50 pages 1-hour read

The Master

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2004

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 1-3Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains references to suicide.

Chapter 1 Summary: “January 1895”

Henry wakes from troubled sleep an hour or so before dawn. He dreamed that he was walking through an unknown but obviously Italian city. As he moved through narrow streets, he’d become aware of two figures ahead of him. They turned around, revealing themselves to be his aunt and his mother. His mother looked stricken and had a haunted expression. In reality, both of these women are long dead, so the dream fills him with sadness and unease. 


Henry’s play, Guy Domville, is set to open on January 5, and he has been working hard to prepare for its first performance. Throughout this last stage of preparations, he has remained largely cloistered, but when he receives a letter from the wife of Prince Oblisky, a Russian, he feels compelled to allow her to visit. Her husband is a stern man who is preoccupied with the future of Russia, and rumors swirl about the couple. She confesses that her husband is forcing her to return to Russia. Henry wonders what sin she must have committed to be exiled from Paris in this way. Seeing her distress as she describes her preparations for leaving, Henry has an urge to capture the complexity of her emotional state and render her story with an eye for the smallest details. She asks if he would like the letters of a mutual friend named Paul, and he is plunged into decades-old memories, as his and Paul’s story is one that Henry has never written and can never write.


On the play’s opening night, he is filled with nerves. He does not want to watch the play, but all of his friends are in the audience, so he has no one to make alternative plans with. He decides to see Oscar Wilde’s new drama, An Ideal Husband. By the time it ends, his play will also be ending. He can then sneak into the theater through its side entrance. He dislikes Wilde’s play immensely and is disturbed by how much the audience loves it. This discord makes him worry about the public reception of his own play. Based on what this audience seems to enjoy, he fears that his first foray into the world of drama will be a disaster. When he makes his way to the theater where his play has just been performed, his worst fears are confirmed; the audience was openly jeering by the end of the final act.

Chapter 2 Summary: “February 1895”

Henry comes to terms with the failure of his play, realizing that the general public might not be the best audience for his work. He knows that his novels appeal to more educated, refined writers and are not works of “popular” fiction. This measured success has been enough for him so far. He is solitary by nature and enjoys writing for writing’s sake. Devoted to his art, he is pleased that his novels are popular among like-minded people, but he remains distressed by the public failure of his play. As a result of the debacle, he has largely withdrawn from society. He decides that he might be happier travelling, so he accepts invitations from two friends in Ireland, Lord Houghton and Lord Wolseley; they did not see his play and were not aware of its resounding failure. 


Lord Wolseley is in charge of the English army in Ireland. Recently, there has been considerable unrest due to the antipathy between the Irish and the British in Ireland. Henry does his best to ignore the uproar. He enjoys his time with Lord Houghton, although there are too many social events; he almost always prefers solitude to the company of others. When he arrives at Lord Wolseley’s, he finds that Lady Wolseley holds Lord Houghton in very low regard. Henry does his best to remain polite to his current host without disparaging his previous one. 


Lady Wolseley has arranged for Henry to be looked after by a manservant named Corporal Hammond. Hammond is Irish but has lived for most of his life in London. He is a quiet, dignified man with whom Henry feels an instant affinity. 


Henry would much rather sit in his room writing or reading, but he must socialize with the rest of Lord and Lady Wolseley’s guests. One night at dinner, another guest makes snide comments about County Cravan, where Henry’s grandfather was born. It is obvious that both the guest and Lady Wolseley do not respect Henry’s ancestors. Henry is puzzled and does not understand why he should care about the social standing of distant relatives. His ancestors left Ireland to find success in America, and they had. He retires to his room in a particularly foul mood, and Hammond does his best to soothe him. He even offers to return to “check on” Henry in the night, and Henry is unsure whether Hammond is trying to make a sexual advance. Worried that he is misinterpreting an innocent offer of help, he politely declines. However, he feels a distinct pang; although he craves the physical comfort of someone who cares for him, he cannot afford to mistake innocence for a romantic advance. 


The next day is clear but cold. He heads outside for a walk and sees the daughter of one of the other guests with her nurse. He observes them carefully, taking note of the nurse’s tone of voice and the child’s response. When he returns to the house, he runs into Lady Wolseley. There is to be a fancy dress ball later, but Henry has no intention of dressing up for it. Truthfully, he wishes he could skip it all together. Lady Wolseley is disappointed that he will not appear in costume, but she assures him that he will enjoy himself. 


At the ball, the young girl he saw on the lawn with her nurse is wearing an elaborate costume. Henry finds both the costume and the attention it garners inappropriate. He looks around carefully, expecting to see shock on other faces, but no one shares his reaction. The ball is not enjoyable, and he is glad to return to his room as soon as possible.

Chapter 3 Summary: “March 1895”

In London, Henry notices that idiosyncrasies are tolerated as long as the individual in question conforms to general societal standards and is well-mannered. He therefore finds relative acceptance of his preference for solitude and turns down invitations without giving offense. He enjoys spending time alone and is much more comfortable thinking and writing in his room than he is at any party. 


After his return from Ireland, he does his best to direct his attention away from the failure of his play and toward other creative ventures. He is at work on a story about a governess and two children. He decides to set the tale in an English country house. He enjoys writing and feels proud of his novels despite the failure of his play. He thinks carefully about each character that he creates, outlining their traits and characteristics, but also their motivations and the nature of their relationships. He is particularly interested in how the governess relates to her small charges, and he recalls the young girl he observed at the Wolseley home, who was at play with her nurse. He wants to present fully formed characters with rich inner lives, so he spends hours getting the smallest details right. 


He also thinks of his siblings. He felt a kinship for Alice, as the two of them were always unprepared for life and ill at ease in society. William, his outgoing elder brother, was better equipped for success in the world and was better accepted by his peers. Still, Henry and all four of his siblings had been deemed “strange.” Their family traveled widely when they were young, and they knew more about Europe than they did about America. 


Alice was overly fond of Henry and deteriorated after his marriage. Their mother diagnosed her with hysteria, but it was obvious that her emotional difficulties were complex in nature and origin. After their parents’ deaths, Alice traveled to London. By that time, she was confined to her bed and quite unwell. Henry wrote two novels during that time. Both The Bostonians and The Princess Casamassima were suffused with Alice’s particular struggles and contained characters reminiscent of his sister, although neither novel was specifically “about” her. Alice’s health deteriorated further, and she eventually died. At the time, Henry thought that she lacked the will to live.

Chapters 1-3 Analysis

The novel begins with a short anecdote that introduces Henry James through several important lenses. Initially, he dreams that he is walking through an unnamed Italian city in the company of his long-dead mother and sister, and this surreal imagery establishes the fact that traveling throughout Europe and embracing a cosmopolitan identity will become very important to him. Although he will wrestle with his identity throughout the entirety of his life, he ultimately comes to view himself as a citizen of “the world,” and is comfortable with that identification. Family, too, will play a large role in the narrative, as James’s relationship with his family is often fraught. But as he ages, he realizes that he shares much in common with his parents and siblings, and he will learn to draw strength from those connections. Death, too, haunts Henry and becomes one of the novel’s key motifs: Henry will come to see death as a time not only of mourning but also of self-reflection: He learns more about himself by meditating on the relationships he has with his friends and family members. 


In the novel’s first chapter, the failure of Henry’s play introduces the novel’s focus on The Pain of Repression and Self-Denial, for he keeps much of his essential nature hidden from the world, expressing his deepest sentiments only in writing and doing his best to avoid social obligations that sorely unsettle him. When his play’s failure destabilizes him and throws him into a panic, he falls back upon his penchant for self-reflection and uses the unfortunate incident as a springboard for reflection. The debacle forces him to realize that he is not a “popular” writer, but he decides that he is comfortable with his more intellectual, rarified reputation. By creating character-driven novels with a high degree of realism, he actively appeals to what he sees as a “higher class” of reader. Once he makes his peace with his lack of success as a dramatist, he throws himself headlong into a new novel and regains his emotional equilibrium. 


Henry’s distinct difficulties in navigating social settings also introduce his fondness for The Lure of Solitude, and it is clear that he is his best version of himself when he is safely alone with his thoughts. However, because he comes from an affluent, well-connected family, he is expected to maintain his role in society. Notably, Tóibín creates an accurate depiction of Henry’s social life amidst the American and European elites of the late 19th century, and these careful details imbue the novel with important historical context. Because Henry is an introvert who would rather spend time alone than in groups, these obligatory social events fill him with unease and distress, while “the prospect of a morning alone fill[s] him with happiness” (26). To remain calm in social situations that he largely finds puzzling, he closely observes the behavior of others, and as a result, his novels are character-driven and psychologically complex. He draws inspiration for his characters from real people, and when he is out and about in society, he does his best to create complete character studies of his friends and family. This instinctive practice, born of the need to survive in a social world that he does not fully understand, allows him to craft deeply realistic fiction that reflects the “human condition.” 


With the introduction of Corporal Hammond to the plot, Tóibín addresses yet another facet of The Pain of Repression and Self-Denial. Because Henry lives in a world that actively forbids romantic encounters between men and harshly prosecutes those who disobey this rule. He must therefore hide the most vital aspects of his personality merely to survive in his rarified social circles. Still, he is forced to contend with his sexuality on numerous occasions and resigns himself to suppressing his desires rather than acting upon them. This issue becomes plain when he and Hammond are instantly drawn to each other, for although Hammond makes a cautious advance, Henry cannot run the risk of misinterpreting Hammond’s apparent overture. When he rebuffs Hammond, he rejects both the other man and himself, and this act causes him a great deal of emotional distress. The scene foreshadows several more in which Henry feels that he cannot consummate his romantic desires. Because Henry never achieves an authentic romantic connection during his lifetime, he is largely characterized by the anguish of unrealized desire.


Henry further displays his powers of self-reflection by telling the story of his sister Alice’s life and death, and the similarities between the two siblings throw Henry’s deepest struggles into sharp relief. Alice, like Henry, also struggled with social anxiety and never quite found her place in the world. Henry reflects that although she could sometimes pull herself out of her melancholia, she ultimately lacked the will to live. Her death stands as a profound loss for him, but he manages his grief by processing her life and analyzing the deeper meaning of their relationship. As his contemplations indicate, death is one of this novel’s major motifs. Even the contemplative process that Alice’s death inspires in Henry becomes a motif in its own right, for Henry proves himself adept at turning difficult situations into opportunities for self-reflection.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 50 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs