The Unlikely Pilgrimage of Harold Fry

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of mental illness, substance use, suicidal ideation, self harm, and death.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. Harold’s journey begins with a simple walk to the mailbox that transforms into a 627-mile pilgrimage. How did this unplanned approach to his journey shape your response to the novel, and what does it suggest about how life-changing decisions often occur?

2. Rachel Joyce’s novel has been compared to pilgrim narratives like Paulo Coelho’s The Alchemist, though Harold’s journey is decidedly more modest and, according to the title, “unlikely.” If you’ve read other journey narratives, how does Harold’s pilgrimage differ in its approach to self-discovery and meaning?

3. Throughout the novel, Joyce weaves moments of unexpected humor into a story primarily about grief and regret. In what ways did this balance of light and dark elements affect your reading experience, and which moments stood out as particularly effective?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Harold’s journey is sparked by a garage attendant who tells him, “if you have faith, you can do anything” (15), leading to his spontaneous decision to walk across England. This transformative moment recalls similar catalysts in books like Cheryl Strayed’s Wild, where a chance encounter leads to a life-changing trek. Reflect on a time when a brief conversation or unexpected meeting altered your own path in life.

2. Throughout his walk, Harold meets strangers who readily share their deepest secrets with him, from the silver-haired gentleman to the woman with self-harm scars. Why do you think people felt comfortable confiding in Harold, and have you ever found yourself opening up to someone unexpected during a transitional time in your life?

3. When Harold examines old photographs, he discovers that he had shown physical affection to David, contrary to what he had believed for decades. How has your perception of past events or relationships been challenged by physical evidence like photographs or letters?

4. Maureen’s compulsive cleaning represents her attempt to scrub away grief, while Harold’s walking becomes his method of processing pain. What physical activities have helped you work through difficult emotions, and why do you think bodily movement can sometimes access feelings that remain blocked otherwise?

5. Harold observes that “it was the smallness of people that filled him with the wonder and tenderness, and the loneliness of that too” (158). How has recognizing the ordinary struggles of others affected your own perspective on human connection and community?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. Harold’s simple walk transforms into a media sensation, with journalists camping outside Maureen’s house and strangers joining his pilgrimage for their own purposes. How does the novel critique modern society’s tendency to commodify and sensationalize personal stories, and where do you see similar patterns today?

2. The novel touches on David’s depression and substance abuse, suggesting that Harold and Maureen lacked adequate resources to help him. How has societal understanding of and support for mental health challenges evolved since the time period depicted in the novel?

3. Throughout his journey, Harold encounters people across various social classes and backgrounds, from the wealthy silver-haired gentleman to the doctor Martina. What does the novel suggest about how class, nationality, and economic status influence human connection in contemporary British society?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. The novel alternates between Harold’s physical journey and Maureen’s emotional evolution at home. How does this parallel structure enhance our understanding of their marriage, and what insights do we gain from seeing both perspectives?

2. Joyce uses nature as both setting and symbol throughout the novel. How does the progression of seasons from spring to summer mirror Harold’s internal transformation, and what specific natural elements serve as meaningful motifs?

3. Harold’s yachting shoes become increasingly battered throughout his journey, yet he stubbornly refuses to replace them. In what ways do his deteriorating shoes function as a symbol for aspects of his character and emotional state?

4. Memory serves as both comfort and torment for the characters, with Harold noting at one point that “sometimes he believed he had become more memory than present” (161). How does Joyce use memory as a literary device to reveal character development and advance the narrative?

5. While Harold physically journeys across England, Maureen undergoes her own transformation through her friendship with Rex and renewed interest in gardening. How do these contrasting paths to healing complement each other, and what do they suggest about different ways of processing grief?

6. The novel is primarily told from Harold and Maureen’s points of view but briefly shifts to Queenie’s perspective at the end. How does this narrative choice affect your understanding of the characters and their interconnected stories?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. Harold’s journey takes him through countless villages and towns across England. Which location from the novel resonated most strongly with you, and what sensory experiences would draw you to that place if you had the opportunity to visit?

2. The forgotten joke that makes Harold and Maureen laugh at the end of the novel remains a mystery to readers. What moment of connection do you believe could have such lasting power between two people across decades of marriage?

3. Harold collects meaningful mementos for Queenie throughout his journey. What three objects would best represent your own life’s journey thus far, and why do these items hold special significance?

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources