48 pages • 1-hour read
Twice
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Character Analysis
Alfie Logan
Alfie is the protagonist of the novel. He is both gifted and burdened with the ability to rewind time and relive moments of his life, giving him the power to alter outcomes and confront the consequences of his choices. This ability places him at the intersection of human desire, moral responsibility, and divine order, and the story explores the tension between personal will and fate through his character. Alfie is defined by both his curiosity and his longing: He is fascinated by the possibilities of what could be yet increasingly aware of the moral and emotional costs of trying to control life. This tension relates to the theme of Changing Fate and Interfering with Divine Design, as his mother reflects, “I want, and you want, and God does what God wants” (154). Through his gift, Alfie experiences the illusion of control, yet he repeatedly discovers that some events cannot be rewritten, reinforcing the novel’s points on destiny and consequence.
Alfie’s emotional journey is equally central to the theme of Accepting One’s Life, Mistakes, and Mortality. From a young age, he grapples with grief and regret, particularly over the deaths of his mother and his friend Wesley. He reflects, “Looking back, I suppose I was depressed. I had lost Wesley as I had lost my mother. Both too young. Both too soon” (79), a line that communicates his early confrontation with mortality and the inevitability of human suffering. These experiences shape his character, prompting moments of introspection and moral questioning and gradually leading him to a more nuanced understanding of love, loss, and the limits of control. Over time, Alfie transitions from an impulsive rewinder to a man capable of restraint, recognizing that not all moments should be altered.
His relationship with Gianna is based in the theme of True Love’s Ability to Endure and serves as the emotional anchor of his development. Alfie’s repeated attempts to perfect his shared experiences with her teach him that love’s authenticity is preserved not through manipulation but through acceptance. He comes to realize, “For the first time in all the years of my magical undoings, I left everything as it was, because another truth in The Truth About True Love is that when it’s good, you don’t want to alter it” (163). This decision reflects his growth in emotional intelligence, showing that true love thrives when allowed to exist freely within the natural flow of life. By mixing his personal experiences with fantastical elements, the story positions Alfie as both a romantic hero and a moral agent, illustrating the common human struggle to balance desire, responsibility, and acceptance. Alfie’s journey is one of profound growth, as he moves from seeking control over life and fate to embracing its unpredictability.
Gianna Rule
Gianna Rule is Alfie’s true love and the emotional core of his journey. She represents constancy, forgiveness, and the enduring nature of deep emotional bonds. Her significance is intertwined with Alfie’s growth, as she provides the mirror through which he measures his actions and intentions. Gianna’s presence emphasizes the theme of True Love’s Ability to Endure, as even after multiple lifetimes, the two always manage to find and connect with one another. Alfie met Gianna in Kenya when they were both children, and they used to play with a local elephant together. Even at that young age, they discussed marriage, a home, and love. Gianna is the single most important and powerful motivator in Alfie’s life, and in everything he does, he thinks of how she would see it. As Alfie reflects, “Of all the things that had happened to me twice, she was the best” (235). Even amid time reversals and mistakes, her influence shapes Alfie’s understanding of genuine affection and patience, of love, and of life itself.
Beyond romance, Gianna represents stability and moral clarity. While Alfie wrestles with the chaos of manipulating time, Gianna remains anchored in reality, illustrating that true love endures both supernatural and ordinary trials. When Alfie becomes lost in the throes of fame, Gianna reminds him of how meaningless it is. Her character demonstrates that love requires recognition of imperfection, which relates with the theme of Accepting One’s Life, Mistakes, and Mortality. Through Gianna’s unwavering presence, Alfie is able to reconcile his desires with the limits of human control and divine design and with the mistakes of his past. In the end, Gianna is the only person to truly believe Alfie’s gift is real, and in wishing for a do-over, she acquires his power when he dies of a stroke. She reverses time to the day they met in the rain, and their love story begins again.
Vincent LaPorta
The detective Vincent LaPorta is an archetype of the investigative figure in the story, as his professional goal to discover how Alfie won an extraordinarily lucky sum of money while gambling becomes a personal quest to understand Alfie’s journey. He represents rationality, societal order, and the moral consequences of actions. Vincent’s significance lies in grounding the fantastical elements of Alfie’s life with accountability, reminding Alfie of real-world limits and adding a mystery subplot to his story. Vincent’s interactions with Alfie illuminate ethical considerations surrounding time manipulation, as he acts as an external conscience and catalyst for reflection. At the same time, Vincent continually doubts Alfie’s claims, forcing him to prove them.
Through Vincent, the theme of Changing Fate and Interfering with Divine Design is explored. The detective’s methodical approach contrasts with Alfie’s impulsive rewinds, emphasizing the tension between human control and natural or divine order. Vincent also provides narrative suspense and structure, guiding Alfie through moral and emotional epiphanies and emphasizing that choices carry weight beyond personal desire.
Alfie’s Father, Mother, and Grandmother
Alfie’s parents are central to his emotional formation and serve as sources of guidance, loss, and the foundation of his moral compass. His mother, in particular, embodies nurturing and ethical awareness, which Alfie recalls with deep admiration. Although he learned that his mother once lived a different, less moral life, he admired her decision to go back and redo it all in a healthier way. Through his life, Alfie honored his mother with his piano playing: “I played piano on Sundays in a nearby church, which would have made my mother happy” (269). Alfie got his gift from his mother, and she warned him not only to avoid using it for money, but to avoid abusing his power at all. Alfie ignored this warning, which led to despair, as did ignoring his yaya’s advice to avoid using it for love. Alfie’s mother’s and yaya’s mutual regret over the use of their powers, even to the time of their deaths, foreshadowed Alfie’s own dissatisfaction with his choices and demonstrated how control doesn’t necessarily make one happy.
Alfie’s father, on the other hand, was more of a distant figure and struggled with grief after his wife died. Though he was always there for Alfie, Alfie often found himself dealing with his emotions in private. Alfie’s parents’ influence is pivotal to the theme of Accepting One’s Life, Mistakes, and Mortality, as Alfie continually reflects on lessons learned from their lives and deaths. Both parents shape Alfie’s understanding of love, responsibility, and mortality, motivating him to consider the consequences of his magical interventions. Their presence in his memory shows that personal growth is intertwined with familial experience, reminding Alfie that life’s lessons often emerge from those one loves and loses.
Unlock analysis of every major character
Get a detailed breakdown of each character’s role, motivations, and development.
- Explore in-depth profiles for every important character
- Trace character arcs, turning points, and relationships
- Connect characters to key themes and plot points