39 pages • 1-hour read
Robin Wall KimmererA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Kimmerer looks at the ways in which a modern economy can move toward something more closely resembling a gift economy. She has two neighbors named Paulie and Ed. They own a farm, and Kimmerer uses them as an example of the way in which a gift economy can be implemented. Paulie and Ed, she says, understand the need to work at building relationships as an important part of their business, viewing it as “an investment in community” (88). The community cannot offer a return on the investment, Kimmerer notes, unless effort is made to first build the community. This community, Kimmerer believes, is the foundation of any gift economy. The building of a community establishes a network of responsibility and reciprocity. In the future, Paulie hopes, the people who accepted the gifts of berries may return to the farm to shop, may offer favors, or may even vote on political issues that would benefit farmers or the environment.
Building such a community helps to address humanity’s “deep desire” to build relationships and connections. Kimmerer acknowledges that the market economy and its commodification are unlikely to entirely disappear, but she stresses that alternatives can be built “alongside” such economies (92). The building of gift economies, Kimmerer says, demands incremental change as well as the imagination to disrupt the current system in new and creative ways. They must also be built on “a foundation of social justice” (95). She cites examples of plant communities that are constantly in flux as a demonstration of the way in which old systems can be replaced by newer versions. The changes in plant communities can be seen as “a parallel to the transition that colonizing human societies must undergo” to thrive in the future (100). Incremental change and disruption are needed in equal measure, Kimmerer suggests, and humans must become active agents of change to defeat “the Darrens’ economy of extractive capitalism” that she considers to be a crime against nature (102). With “joy and justice” on her side (103), Kimmerer believes that gift economies can and should be built.
Kimmerer closes the book with a call to action. She invites the readers to be a part of a gift economy, suggesting that they make gifts of their own in return for the gifts they take from the earth. These gifts can take many forms—such as time, art, money, teaching, or political action—but they will help to build communities and, in doing so, begin a process of changing the way society thinks about the economy and the way in which people relate to one another.
In the final chapter of The Serviceberry, Kimmerer marries the theory and practical implementation of the previous chapters with a broader plan for long term activism. She frames her book both as an exploration of gift economies as a vestige of the Indigenous cultures of America’s past and as a fierce advocation for gift economies as a viable and necessary remedy to many of the issues that plague modern society. Citing social alienation to destructive climate change, Kimmerer emphasizes the need to rethink the dominant Western economic model as a whole, underscoring the idea of The Natural World as Inspiration for Economic Reform. To that end, she closes the novel with a description of the immediate action that people can take to implement her ideas in their lives. Contained within this advice is the tacit acknowledgement that a full dismantling of capitalist systems of power in the world takes time. Kimmerer may not live to see the changes she wants to implement, nor does she believe that she has the power to bring her advice to as broad an audience as necessary. Instead, she outlines a potential synthesis of her theories that centers Optimism as a Tool for Building a Better World. For example, she encourages readers to embrace ways to implement and participate in small gift economies within larger capitalist systems, offering examples of ways they can coexist. Like the natural analogies of which she is so fond, Kimmerer shows how great change can be born from a small seed. By drawing attention to the way society thinks about economies, Kimmerer aims to shift readers’ perspectives, encouraging a synthesis of her ideas with existing economic models.
The building of communities and networks remains essential to Kimmerer’s vision of a future in which gift economies are prevalent. In the context of her book, this desire to build is fundamentally optimistic. Even though The Serviceberry provides a scathing critique of the modern capitalist economies, Kimmerer emphasizes her belief in the fundamental generosity and goodness of people. She notes that capitalist economies were built by people, so people can also build something different. Gift economies have existed for centuries, so they can be rebuilt in the future—a perspective that relies on her extensive knowledge of both ecological and human history.
In the book’s conclusion, Kimmerer links her optimistic view of human generosity with her exploration of The Tension Between Cutthroat Capitalism and Communal Reciprocity to incite her readers to action, positioning The Serviceberry as a polemic. Kimmerer uses every rhetorical resource available to urge her readers to go out into the world and enact the changes that she has outlined. Her vision for a better, more natural, more generous world is utopian in nature, but she leaves her plans up to the readers to achieve. Actively pushing back against the image of herself as the grand architect of a brave new world, Kimmerer ends the novel with a rhetorical question that positions herself and her readers in solidarity—noting that it’s a question “we answer” (105). Because gift economies involve the building of communities, the building of gift economies must be a communal effort. The necessity of an author as a sole leader is put aside, with Kimmerer urging her readers to join in a collective effort to achieve a better world for everyone.



Unlock all 39 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.