The Phoenix Crown: A Novel

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of racism.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. The Phoenix Crown puts fictional characters in the midst of historical events against the backdrop of the 1906 San Francisco earthquake. How effectively did the authors balance historical accuracy with compelling storytelling? What moments stood out as particularly successful in bringing this era to life?

2. The novel features four strong female protagonists from different backgrounds who form an unlikely friendship. Which of these women did you find most compelling, and why? How did their different perspectives enhance your understanding of early 20th century San Francisco?

3. Kate Quinn is known for her historical fiction novels like The Rose Code and The Alice Network. If you’ve read these or others of her works, how does The Phoenix Crown compare in its portrayal of female relationships? What elements of her storytelling style remain consistent across her works?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Throughout the novel, the Queen of the Night flower symbolizes the women’s resilience. What object or symbol in your own life represents an important relationship or personal strength?

2. Gemma turns to her music for comfort and healing after difficulty, while Reggie finds herself unable to paint. How do you process challenging experiences in your life? Do you find creative expression helpful or difficult during times of stress?

3. The four women in the novel navigate complex personal and professional identities. Which character’s journey resonated most with your own experiences of balancing personal fulfillment with professional ambition?

4. Suling strategically dresses as a boy to navigate safely through San Francisco. Have you ever adapted your self-presentation to fit into different social or professional environments? What did you learn from that experience?

5. The novel explores how artistic talent and recognition often depend on patronage or financial support. Have you observed how economic resources affect access to creative opportunities? How does this dynamic continue to shape artistic communities today?

6. Alice prioritizes her scientific work over conforming to traditional gender expectations of her time. When have you chosen to pursue your passions despite external pressures or conventions? What gave you the strength to make that choice?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. The Phoenix Crown depicts the racism faced by Chinese Americans in early 20th century San Francisco. How do the authors portray the complexities of Chinatown and its residents to move beyond stereotypes? What insights does this historical portrayal offer about cultural representation in literature?

2. The novel portrays how the 1906 earthquake affected different communities unequally, with Chinatown being completely destroyed. How does this historical disaster parallel modern conversations about environmental justice and the disproportionate impact of natural disasters on marginalized communities?

3. The book explores various forms of artistic expression during the early 1900s, from opera to visual art to fashion. How do these different art forms reflect the social stratification of the era? What do the characters’ relationships with their art reveal about class and gender in their society?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. The authors use multiple point-of-view characters to tell the story. How does this help them explore how people from different kinds of marginalized communities experience oppression? Which perspective offered insights that complemented each other particularly effectively?

2. Fire operates as both a literal and metaphorical force throughout the novel, similar to how water functions in Virginia Woolf’s To the Lighthouse. Consider fire imagery in the Park Avenue Hotel fire, the earthquake, and in the final confrontation with Henry. What does fire represent for different characters?

3. For much of the novel, Reggie/Nellie’s identity remains deliberately ambiguous. How does this narrative choice affect your reading experience? What does this reveal about the authors’ approach to gender and sexuality in historical fiction?

4. The novel moves from San Francisco in 1906 to Paris in 1911. How does this time jump structure suggest about trauma and recovery?

5. How do the authors use different artistic mediums (opera, painting, sewing, botany) to explore the intersections of gender, class, and personal expression? Which artistic metaphors most effectively illuminated the characters’ inner lives?

6. Throughout the novel, characters adopt different names and identities—Gemma/Sally, Henry/William, Nellie/Reggie. What do these dual identities reveal about power, authenticity, and survival in the different worlds the characters inhabit?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. Reggie’s paintings document the lives of her friends after Henry’s death. If you were to create a piece of art capturing the essence of The Phoenix Crown, what medium would you choose, and what elements of the story would you highlight?

2. Imagine that Suling’s fashion designs have been exhibited in a modern museum. Write the curator’s note that would accompany her collection, highlighting how her personal journey and cultural background influenced her artistic vision.

3. The four women in the novel each have distinct voices and perspectives. Choose one pivotal scene from the book and rewrite it from the perspective of Reggie, whose point of view we never directly access in the novel. How might she have interpreted and experienced that moment?

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources