64 pages • 2-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of death and substance use.
The motif of death links to the theme of The Unresolved Past Haunting the Present. Paul philosophizes about death and what it means both for the deceased and the living. As tragedy colors both his professional and personal lives, Paul cultivates an attitude about death that helps comfort him throughout these troubling events: “And to me death is death—final, the end, nothing coming after, the finish line, no more” (140). Paul views death as the definitive end of a person’s life and influence, which is a concept meant to help him rebuild and still live a fulfilling life. However, this perspective becomes complicated when deaths are mysterious or untimely, like Camille’s murder and Jane’s terminal illness. Although their physical bodies are dead (or, in Camille’s case, assumed dead), the uncertain and shameful circumstances surrounding their deaths prevent Paul from moving on entirely. In both cases, Paul has a lingering sense of culpability for abandoning the women he loved in their time of need, so he can’t accept that they’re gone forever and that he can’t be absolved or redeemed.
Other characters weaponize the belief in death’s finality against Paul to prevent him from digging into the past. Ira, for example, uses his last words to tell Paul that Camille is dead because he believes this will force Paul to abandon his quest for answers: “It’s over. The dead are gone. The living are safe” (336). Similarly, Sosh pleads with Paul to let the dead rest. Both men think the Camp PLUS murders happened so long ago that Paul should have moved on by now, and his continued questions only threaten to resurrect old wounds for those who have tried to move on.
Music is a motif that helps illuminate the characters’ relationships with one another and with themselves. In particular, music helps the Silversteins deal with trauma and overwhelming emotions. The text frequently describes Ira listening to music from the 1960s because it was a comfortable, happy decade for him. He’s extremely sensitive, so doctors encourage him to immerse himself in whatever makes him feel safe. For example, the text introduces Ira listening to The Grass Roots’ “Let’s Live for Today” from 1967. Songs like this were released before the murders, and Ira listens to them to trick his mind into forgetting that these traumatic events ever occurred.
Conversely, Lucy uses music to torment herself into reliving her pain and heartbreak. Ever since the murders and her breakup with Paul, Lucy has felt emotionally stunted and alone. She spends her evenings listening to depressing songs and drinking, hoping to get “a feeling. A rush of emotion. A high or low, didn’t matter” (157). Lucy uses songs and their lyrics to express what she can’t say. For example, she emails Paul a Bruce Springsteen song, and the lyrics describe her feelings after they reconnect: “Bruce sang about indifference and regrets, about all he’s thrown away and lost and longs for again and then he achingly begs to be back in her arms” (290). Music is inextricably linked to Lucy’s relationship with Paul. They have “their songs” that they always listened to with one another and that both associate with old emotions of love.
The woods near Camp PLUS are both a physical and symbolic setting. Inextricably linked to the horrific murders, the woods become a site and symbol both of mystery and pain. The characters believe the woods continue to hold the suffering and grief of the murders, as if the screams of the deceased teens continue to echo among the trees. Locals create ghost stories and terrifying legends about the woods to make sense of the eerie feeling the location produces. These stories illustrate how the woods’ symbolism of fear and uncertainty extends far beyond those directly involved in the mystery and into public consciousness. Characters speak about and remember nighttime in the woods, which intensifies feelings of obscurity and the unknown. In addition, the physical size of the woods amplifies connections between the setting and the uncertainty of the crime. The woods were simply too large for search parties to ever find Gil and Camille’s bodies, which is why questions remained unanswered about the crime for so long. Similarly, Paul’s quest for the truth appears virtually impossible to him because of the many unknowns.



Unlock the meaning behind every key symbol & motif
See how recurring imagery, objects, and ideas shape the narrative.