56 pages • 1-hour read
Evie WoodsA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of sexual violence and harassment, child death, death by suicide, and animal cruelty and death.
Alone in her cottage, Sarah feels anxious about a missed call from Jack on her phone. Resisting the urge to numb her feelings with alcohol, she orders a cab to Fee’s farmhouse. Fee welcomes her and explains her long-running agreement with Marcus to always look out for stranded visitors.
Over tea, Sarah speaks openly about her failed marriage and the stillbirth of her daughter, Emma. In a flashback, she recalls the placental abruption, the silent delivery, and the painful, emotional aftermath that drove her and Jack apart. Fee listens, then brews a fresh cup of tea using hawthorn berries and rose petals, calling it her remedy for heartbreak. The warmth of the drink and the comfort of the ritual steady Sarah, who feels a surge of hope as she links the hawthorn in the cup to the sacred tree that drew her to Ireland.
Anna and Father Peter arrive at the county jail, where the guard refuses to let Anna see Harold. Father Peter gains access alone and returns to tell her that Harold has confessed to a scuffle in which George died. He explains that the police found Anna’s pearls at the river and suspected her of the crime. Harold confessed to shield her from a society that condemns women who survive sexual assault rather than the perpetrators.
Determined to clear Harold’s name, Anna goes to Thornwood House and demands to see Olivia. In the library, Olivia accuses Anna of seducing both George and Harold and causing George’s death. Anna denies this and argues for Harold’s innocence, asking Olivia to intervene. Lord Hawley appears and orders Anna out of the house. Anna leaves shaken but determined to clear Harold’s name.
In the days following, Anna collects her brother Billy from the Gallaghers’ house and stays for supper. Exhausted, she falls into bed with a fever, plagued by dreams of George drowning. She regains consciousness two days later, and Rosie Gallagher tells her that authorities are transporting Harold to Dublin for trial. When Anna confides that Harold took the blame to protect her, Rosie implies that George also assaulted her, noting how class privilege shields such men.
Back home, Anna learns that Paddy overheard her fevered murmurings about her assault and has contacted Danny of the Irish Republican Brotherhood to plan a rescue. Her parents explain that the men intend to intercept Harold’s train at Brookledge station. Feeling powerless, Anna prays to her deceased sister, Milly, to save Harold.
After her talk with Fee, Sarah walks the Cnoc na Sí forest trail, reflecting on her grief. Her sister, Meghan, calls from New York, and Sarah admits she has feelings for someone in Ireland. When she sees Oran approaching with his dog, she ends the call.
Sarah and Oran greet each other warmly. Oran invites her to walk, and they hold hands along the trail. At a viewpoint overlooking Thornwood, he kisses her. Sarah tells him about Emma’s stillbirth, explaining that Anna’s diary helped her understand her own guilt and pain. Oran describes grief as a maze people must navigate and offers steady support. They hold each other, sharing a quiet moment of comfort.
Paddy returns home and recounts the events of the rescue. He tells Anna that Danny and the IRB men caused a diversion at Brookledge station with escaped pigs while the engine billowed steam, blinding the guards. In the confusion, they pulled Harold from the train. Paddy says Harold is already on his way to Cork to board a ship to the United States.
Anna reels at the thought of losing him without a goodbye, but Paddy hands her a letter, written by Harold before he left. Alone, she reads Harold’s words, in which he confesses his love and promises to arrange her passage to the US so they can build a future together.
Sarah finishes Anna’s diary, discovering Harold’s original letter and the unused ship ticket tucked into the back cover. Oran arrives in the rain, and Sarah invites him in for Fee’s herbal tea. He admits he has punished himself since his wife’s death and says Sarah has helped him change course. He shares what his grandfather told him about Anna’s fate: Her mother died shortly after Harold left, and Anna stayed to care for her family. Harold sent tickets every year, but Anna never used them. After the World War I, she married Danny.
Oran adds that Olivia died alone and Thornwood House fell into ruin. He asks Sarah about her plans. She tells him she needs time, and he promises to wait.
On June 20, 2011, in New York City, Sarah prepares for her art exhibition opening. Her drawings of the fairies, based on Harold Griffin-Krauss’s research, mark a new phase in her work. Jack arrives to help, their easy friendship anchoring them. They acknowledge their shared past and recall their visit to Emma’s grave after Sarah returned from Ireland.
The gallery doorbell rings, and Sarah finds Oran at the entrance. Surprised and pleased, she thanks him for coming, and he notes that she “sent the ticket” (358). She embraces him. She sent no ticket, but his arrival feels like coming home.
The novel’s final section shifts the act of story collecting from passive reception to active creation, evidencing The Healing Power of Storytelling. Sarah’s arc begins with the consumption of a story—the legend of the hawthorn tree in a newspaper, followed by her immersion in Anna’s diary. This engagement with another’s past provides a necessary psychological buffer, allowing her to approach her own trauma indirectly. The climax of her healing, however, occurs when she transitions from reader to teller. Her confession to Fee about Emma’s stillbirth is the first time she articulates her own story without the filter of Anna’s parallel experience. This verbalization externalizes her grief, transforming it from an internal, paralyzing force into a communicable narrative. Fee’s role as a folkloric healer, dispensing a hawthorn-and-rose-petal tea, literalizes this process. The hawthorn, the initial symbol that drew Sarah to Ireland, becomes a tangible element in her recovery. Fee’s description of the preparation as a “DIY heart-repair kit” (312) frames folk tradition as a living, therapeutic practice. Sarah’s final act—the creation of her art exhibition “The Story Collector”—completes this thematic arc. She synthesizes the stories she’s absorbed and transforms them into a new, public narrative, reclaiming her identity as an artist.
These concluding chapters resolve the parallel character arcs of Anna and Sarah by moving both women from positions of disempowerment to decisive agency. Initially, Anna is a survivor of George’s assault, of a patriarchal society, and of a legal system that unjustly imprisons Harold. Her confrontation with Olivia marks a pivotal shift. Despite being verbally assaulted and dismissed as a “peasant girl” (323), Anna refuses to be silenced, defending Harold’s innocence and asserting her own truth. Sarah’s arc mirrors this trajectory. She arrives in Ireland, paralyzed by unspoken grief, using alcohol to manage her panic attacks. Her turning point is an active confession—first to Fee, then to Oran. By articulating her guilt and sorrow regarding Emma’s death, she takes control of her own narrative and dismantles the emotional silence that destroyed her marriage. For both protagonists, the catalyst for this empowerment involves another person, but the ultimate change is internal. Their resolutions diverge—Anna chooses duty to family, while Sarah embraces a new relationship—but both outcomes are products of conscious, self-directed choice.
The narrative’s dual-timeline structure converges and resolves in this final section, underscoring The Lingering Influence of the Past on the Present. Throughout the novel, the past has acted as an active, often disruptive, force, with the secrets of 1911 shaping the emotional and physical landscape of 2011. In these chapters, the structure demonstrates that confronting and understanding this influence is the key to resolution. The climax of Anna’s plotline—Harold’s arrest and dramatic escape—is presented as the missing piece of Sarah’s contemporary puzzle. When Sarah finishes the diary, the story is incomplete. The narrative thread is then picked up by Oran, whose family’s oral history provides the epilogue to Anna’s life. This seamless transition from a written, first-person account to an oral, third-person one highlights the different forms that story collecting takes and reinforces the idea that history is a communal, living entity. The resolution of Anna’s story is the direct catalyst for Sarah and Oran’s own emotional honesty. Once the past is fully uncovered, its haunting power dissipates, allowing the characters to move forward toward a new future.
This resolution also crystallizes the novel’s exploration of The Interplay of Fate and Personal Agency. The narrative consistently blurs the line between mystical intervention and human will, suggesting they are intertwined rather than mutually exclusive. The rescue of Harold from the train at Brookledge station provides an example of human agency triumphing over institutional power. In contrast to the supernatural swarm of bees that saved Anna, this rescue is a product of meticulous human planning, relying on rebel strategy, escaped pigs, and the mechanics of a steam engine. It is a moment grounded in historical reality—the burgeoning Irish Republican movement—and demonstrates a collective will to defy an unjust fate. Yet, the novel’s final scene returns to the unexplained. Oran arrives in New York with a plane ticket that Sarah admits “she hadn’t sent at all” (357). This uncanny event serves as a final, quiet affirmation of the unseen forces at work in the characters’ lives. It suggests that while human choices are essential, there may be fated forces that conspire to guide them. The narrative does not prioritize one over the other; instead, it posits a worldview in which fate creates pathways, but individuals must possess the agency to walk them.
In the conclusion, Anna’s diary, the central symbol connecting the two timelines, completes its function as a vessel of buried truth. Once its contents are absorbed by Sarah and supplemented by Oran’s oral history, its physical remnants—the letter and the unused ticket—serve as artifacts of a resolved past. The hawthorn tree symbol also completes its arc, transforming from a mythic concept that sparks Sarah’s journey into a tangible agent of healing in Fee’s tea. This movement from macro-symbol to micro-application renders the folklore personal and practical. Finally, the motif of story collecting is shown to be a multi-generational process. Harold’s academic collection gives way to Anna’s personal diary, which is completed by the Sweeney family’s oral tradition and ultimately transmuted into Sarah’s visual art. Each form is a necessary layer of the same essential human practice: the preservation and reinterpretation of experience to make sense of loss and find a way forward. Sarah’s realization that guilt is a barrier to grieving is the direct result of this cumulative storytelling, positioning these narratives as vital tools for confronting reality.



Unlock all 56 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.