrieve only what they can carry from their homes, Michael returns with all his clothes piled into a wagon. This contrast draws attention to how much the librarians’ lives and characters are changed by Father and their experiences in the Library.
These final chapters continue to develop the significance of Carolyn and Steve’s relationship. The importance Steve holds for Carolyn isn’t fully established until the Epilogue, which reveals the meaning of the book’s title for the first time. Carolyn’s use of the childhood nickname that she and Steve gave Adam Black’s house signifies the divide between her idealized memory of Steve and the actual friendship they had. Father said Steve would be “the coal of her heart” and pointed out that sending Steve away was necessary because: “No real thing can be so perfect as memory, and she will need a perfect thing if she is to survive” (356). Carolyn’s dreams of a life with Steven, then, could never have become a reality. Jennifer’s words—“It never works out the way you would think” (321)—reinforce this truth. As Father planned, however, the idea of Steve became a cornerstone of Carolyn’s vision of the future and her sense of self. She remembers the name Mount Char now because she’s beginning to remember the friendship as it was, rather than as the ideal she’d held onto. She’s been grieving the loss of this ideal, but this moment marks her shift toward acceptance.
The allusion to Mount Char also signifies the divide between the person Carolyn once was and the person she’s become, highlighting The Emotional Toll of Wearing a Mask. Her character arc is defined by her inner conflict with the effects of abuse and trauma. As Steve observes, she had to shut down to survive. To her, this was adjusting, and it was necessary, but it cost her. She hasn’t thought of the name Mount Char in years, and the fact that she does so now symbolizes her beginning to undo the damage Father and David inflicted on her. She’s thawing and seeking the remnants of her humanity so she can nurture them and heal her shattered identity. Erwin’s bombing of Mount Char supplements this by symbolizing the loss of Father’s hold over Carolyn. As Carolyn is able to reintegrate her identity, she becomes more fully capable of taking Father’s role as leader and protector of the Library.



Unlock all 54 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.