54 pages 1-hour read

The Shoemaker's Wife

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2012

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 2, Chapters 9-14Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of illness and mental illness.

Part 2: “Manhattan”

Part 2, Chapter 9 Summary: “A Linen Handkerchief”

Ciro travels to Marseilles, where he spends the night in a church. His heart aches with longing for Vilminore and Eduardo. He misses the nuns, too. Finally, he boards the SS Chicago to the US, where a man named Massimo Zito offers him three dollars to shovel coal for the nine-day voyage. Ciro refuses to do the job for less than $10. Ciro spends the rest of the journey working in the boiler room with a fellow Italian passenger named Luigi Latini. They become friends during the trip, sharing plans and dreams for their lives. Luigi is headed to Ohio to marry a match his parents made for him. Ciro is going to Manhattan. Each night, as Ciro falls asleep, he thinks of Enza.

Part 2, Chapter 10 Summary: “A Green Tree”

Ciro and Luigi arrive in Manhattan. Ciro is overwhelmed by the beauty of the Statue of Liberty and the rush of Ellis Island. Then he’s called out of the processing line. Ciro panics, but the officer informs him that he has received orders from “the sisters of San Nicola” (132) to expedite his passage. He tells Ciro to change his last name so that Americans will be able to pronounce it, but Ciro declines. Endearing himself to the officer, he convinces him to expedite Luigi’s papers, too.


After passing through Ellis Island, Ciro and Luigi part ways and wish each other luck. Then Ciro meets up with his sponsors and employers, Remo and Carla Zanetti. They take him to Little Italy, where they own and operate Zanetti Shoe Shop.


Meanwhile, on the mountain, Enza and her family encounter further trouble. Signore Arduini wants to sell their house. Enza suggests to Marco that they buy their own house, proposing that she and Marco travel to the US for work.


In Little Italy, Ciro settles in with the Zanettis. They attend the Feast of Santa Maria. Amid the crowd, Ciro spies the May Queen, Felicitá, and decides to pursue her.

Part 2, Chapter 11 Summary: “A Blessed Medal”

By May of 1910, Marco has relocated his family to a new rental house. Meanwhile, he mulls over Enza’s proposition. One day, their faithful horse, Cipi, dies. The loss devastates Marco.


Ciro makes Felicitá’s acquaintance. Obsessed with fine things, she demands that Ciro give her his gold ring; he refuses to give it up, as it was his mother’s. Although Felicitá has been promised to another man, and Ciro doesn’t have strong feelings for her, he “[imagines] he [is] in love with her” (152).


In Italy, Enza and Marco make plans to leave for the US. They’ll send money from their new jobs home to Giacomina to provide for the family and save for their own house. On their way down the mountain and away from home, Enza focuses on her future in the US.

Part 2, Chapter 12 Summary: “A Fountain Pen”

Enza and Marco board the SS Rochambeau for New York. Along the way, Enza becomes gravely ill. Marco stays at her bedside, terrified that he’ll lose another daughter. When they arrive in Manhattan, the doctor informs Marco that he’ll have to go through Ellis Island alone; Enza will be processed through the hospital, where she must recover before entering the city. Marco worries about being separated from her.


Meanwhile, Ciro settles into life with the Zanettis and adjusts to work at the shoe shop. He works tirelessly under Remo’s tutelage and befriends Carla. One day, Ciro seriously cuts his hand while working. The Zanettis race him to the hospital.


Enza wakes up in the hospital. The doctors nurse her back to health but inform her that she’ll never be able to board another ship again, or she’d risk death. Meanwhile, Marco goes through Ellis Island and tracks down Enza at the hospital. The news that Enza will never be able to return home devastates him, but he’s relieved that she’s alive. They also learn that Enza will be working across the Hudson River in Hoboken, New Jersey.


After the hospital staff tend to Ciro’s injury, he wanders into the chapel, where he runs into Enza. The two are shocked to see each other again. They catch up on all that has happened since their last meeting. Enza is delighted by the chance encounter but feels discouraged when Felicitá arrives to pick up Ciro. Enza says goodbye, convinced that Ciro’s heart belongs to another.

Part 2, Chapter 13 Summary: “A Wooden Clothespin”

Six years later, Ciro is finishing up his apprenticeship with Remo. He has thrived at the shoe shop and loves his work. Remo and Carla have grown attached to Ciro, too. In October 1916, Ciro receives a letter from Eduardo informing him that he has tracked down their mother. Caterina has been living at a convent hospital near San Nicola all these years; she had a nervous breakdown after Carlo’s death and hasn’t been well since then. Ciro struggles to process these revelations.


One day, Luigi appears at the shoe shop. He didn’t marry after all and left Ohio. Ciro convinces him to stay in Manhattan.


In Hoboken, Enza has been working and sending money home to her family. Marco left the East Coast for Pennsylvania, where he has been working in the coalfields. They’re close to affording their dream house, but Enza must continue working and saving. Her living and working conditions are abominable. Her sponsors, the Buffa family, are cruel and abusive. Her work at the factory is exhausting. Enza’s only pleasures are listening to Enrico Caruso records and spending time with Laura Heery, a friend and coworker. Both women are seamstresses and want to leave Hoboken for Manhattan. Together, they plot their escape, applying to women’s boardinghouses across the river.

Part 2, Chapter 14 Summary: “A Rope of Tinsel”

Enza and Laura attend the Columbus Day celebrations in Little Italy. While reveling in their freedom, Laura and Enza talk about romance. Enza has told her about Ciro, and Laura teases her about being in love with a gravedigger. Shocked to learn that Ciro lives locally, Laura insists on visiting Zanetti Shoe Shop to see him.


At the shop, Carla is initially skeptical of the girls. Then, Ciro returns to the shop with Felicitá and another horde of young people. He can’t stop looking at Enza throughout the encounter. Remo invites Laura and Enza to join their celebrations for the evening.


The group goes up to the Zanettis’ rooftop to see the fireworks. Enza and Ciro strike up a conversation and rekindle their connection. They talk about their lives in the US and their craftwork. Remembering her connection with Ciro, Enza professes her feelings unabashedly. She insists that he act more seriously if he’s really interested in her. She tells him where she lives, and he promises to call on her in a few weeks.

Part 2, Chapters 9-14 Analysis

Ciro’s and Enza’s arrivals in New York City initiate the novel’s thematic exploration of Immigrant Resilience and the Pursuit of the American Dream. Neither Ciro nor Enza travels to the US under entirely voluntary circumstances. Rather, hardship and necessity precipitate their departures from the Italian Alps. Ejected from the convent he called home since he was a child, Ciro agrees to voyage overseas to the US as his best option, since he’ll be safe from Don Gregorio and the Catholic Church and able to create a life and livelihood for himself. For Enza, leaving Schilpario is the last thing she imagines for her life. She envisioned residing on the mountain and caring for her family for the rest of her days. Leaving home for the US is a decision to help facilitate her family’s dream of having “a home of [their] own” in Italy (142). Neither Ciro nor Enza is driven by selfish desires or autonomous aspirations of adventure. Rather, the US offers hope for a new future that their realities at home couldn’t provide; still, traveling and orienting to life overseas requires faith, courage, and resilience.


Ciro and Enza face harrowing circumstances as they attempt to establish themselves in the US. Their difficulties again parallel one another’s, even before they know that their lives have led them to the same place. On board the SS Chicago, Ciro’s “heart ached for all he was leaving behind, especially the company and counsel of Eduardo, the person who had made him feel safe in the world” (120). Despite his heartbreak, he doesn’t give up, even negotiating with the ship crew to secure a decent job and wage along the way to Manhattan. On board the SS Rochambeau, Enza faces difficulties of her own. She becomes so sick that she’s “unable to lift her head or focus her gaze. […] Nausea rolled through her in waves. Sounds were deafening, each wave against the ship’s hull shattering within her ear like explosions of dynamite” (160). Her physical illness is a metaphor for her overarching hardship. She must remain strong despite her impossible circumstances and depleted state. The same is true once she settles into life in Hoboken, where she endures abuse at the hands of her employers and sponsors. Both her and Ciro’s forays into the US are defined by difficulty and require a healthy dose of delusion for survival. Ciro loses himself in his work and his relationship with Felicitá (all but ignoring the sorrow of the past), while Enza comforts herself with opera music and her connection with Laura. She, too, tries to stave off memories of her mother and siblings to avoid giving in to her sorrow and longing.


Ciro and Enza’s connection survives despite their difficulties, reiterating the theme of Love Enduring Through Hardship. Ciro and Enza have never been in a relationship or overtly professed their love for one another. However, their internal monologues throughout the novel convey their indelible bond. Even when years pass between their encounters, Ciro and Enza continue to think of each other. Their subsequent encounters at the hospital chapel and the shoe repair shop reignite their intense and mysterious feelings for one another, offering them hope for a different kind of future. Everything about their connection defies logic. They lived on the same mountain on the other side of the world from each other, and happenstance brought them both across the ocean to the same place in the US. This uncanny connection inspires them to hold out hope for true and lasting love, despite how unkind life has been to them.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 54 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs