51 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of pregnancy loss.
Angelo moved to Milan a month ago, and he invites Jess and Laura to visit. Jess decides to be spontaneous and agrees to go. They take a train, and Laura has worn herself out, just like Phil, so she sleeps while Jess nurses her guilt at not being home for Christmas to be her family’s “workhorse.” She usually does the tree, the shopping, the gift-wrapping, and the cookies. Jess considers sending a card, but she is serious about changing things, and she doesn’t want to fall back into old patterns. Conor texts to tell her that Googs was sentenced to two years in prison. She came to Italy for a “better life,” and she doesn’t want to crawl back into her parents’ cellar ever again.
When Laura wakes up, they talk about Angelo. Laura tells Jess that she had multiple pregnancy losses prior to delivering Angelo, and Jess admits that she, too, lost a pregnancy. Jess says it destroyed her, even though it was so early in the pregnancy, and she never told her mother or sister about it. She didn’t even get to tell Bobby she was pregnant before the pregnancy loss occurred. He was understanding, but he didn’t know how to help Jess. She excuses herself and goes outside to cry, to mourn all she’s lost. When she returns to their seats, Laura is asleep again.
Jess journals about her family’s traditional Feast of Seven Fishes. Each year, all the Baratta families gathered in Grammy B’s kitchen to draw for fish. Each of seven homes would serve one fish, and then the group would end up at Louie and Lil’s for dessert. One year, when Jess was eight, Louie talked about learning to mine the marble in Carrara and the brotherhood that developed among the workers. She felt certain that he’d get her to Italy someday.
Back in the present, Jess thinks Milan is beautiful. Angelo bought his mother tickets to the opera, and he plans to take Jess to meet Beppe Novelli, another gilder whom Laura dismisses as eccentric. Nonetheless, Angelo and Jess go to his workshop, and Beppe gives Angelo a hard time about Dalia; Angelo says they aren’t together anymore.
Jess asks Beppe why Laura dislikes him so much. He explains that he dated her sister, Bette, when they were young. He knew it wouldn’t work out, so he acted “crazy” to make her break it off with him. Jess watches Beppe work, and he explains that traditions can only survive when other things change. On their way out, Angelo takes her hand.
Angelo drives Jess through the Italian Alps to Vilminore di Scalve, a small village with a Baroque cathedral. Unlike at home, they will fast on Christmas Eve and feast on Christmas Day. Jess thinks of the “easily assigned” roles for men and women in her family and how “no one questioned them” (283). She misses their traditions but hopes to “reinvent” some. After the mass, they drive back to Milan, and Angelo confesses that he broke up with Dalia because he likes Jess. She reflects on the peace she’s found in Italy and kisses him on the cheek.
Jess takes a bus to Italy’s Lake Como, needing solitude and clarity on her feelings for Angelo. She joins a group headed to the waterfalls that feed the lake. Farah texts to say that she went to visit her mother, who has completely accepted her as a daughter. As the group approaches a suspension bridge, Jess wants to turn back. She pushes herself forward, though, and her courage is rewarded by the beauty of the falls. Jess texts Lil, saying she found peace on earth, and Lil is thrilled for her. She texts her siblings a picture and feels full of hope for her own healing in the year ahead.
That night, Jess dreams about a loving, powerful man. When she wakes up, however, she can’t remember who he was. She goes back to sleep and wakes up hopeful. She decides to emulate Lucy Honeychurch and be the heroine of her own story.
When Jess arrives in the lobby, Bobby Bilancia is there, waiting for her. He tracked her down from Carrara. She tells him that she’s happy in Italy, and he says she belongs in New Jersey. She asks why he came, and he says he needs to understand what happened between them. He says he didn’t try hard enough, that he should have been kinder. Just then, Angelo walks in, and both men immediately begin posturing. Angelo suggests that Jess has been dishonest, but she confirms that she is not in a relationship with either one. Conor and Gaetano arrive, and Angelo storms off.
After dinner that night, Jess and Bobby go for a walk. He kisses her, but there is no spark. He asks if they should try again, but Jess knows it won’t work. She accompanies him back to Milan for his flight home. Jess looks forward to spending some time alone: “No drama, no confusion, just a feeling of peace” (306). She does miss Angelo though.
It is now March, and Jess has been working for Mauro for three months. Her texts to Angelo have gone unanswered, so she assumes he’s no longer interested. Campovilla says that the final report on the Elegant Gangster will be finished soon. Jess and Farah go into Mauro’s office, where Jess sees an old photograph that includes her uncle, Louie. When Mauro reenters, Farah asks who the man is, and Mauro says it’s his father. They leave for lunch at his mother’s, and he says that his father, “Luigi,” died before he was born. When Jess sees Mauro’s mother, Claudia, she realizes this is the woman from some of Louie’s old pictures and the love Louie spoke of on his deathbed.
Claudia tells the group that, according to her father, Luigi died in a mining accident. He was American, and they fell in love and planned to marry. Claudia found out she was pregnant after Luigi’s death. Jess feels sick. Later, she tells Dr. Scott from Thera-Me what she learned. He asks how this secret affects Jess, and he suggests she needn’t bring Mauro into the family fold. She tries to explain the importance of family and of knowing the truth, even if it’s painful. Angelo wants to talk, but Jess isn’t in the mood. She’s confused by his behavior, and he says he doesn’t text his feelings. He wants to know how he can make things right with her.
The next day, Angelo picks Jess up and drives her to Mauro’s quarry. She asks if this is the right thing to do, and he says that she can keep the secret or share the truth. They arrive at Claudia’s, and Jess reveals that “Luigi” (Uncle Louie) lived and went home to New Jersey; he didn’t die in a mining accident. Claudia is shocked that her father lied, and Mauro gets angry that Louie never returned for Claudia. Jess points out that they cannot know what Claudia’s father told him. She plans to tell Lil about Mauro, but she’s not sure how yet. When Mauro learns that Louie died recently, he feels that his tragedy is doubled.
Angelo and Jess go to the cemetery where Claudia’s father set up a memorial for all the men who died at the quarry. She says that Louie understood her, the same way Angelo does, and Angelo confesses that he’s in love with Jess. She tells him that she’s not ready, and he says he will wait. When she gets home, Joe calls to tell her that Lil died and that it’s time to come home.
Jess continues to embrace Independence as a Catalyst for Transformation in this section and can now say, “I am at peace” (292), while celebrating the progress she has made so far. As she looks out over Lake Como, Italy, she realizes that her refusal to conform to her family’s expectations led her to where she truly wanted to be. She chose to act independently, to be courageous, instead of enacting the same patterns that made her unhappy and even angry in a life that made her feel stuck. Now, she thinks, “A year ago, I couldn’t imagine a holiday away from home, and this year, I’m happier than I ever have been in my life” (292). Living on her own in Italy therefore enables Jess to grow confident in her own abilities, giving her a strong sense of agency that she never had before.
Jess also demonstrates her newfound confidence and agency in the way she navigates her love life. While she could have fallen back into a familiar dynamic with Angelo, she instead puts his feelings to the side so that she can more closely examine her own, without pressure or hurry. Even when she knows she is attracted to him, when he stops answering her texts for a while, she simply accepts it and busies herself with her own life and hobbies, demonstrating her lack of need for validation and approval from others. In a similar vein, Bobby’s sudden reappearance and desire for reconciliation does not undermine Jess’s newfound habits of mind and behavior: She knows there is no hope for them, and so instead of passively leading him on, she tells him openly how she feels and urges him to return home. Free of everyone else’s expectations, she reflects, “This is what Uncle Louie meant when he told me to be happy. Pay attention to the moments you live in and find your place in them. Be content with your portion” (292). Knowing what she truly wants helps Jess to be more honest about her emotions and to establish firm boundaries with others.
After Jess learns that Louie is Mauro’s father, she agonizes over what to do with this new knowledge, introducing the theme of The Damaging Nature of Family Secrets. Through her own reflections and growth, Jess has realized that secrets have sometimes played a damaging role in her own life. For example, she never knew her parents were overprotective because she was in the NICU for seven weeks, which she thinks may have helped her to understand her own anxiety better. Now, having learned a new family secret about Louie, Jess debates whether it is better to divulge the truth. In making her decision, Jess thinks carefully about what choice feels best for her, demonstrating how in tune she now is with her feelings and values.
Jess also shows that she is moving toward a better, more balanced relationship with her family in this section, which once more speaks to her growing confidence in navigating relationships. She tells one of the doctors at Thera-Me that family is at the center of her life: “It’s our reality, our truth, our facts—which belong to the group. Over these months, I’ve been working hard to come up with a plan that helps me embrace my kin, flaws and all, along with any dreams and hopes I have for my own life” (318). Jess cannot move forward for herself if she cannot find a way to move forward within her family relationships. She knows that, “The truth matters in this situation. […] I came to Italy to find out why I am who I am. My cousin Mauro is part of the story now” (318). As painful as it might be to reveal Mauro’s existence, especially now that Lil has died, Jess knows that family secrets do more harm than good. In deciding to be true to what she thinks is right, Jess takes on a stronger, more active role in her family dynamics.



Unlock all 51 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.