Plot Summary

The Secret to Hummingbird Cake

Celeste Fletcher McHale
Guide cover placeholder

The Secret to Hummingbird Cake

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2016

Plot Summary

Set in the small fictional town of Bon Dieu Falls, Louisiana, the novel is narrated by Carrigan Whitfield, a sharp-tongued, impulsive thirty-year-old whose marriage, friendships, and sense of self are tested when cancer strikes the person she loves most.

Carrigan has been best friends with Laine Landry and Ella Rae Weeks since kindergarten, when Ella Rae punched a boy who pushed Laine and broke her glasses. Their roles solidified early: Carrigan is the ringleader, Ella Rae the fighter, and Laine the gentle, morally grounded peacemaker. Now adults still living in Bon Dieu Falls, the three remain inseparable.

Carrigan eloped with Jack Whitfield III, the wealthy heir to Whitfield Farms, a prominent soybean and cattle operation, when she was seventeen and he was twenty-seven. After forging her father's consent signature and convincing a reluctant Laine and an eager Ella Rae to join them on the drive to Texas, Carrigan married Jack in a brief ceremony. The fallout was severe, with both families furious, but a proper church wedding followed the next weekend, and the early years were passionate and happy.

About a year before the novel opens, Jack became emotionally and physically distant without explanation. Carrigan tried everything to reconnect, but he insisted nothing was wrong. Eventually she gave up and began an affair with a man she and her friends call "Cell Phone Romeo." Only Laine and Ella Rae know. Laine disapproves sharply, insisting Jack loves Carrigan and urging her to take responsibility for her choices, while Ella Rae, loyal and uncritical, supports Carrigan unconditionally.

As the story opens, Carrigan waits up late for Jack, fielding Romeo's persistent calls. Laine walks in from across the street and quickly deduces the situation, delivering a lecture Carrigan resents but knows is deserved. The next day, at a charity softball tournament, Romeo shows up in person despite Carrigan's texts telling him to stay away, forcing a panicked cover-up. Through these early chapters, Carrigan admits privately that she still loves Jack deeply but hides behind pride and defiance.

Carrigan soon ends the affair after Romeo claims God brought them together, a statement so absurd it jolts her into recognizing the relationship's wrongness. At the annual Crawfish Boil at Whitfield Farms, Charlotte Freeman, a trusted friend visiting from Vicksburg, Mississippi, tells Carrigan she does not believe Jack is cheating and notes that Laine looks unusually tired and unwell. Carrigan dismisses the observation as overwork but files it away.

In July, with Jack's parents away on a cruise, Carrigan stays at the Farm to help Jack, and the couple begins to reconnect. One evening Jack tells her he loves her and asks her to ride out to the old barn the next day so they can finally talk. Their outing becomes a passionate reunion. As they ride home at dusk, Carrigan is about to confess her affair when Ella Rae appears, sobbing, with devastating news: Laine is seriously ill.

At Shreveport Medical Center, Doctor Rougeau delivers the diagnosis: stage four ovarian cancer that has already spread. He gives Laine perhaps a year to eighteen months with treatment. Carrigan erupts, insisting a young, healthy woman cannot have terminal cancer. Laine reveals she has already obtained three opinions and has decided to refuse chemotherapy, preferring to spend her remaining time feeling well rather than sick from treatment. Carrigan begs her to reconsider, but Laine will not budge. Before leaving, Laine makes three requests of her friends: that they never treat her differently, that they always tell her the truth, and that they stay with her to the end. Carrigan flees the hospital and collapses weeping in a garden, where Jack, who has driven to Shreveport, holds her.

Jack arranges for Laine to stay at Whitfield Farms with a full-time nurse, Debra Pierson. Carrigan and Ella Rae move in as well, Ella Rae's extended stay made possible because her husband, Tommy, is working in a Texas oilfield. The Farm becomes a cocoon of love and normalcy where the friends squeeze every second from every day. Jack's parents support the arrangement wholeheartedly.

One evening, the sight of eggs makes Carrigan nauseous, and Ella Rae immediately suspects pregnancy. The household erupts in celebration when the suspicion is confirmed, and the doctor sets a due date of April third. Carrigan worries her pregnancy will steal attention from Laine, but Laine tells her the baby is a blessing, a sign of life restoring itself, and gives her a reason to hold on.

The morning before Thanksgiving, Laine reveals a long-held secret: During college, she had a love affair with Mitch Montgomery, a quiet former classmate whose marriage was failing. They fell deeply in love, but Laine encouraged Mitch to return to his wife for the sake of his young son, knowing that Mitch's own troubled childhood made him unable to bear the thought of a child bouncing between parents. Laine told him not to contact her again and carried the heartbreak silently, never dating seriously because no one measured up.

In December, Laine hemorrhages and is rushed to the ER but rallies after treatment. Christmas is joyful, and on New Year's Eve, Laine asks Carrigan to deliver her eulogy. Carrigan reluctantly agrees. By late March, Laine is visibly weakening. At a routine appointment, the doctor says the baby could come anytime, and that afternoon Carrigan's water breaks at a restaurant. After an agonizing labor, she gives birth to a girl. Jack and Carrigan name her Ella Laine Whitfield, called Elle. Laine holds the baby and whispers that she has so much to tell her but not so much time.

As Laine's condition worsens, she asks to see Mitch. Ella Rae reveals she tracked him down months earlier: Mitch is now divorced, living in Dallas, and has wanted to see Laine for years. He arrives within two days and stays for five, during which Laine smiles more than she has in months. Then Laine asks Mitch to leave, not wanting him to witness the end. She tells Carrigan and Ella Rae that their love endured, remembered, and forgave, and that the next time Mitch sees her, she will be whole again.

On Laine's final night, Carrigan panics and flees to the barn in a thunderstorm. Jack catches her and holds her as she unleashes months of rage at Laine, at God, and at herself. He tells her she is not really angry at Laine for refusing treatment; she is angry at Laine for dying, which is not Laine's fault. His words dissolve the fury she has carried, and she returns to Laine's bedside with renewed peace. At 2:12 a.m., Carrigan wakes to find Laine looking at her and smiling faintly. Their eyes lock, and then Laine takes a deep breath, exhales, and does not breathe again. Carrigan is the only one awake to witness the moment.

On the morning of the funeral, Jack finally explains his yearlong withdrawal. Lexi Carter, his most significant ex-girlfriend, had returned to town and told him she heard Carrigan was restless in the marriage. Jack then overheard Carrigan tell Ella Rae she regretted not going to college or taking her softball scholarship. Consumed with guilt for having stolen Carrigan's youth, he pulled away. Lexi later visited the barn, drugged his beer, and staged a scene to make him believe they had slept together, then claimed pregnancy as part of an extortion scheme tied to drug debts. Months later, Lexi's baby was stillborn, and she confessed the entire fabrication; this confession came the day before they learned of Laine's illness, which was what Jack had intended to discuss at their picnic. Jack also reveals he has known about Romeo all along and blames himself. Hearing Laine's voice in her mind, reminding her that her choices are her own, Carrigan takes full responsibility. They forgive each other completely.

At the packed funeral, Reverend Martin reads opening remarks Laine wrote herself months earlier. Carrigan delivers the eulogy, telling the congregation that their stories over the past two days revealed things about Laine she never knew, and that cancer took Laine's body but never took her spirit.

Months later, a box arrives addressed to Carrigan and Ella Rae with the return address "Laine E. Landry, Heaven." Inside, after spring-loaded toy snakes that make them scream, are three leather-bound journals, the secret project Laine worked on during her final months. Carrigan's and Ella Rae's journals are filled with photographs, mementos, and handwritten notes spanning their friendship. A letter from Laine urges Carrigan to stop obsessing over why and to live fully. The third journal is for Elle, containing guidance for each birthday through her twenty-first. On the back cover, Laine has inscribed her closely guarded Hummingbird Cake recipe with a note: The secret ingredient was never a spice but love, because she only made the cake for people she loved, and it tasted best to Carrigan and Ella Rae because she loved them most of all.

In the epilogue, set when Elle is five, Carrigan and Ella Rae have founded the Laine Landry Foundation to assist elderly residents of Bon Dieu Falls, with Mitch managing its finances from nearby Natchitoches. Jack has purchased Laine's house across the street to spare Carrigan the pain of seeing strangers there, and the house serves as the Foundation's office. Ella Rae and Tommy have a son; Carrigan and Jack are expecting a second daughter. Each year on Elle's birthday, a card and charm bracelet charm arrive from an unknown sender on Laine's behalf. When Elle asks if Laine can see them, Carrigan tells her, without a doubt, that Laine watches over them all.

We’re just getting started

Add this title to our list of requested Study Guides!