Tough Guy

Rachel Reid

48 pages 1-hour read

Rachel Reid

Tough Guy

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2020

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Symbols & Motifs

Hockey

Throughout the novel, hockey operates as a motif of Toughness as a Professional Role That Corrodes the Self. One of the primary characters, Ryan, has played hockey since he was a boy and thus identifies with the sport. In the narrative present, he is an enforcer for the Toronto Guardians, a role that requires him to be strong, imposing, and often violent. Ryan has “been quietly out for years, which mean[s] he d[oes]n’t actively hide his sexuality, but he d[oes]n’t talk about it either” (17). Few of Ryan’s teammates think to ask him about his sexuality or relationships, either, because Ryan hides behind his enforcer position. He understands that hockey players—no matter their sexuality—are expected to be tough. Ryan prefers to shield his more reserved side and anxious tendencies behind his hockey reputation. If people see him as “Pay-the-Price” enforcer Ryan Price, they are less likely to interrogate his mental health or deride him for being gay. Being a stereotypically masculine NHL star is a more acceptable identity.


Fabian urges Ryan to leave the world of professional hockey because he fears that Ryan’s job is compromising his true identity. He worries about Ryan’s mental, physical, and emotional health—aware that he is playing a part on the ice. Ryan goes so far as to take painkillers to numb his back injury so that no one will suspect him of being weak. Fabian challenges Ryan to embrace who he really is and let go of a profession that is endangering him. When Ryan does ultimately quit, he lets go of his facade and accepts his true self.

Fabian’s Music

Fabian’s music is a symbol of Vulnerability as the Key to Authentic Masculine Identity. He has studied music and played the violin for many years. He is so musically talented that he was offered a spot on the Toronto Symphony. Although honored, Fabian gave up the position to pursue his own solo career. His relationship with his craft conveys his willingness to be vulnerable, show emotion, and express himself freely. When Ryan hears him perform at the Lighthouse for the first time, he is overwhelmed by the beauty of Fabian’s performance:


It was the most beautiful thing Ryan had ever heard; haunting in a way that sent sparks dancing down Ryan’s spine and into his abdomen. Fabian’s voice was kind of soft and high, but also clear and confident. The music could probably be called pop, but it was so complex that Ryan wasn’t sure it fit any category (49).


Diction including “beautiful,” “haunting,” “sparks,” “dancing,” “soft,” “high,” “clear,” and “confident” conveys the nuance and depth of Fabian’s music. The same is true of Fabian’s character and expression of masculinity. He is not easily categorizable because he presents in a more androgynous way. He is also soft-hearted and kind while being self-assured and outspoken. Fabian is unafraid to express his sexuality and embodies Ryan’s perfect guy: someone who discards stereotypes and is authentically himself despite what his family and society expect of him.

Furniture

The furniture that Ryan buys for his apartment is a symbol of commitment and change. For years, Ryan has been traded from team to team, moving from city to city without ever feeling settled. Because of this pattern with his work, Ryan feels reluctant to commit to his life in Toronto when he first starts playing for the Toronto Guardians. He tells his sister that “[t]here’s no point in buying furniture if [he’s] just gonna be traded again” (70). However, this way of life precludes Ryan from feeling at home. He doesn’t allow himself to get comfortable or even seek belonging because he is afraid of having to let go of whatever life he creates.


When he decides to order IKEA furniture in Toronto, he makes a decision to commit to his new life—even if it means having to leave it someday. Just adding the “items to his cart” grants him a sense of excitement (70). Furnishing his apartment is Ryan’s way of creating room for newness and possibility. He doesn’t think he’s ready to start dating again, but buying furniture shows that he is beginning to imagine inviting someone over and letting someone into his life.

Pearl Necklace

The pearl necklace that Ryan gives to Fabian for Christmas is a symbol of love and connection. The necklace is Ryan’s way of telling Fabian what he means to him. He isn’t accustomed to buying gifts for a significant other but guesses that Fabian will appreciate the pearls given his particular style. They show that he is attentive to Fabian’s identity and self-expression. Fabian is moved by the gift because he has never had such nice jewelry before. He is also taken by the gift because the necklace has such permanence—it isn’t something disposable that he can get rid of or easily forget, much like his relationship with Ryan.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock the meaning behind every key symbol & motif

See how recurring imagery, objects, and ideas shape the narrative.

  • Explore how the author builds meaning through symbolism
  • Understand what symbols & motifs represent in the text
  • Connect recurring ideas to themes, characters, and events