48 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Ruby falls into a deep melancholy. Marcel still hasn’t come home. Charlotte comes by to check on her regularly. Marcel eventually arrives, and Ruby tells him about the pregnancy loss. Marcel is visibly upset but acknowledges that it may be for the best. Over the next few months, he is increasingly absent.
One day, Ruby receives a delayed letter from her parents, asking Ruby to bring her child back to America. She writes a response and reflects on her life so far. Later, Charlotte comes to invite Ruby over; her parents tell her that Charlotte won’t be returning to school and ask her to tutor Charlotte in English. They discuss rumors about the treatment and removal of Jewish people. While Madame Dacher is cautious, Monsieur Dacher refuses to believe the worst.
Ruby and Charlotte begin English lessons. Later, Marcel arrives with a luxurious dinner and attempts to make amends with Ruby. After he leaves, a wounded man comes to the door looking for him. Ruby realizes the man is a pilot and invites him in. As she closes the door, she sees Charlotte watching.
Charlotte processes seeing Ruby with the pilot. She’s confused and hurt because Ruby didn’t trust her with her secret. She decides to bring the airman some food, but when Ruby sees her, she is deflective. When Charlotte protests, Ruby invites her in and swears her to secrecy. She introduces Charlotte to the pilot, Dexter, and they care for him together.
Dexter explains that he followed an escape line after crashing his plane, and that Marcel helped a fellow pilot before. Charlotte reveals that she saw Marcel conducting his resistance efforts. They discuss the pilot’s injury, worrying that it could be fatally infected.
Thomas begins flying over France. Harry assures him that the war will soon be over and reminds him that he’s not alone. Thomas’s plane is shot at, but he sustains no damage. His missions become second nature over time, though Harry is lost in one of the battles.
Not long after, however, Harry turns up alive and well with news of an escape line from Paris. He encourages Thomas to keep the information in mind should he ever need it.
Ruby waits for Marcel’s return while Dexter hides in the closet. Dexter acts bravely, but Ruby knows he’s worried and hurt. When Marcel finally returns, Ruby confronts him about his activities and tells him about the pilot. Marcel is defensive, but Ruby implores him to let her help with his work. He promises to talk to her about it the next day. However, he doesn’t return for several days.
On the third day, Aubert comes to tell Ruby that Marcel has been killed by German soldiers. Ruby asks Aubert to let her continue Marcel’s work, but he refuses. A few days later, three guards come to search her apartment. They find nothing incriminating but vow to keep watching Ruby.
Thomas is on a routine mission, enjoying the view above the world. Suddenly, he’s hit by an enemy pilot, and his plane is lost. Thomas ejects and floats down to the ground, then quickly hides his parachute and assesses his situation. He uses the compass in his survival kit to find his way, walking for several hours until he meets a stranger in the woods. The man, Claude, invites Thomas to stay at his farm for the night. Thomas is suspicious but accepts.
Claude and his wife care for Thomas for the night; they tell him they’ve been helping other pilots along their way. The next day, Thomas sets out toward Paris, practicing his French accent so he won’t arouse suspicion. Once in the city, he tries to find the location Harry told him about. He ends up getting directions from a Nazi soldier, pretending to be a laborer. He finds Ruby’s apartment and knocks on one of the doors, hoping it’s the right one.
Charlotte considers what she knows about Marcel’s death and Ruby’s activities. She remembers the guards who came to Ruby’s door and their misogynistic sexual comments about her. Determined to learn the truth and earn Ruby’s trust, Charlotte goes to see her. However, she sees that Thomas has come to Ruby’s door. Once Ruby answers, Thomas faints in the hallway.
Ruby brings Thomas inside, hastily dismissing Charlotte. Thomas wakes up several hours later, and Ruby explains that her husband helped men like him. She examines him and sees that he has an infected wound. She cares for him for several days until he recovers, and they grow attracted to each other.
Eventually, Thomas realizes that Marcel is gone, and Ruby is alone. Later, Ruby goes to find Aubert and leaves a message for him, asking him to get in touch. Back at home, Thomas finds a photo of Ruby at home in America in the middle of a poppy field. They begin talking about her past and her marriage. She tells Thomas that helping pilots like him makes her feel confident and independent again. Thomas encourages her, telling her that she’s strong and brave.
Thomas is growing more attached to Ruby and doesn’t want to return to the war. He remembers talking to her all night, sharing stories about their families. Thomas opens up about his mother’s death and his regrets about not spending more time with her.
The next day, Ruby goes to find someone who can help Thomas escape. While she’s gone, Charlotte comes to the door asking for help. Thomas is initially suspicious of a trap, but he follows her to her apartment.
Charlotte is panicking because her mother has fallen and hit her head. She is unconscious and bleeding, but Charlotte doesn’t want to go to anyone else for help in case there is retribution because they are Jewish. Thomas arrives and helps care for Madame Dacher until she wakes up. He praises Charlotte for her quick thinking.
Thomas and Charlotte sit down to talk, and he asks about Ruby. Charlotte confesses that Marcel was unkind and that Ruby was devastated by the loss of her baby. Thomas tells her about his flight to Paris and asks her to look after Ruby once he’s gone. As he prepares to go, Charlotte offers him some of their food as a thank you. He asks if Charlotte is Jewish, and she acknowledges that she is. He encourages her to be strong until the war is over.
Ruby’s pregnancy loss and the ongoing struggles in her marriage continue to develop the theme of The Nature of Love During a Crisis, with her depression and growing marital tension once more speaking to the strains of wartime upon intimate relationships. Ruby and Marcel’s relationship continues to alternate between deterioration and brief moments of optimism and hope; while they are never entirely reconciled, they are also never entirely driven apart, either. Once Ruby discovers more details about Marcel’s line of work in the Resistance, there is a possibility that they can reconcile and be in each other’s lives more fully than they were before, since Ruby is eager to become involved. However, Marcel’s death brings a permanent end to their hopes of renewing their bond before they can explore what their future might have been. Their unresolved feelings at the time of Marcel’s death thus suggest that not all bonds can survive the effects of war and crisis.
Charlotte continues to wrestle with The Experience of Identity and Coming-of-Age as her life continues to change dramatically under the circumstances of war and rising antisemitism. Whereas at the beginning of the novel, she was still able to attend school despite the taunting of her peers, in these chapters she now has to be homeschooled due to the growing hostility aimed at French Jews. Her mother’s injury reinforces her sense of isolation and vulnerability: She cannot seek help directly from the medical authorities or a random neighbor because she now understands that, as Jews, she and her family are vulnerable to discrimination and persecution. Her growing awareness of her vulnerability also speaks to her developing maturity: She reaches out to Thomas and ends up helping her mother, showing her increased sense of responsibility and ability to adapt to her current challenges.
Thomas reaches a major turning point in his character arc when he is shot down and forced to make his way through the French countryside. He encounters local people who help him along the way, introducing him to The Impact of Everyday Heroism. The sprawling Resistance network is made up not of trained soldiers and officials but of ordinary people attempting to make a difference. This leads him to Ruby, who will go on to become the love of his life. Their attraction is immediate, yet their relationship progresses more slowly and with an emphasis on emotional intimacy, forming an important contrast to the instantaneous, idealized attraction of Ruby and Marcel. Thomas also becomes one of the only pilots to learn Ruby’s true name before the advent of her new code name, reinforcing the sense of a special connection between them as they both seek to aid the war effort in different ways.
Following his mother’s death, Thomas feels entirely isolated from the world around him. Ruby’s influence gives him a new reason to fight and survive, which invokes a new dimension of The Nature of Love During a Crisis. At one point, he tells Ruby that she reminds him of her mother: “‘[S]he was one of the most decent people I knew, and it strikes me that you’re that way too’” (176). This creates a unifying thread of the feminine influence in Thomas’s life—something which, to all appearances, Marcel was missing. In a similar vein, Thomas’s first interaction with Charlotte is through her mother, reinforcing the idea that Thomas easily forms close bonds with women.
Through Thomas and Charlotte’s interactions, the novel also introduces the importance of platonic love alongside the developing romance plot between Thomas and Ruby. Charlotte struggles with the divide between who she wants to be and her limitations as a young girl. She doesn’t get the validation and respect she feels she deserves from her parents or Ruby, but she does find it in an unexpected place: After Thomas tends to her mother, he praises Charlotte’s courage and encourages her to be strong. Thomas also shows that he recognizes Charlotte’s maturity when he asks her to look after Ruby for him. His trust and affection for Charlotte explore the idea that friendship, like love, can also offer an important emotional lifeline in times of war and crisis.



Unlock all 48 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.