The Spy and the Traitor: The Greatest Espionage Story of the Cold War

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. What aspects of Gordievsky’s story make it “the greatest espionage story of the Cold War,” as Macintyre’s subtitle claims? How does this real-life account compare to fictional spy narratives, like John le Carré’s Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy, or other works by Macintyre, such as Agent Zigzag?

2. The book opens on a scene in which Gordievsky realized that someone had entered his apartment when he noticed all three locks secured instead of just two. What expectations did this in medias res beginning create for your reading experience?

3. Which elements of “old-school” spycraft described in the book struck you as the most interesting or surprising?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Gordievsky’s exposure to Western culture through music, literature, and freedom of expression gradually changed his ideological beliefs. What experiences have profoundly altered your perspective on something you once took for granted?

2. The constant vigilance that Gordievsky practiced involved checking for surveillance, memorizing escape routes, and maintaining cover stories. When have you experienced sustained periods of heightened alertness in your life?

3. Gordievsky kept his wife, Leila, completely in the dark about his espionage activities. Consider a time when you discovered something significant about someone close to you that changed your perception of them.

4. Throughout the period the book describes, Gordievsky made decisions based on his belief in democracy and freedom rather than material gain. What principles would motivate you to take significant risks?

5. The psychological burden of Gordievsky’s double life included constant fear of detection. When have you had to compartmentalize different aspects of your life? What strategies did you develop?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. Operation RYAN revealed how deeply Soviet leaders feared a Western nuclear first strike. What does this paranoia tell us about how closed societies can develop distorted views of their adversaries?

2. Both MI6 and the KGB operated under different justifications for their intelligence methods. What determines acceptable tactics in intelligence gathering across different political systems?

3. Gordievsky’s intelligence directly influenced Thatcher’s and Reagan’s approaches to the Soviet Union. What does this suggest about the role individuals can play in major historical events?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. Macintyre portrays Aldrich Ames as a foil to Gordievsky, contrasting their motivations and character. What techniques does the author use to differentiate these two spies despite their both being traitors?

2. The book’s structure builds toward the escape in Part 3 as earlier sections establish Gordievsky’s character and significance. What effect does this organization have on the narrative tension?

3. Throughout the text, Macintyre shifts between broad historical context and intimate personal details. How did this movement between perspectives enhance your understanding of both Gordievsky and the Cold War?

4. Macintyre adopts a minute-by-minute approach with time stamps and location headings in Chapter 14. What did this stylistic shift contribute to your experience of the escape sequence?

5. In what ways do trust and betrayal manifest in the book’s themes and across different relationships in the book?

6. The book contains numerous instances of irony, such as when Gordievsky unknowingly meets his betrayer Aldrich Ames. Why are these moments particularly powerful in a story about espionage?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. If you wrote a letter from Leila to Oleg after she learns of his defection, what complex emotions would the letter express?

2. If you were adapting this book into a film, which scenes would be essential to include and why?

3. Create a brief internal monologue from one of the MI6 agents during the tense border crossing when Gordievsky is hidden in the trunk.

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources.