49 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of graphic violence, illness, and death.
Over the days following Verity and Tacita’s return, all the spells Verity cast to help Foxfire have failed. Fixed things have broken again. The cows have stopped producing milk, and the gardens have died.
The townspeople start to doubt Verity’s powers and blame her for tricking them. Despite the setback, Verity keeps working to help them and reverse the curse as best she can. One day, Del stops by the shop to see Verity and asks after Tacita. Verity realizes that she hasn’t checked on Tacita and worries that she’s okay.
Throughout the next few days, the townspeople start questioning how and why Verity saved Tacita. Gilly is overwhelmed by all the gossip and worries about trusting Verity. One day, the two have a more open conversation. Gilly explains that everyone is upset because countless townspeople went missing before Tacita. The other residents are jealous that Verity didn’t save their family members, too. Verity wishes she could help and suggests that she venture back to the mountain to fix the bridge so everyone can simply escape Foxfire once and for all. Gilly is incensed, insisting that they don’t want to leave their town. Verity realizes she’ll have to confront Earl if she wants to reverse the curse and restore Foxfire.
Gilly suggests that Verity visit the old mine on the south side of the mountain, where Earl allegedly stays. She has heard stories about the mine’s magical power, too. She reveals that her mother, father, and brother were lost to the mountain years before, convinced that the mine would lead them to safety. They never returned, leaving Gilly alone in Foxfire as a child, and she has always wondered about them. The residents took care of her until she could care for herself. A shocked Verity declares that she will reunite Gilly with her family, no matter what.
Verity decides to use a charm to travel by candlelight so that she can confront Earl. First, she must make a drawing of the region. Gilly corrects Verity’s map, as she needs the drawing “to mirror the exact measurement” of her route (143).
Amid their work, Tacita appears at the shop for the first time since her return. She explains that her mother has been keeping her at home. She joins Verity and Gilly’s mapmaking, confirming that Earl does hang out near the old mine. She also admits that she has been experiencing some chest pains since coming back, but otherwise, she is fine. After Tacita leaves, Verity tries settling in for the night but can’t sleep, anticipating her journey. She has dreams of eyes in the forest.
The next day, Verity and Gilly return to their plan. Verity will use her candle to travel to the mine. Jack will accompany her but travel separately, on her broom. He will come to her aid when she finishes facing off with Earl, and they will fly back to Foxfire together. When the time comes, Verity starts singing her spell. Eventually, she lights on fire and disappears from Gilly’s shop, heading to Earl’s domain in a burst of flame.
Verity bursts through the flames and eventually reaches her destination. She feels sick and pained from her magical journey when she arrives. The woods are pitch dark, and the trees are “filled with nightjars” (158), a type of bird that, in the world of the novel, has magical powers.
Stumbling through the dark, Verity is overwhelmed by a rotting smell. She is horrified to discover that she is walking on the remains of dead bodies. Then Earl appears out of the dark. Verity is shocked by his appearance but tries to mask her horror. Earl is made of a collection of odd body parts, which Verity infers he stole from his victims.
Earl demands to know what Verity is doing there, as he is the king of this region. Verity insists that he can have the mountain and woods, but she demands that he stop tormenting the innocent Foxfire residents. Earl scoffs and says he and Verity should work together.
When she refuses, he suggests she make a deal with him. He is at the mine because he wants to access the power of the gods from within. However, he cannot move the stones to enter it. He knows Verity can because she is a witch. He promises that he will let go of the bargains he made with the Foxfire townspeople if she moves the stones.
Verity takes the deal, convinced that Earl is telling the truth and only wants to leave the woods and enter the mine. She moves the stones, the mine opens, and Earl disappears below. A satisfied Verity waits for Jack to arrive so that she can head out of the woods and back to Foxfire.
Verity Vox’s continued stay in Foxfire raises new interpersonal, political, and communal challenges, which further the novel’s theme of the Use of Power for Good Versus Evil. Since her arrival in Foxfire, Verity has done her best to convince the Foxfire residents that her efforts to help them are without guile or expectation. Her decision to brave the woods and mountain to bring back Tacita Tarry is also inspired by her desperation to use her magical powers for good. However, this decision upsets the fragile peace in Foxfire when all of Verity’s spells start to reverse and the townspeople turn against Verity once more, underscoring the novel’s message that power can heal or harm, depending on the spirit in which it is used.
As their fortunes shift, the people of Foxfire start to blame Verity for their failing crops and ailing animals because they have not recovered from Earl’s abuse. Their tenuous trust in her reiterates the novel’s theme of Navigating Community Hurt, Need, and Healing. In Foxfire, Verity cannot simply show up and enchant her new neighbors with her charmed black hat, magical black cat, and flying broomstick. The people have a fundamental distrust of all forms of magic, and Verity’s whimsical embodiment of the “dark arts” piques their suspicion. The exploitation they have suffered dictates their outlook on outsiders, and Verity in particular. So when their town starts to fall victim to famine and upheaval once more, they disparage their newcomer:
The town of Foxfire had been through this before. Small gifts of convenient magic had suddenly been taken from them and used as a bartering chip to exact a higher price, a steeper price. They had to wonder: Was that what she was doing? Was she actually here to help people or was she playing a different version of the same game Earl had played with them years before? (129-30).
The townspeople’s perception of Verity is based on their community’s history. Their collective past has taught them that they are vulnerable, and that others with power are willing to exploit their vulnerability for their own gain. Verity cannot immediately reverse their impressions of magic in general, and herself in particular, because she cannot erase the history of abuse they’ve suffered. Instead, she must prove her intentions to them through her decisions and actions, engendering her own growth as she comes to value other aspects of herself and understand that she has more to offer than just magic.
Verity’s decision to confront and combat Earl captures her desperation to prove herself as a witch and a trustworthy Foxfire ally, but it also highlights her courage, determination, and compassion, aspects of herself that she is just discovering. Her venture to the mine thus furthers the novel’s theme of Self-Exploration amid a Small-Town Community. Through Gilly, Verity comes to understand why Foxfire is having such a hard time taking her word and trusting in her power: “Hospitality,” the narrator remarks, “is a deep magic, after all, and she was still a guest” (137). Desperate to be accepted into this close-knit community, Verity sets her mind to undoing Earl’s curse so that she might rescue all the lost Foxfire souls. Her response to Gilly’s story about her family’s disappearance captures her desperation to prove her relevance to the community, and in turn, to prove her worth to herself. As soon as she hears about her friend’s loss, she announces that she is going to reunite the Green family “if it’s the last thing [she does]” (139). Facing off with Earl is a test of strength, power, and courage Verity has designed to test herself, and she proves that she has bravery and commitment. She sends Earl quite swiftly to the mine, convinced that she has acted in the best interest of Foxfire. Her actions capture her eagerness to belong and to be accepted so she might formulate a definite sense of self.



Unlock all 49 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.