67 pages • 2-hour read
Wally LambA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of death, substance use, addiction, pregnancy loss, mental illness, graphic violence, antigay bias, and child sexual abuse.
Orion expresses frustration with his new in-home nurse—Belinda—whom he perceives as overly timid. During a writing session, she brings him the phone when Marissa calls with news that her contract on a soap opera has been extended due to her growing fan base. Orion notes that Marissa’s connection with Joe Agnello at the wedding seems to have brought her “good luck,” and they discuss Gualtiero Agnello’s recent death and approaching funeral.
Marissa shares that she experienced a breakthrough in therapy, realizing she had long suppressed anger toward Annie and feelings of abandonment in childhood. She reflects on Annie’s focus on work, also acknowledging Orion’s long working hours but stating that it didn’t bother her because he was not at home, while Annie was. Their conversation touches on Annie’s pregnancy loss—“another one of the secrets she’d kept” (858)—Marissa’s sobriety, and her relationship with a fellow actor, Kieran. Marissa informs Orion that Minnie and Africa are moving after violence in their neighborhood, and she inquires about his writing progress. After the call ends, Orion reflects on Marissa’s apparent health and happiness and recalls his final session with Seamus.
After preparing for physical therapy with Belinda’s awkward assistance, Orion is transported to the session by a hired driver, Larry. During the drive, he discusses the conviction of his attacker and the permanence of his paralysis. He reflects on his depression following the assault and his harsh treatment of Annie during that period. In particular, he recalls a confrontation after Andrew confessed to killing Kent. Rather than report the crime, Orion instructed Andrew to confide only in him and blamed Annie for contributing to Andrew’s violence. After picking a fight with her, he ordered her to leave; however, she refused, keeping her word to care for him. Orion now recognizes his own hero complex and questions his decisions, though he ultimately feels relieved that he protected Annie from the knowledge of Andrew’s violence.
Upon returning home, Orion grows uneasy when he notices Belinda emerging from the back of the property, where Kent’s body is hidden. Later, Ariane arrives with her son, Dario. During a conversation about Josephus Jones’s Adam and Eve—the only one of Jones’s paintings Orion has kept—Belinda reveals that she knew Jones, emphasizing his kindness. Though she denies knowing any information about the circumstances of his death, she defensively informs Orion that Jones did not have an affair with Rufus’s wife.
That evening, Orion resumes work on his fiction manuscript, which is inspired by his family’s history. Though uncertain about publication, he finds the writing process healing, and he expresses gratitude for his survival.
Annie and Viveca arrive at Orion’s home after attending Gualtiero Agnello’s funeral. When Annie asks about Andrew’s well-being, Orion expresses uncertainty, noting Andrew’s frequent solo trips to the casino and possible increase in alcohol use, though he cannot confirm the latter. He does observe that Andrew appears increasingly isolated, despite maintaining a close bond with Dario.
Their conversation turns to Annie and Viveca’s upcoming trip to Greece. Orion acknowledges Annie’s support during his recovery and Viveca’s role in selling the Jones paintings, which enabled him to afford his medical costs. Annie remarks that the sales also advanced Viveca’s career. Annie speaks enthusiastically about future artistic opportunities abroad, while Orion discusses progress on his writing. Returning to Andrew, Annie speculates that his withdrawal may be related to the Fort Hood shooting. Orion does not disclose Andrew’s involvement in Kent’s death, though he privately reflects on the true source of Andrew’s distress.
Orion ruminates on Andrew’s situation. Although he recognizes Andrew’s violence, he rationalizes Kent’s murder—“The guy was a pedophile […] And he’d been a loner” (907)—and prioritizes protecting his son. He acknowledges occasional resentment over carrying this knowledge but remains committed to shielding Andrew from legal consequences.
Later, Annie and Orion discuss her Catholic faith, including her conflict over the Church’s opposition to marriage equality and its history of clerical abuse. Their conversation is interrupted by Ariane and Dario’s return. That evening, Annie and Viveca read to Dario before bedtime. Ariane departs to address an issue at the group home, and Viveca later informs Orion that she has purchased The Cercus People for Annie. Orion expresses gratitude for her support and reflects on his earlier mistrust of Viveca, recognizing that he misjudged her and that he was not a “blameless victim” in his marriage’s dissolution.
After Annie and Viveca depart, Andrew assists Orion with his nighttime routine. Orion admits missing romantic intimacy and reveals that he ended his relationship with Tracy for her benefit. When he asks Andrew whether he misses intimacy, Andrew acknowledges that his secret prevents him from pursuing relationships. Before leaving, Andrew proposes a road trip to Long Nook Beach. Although Orion remains wary of returning to the site of his assault, he agrees to consider it. As he prepares for bed, holding a soapstone dolphin carved by his grandfather, Orion feels cautiously optimistic about the future.
Orion and Andrew travel to Long Nook Beach in Cape Cod. After selecting a place to sit, Andrew carries Orion across the sand. Orion observes the overcast but pleasant weather and recalls his previous visit to Long Nook with Ariane three years earlier. When Andrew offers to carry him down to the water, Orion initially refuses, concerned about his weight, but Andrew insists and brings him to the shoreline.
As Andrew swims, Orion reflects on Andrew’s difficult birth and the man he has become, describing him as “powerful.” He also reconsiders his feelings toward his own father, Francis Oh. Rather than anger, he now feels pity, recognizing that reframing the past diminishes its hold over him.
When Andrew returns, Orion notices his new tattoo, which reads “love wins” in Chinese characters. They sit together quietly before Andrew asks what Orion is thinking about. Orion explains that he has been contemplating Annie’s planned artistic project, We Are Water, and reflects on the metaphor that people, like water, often follow the path of least resistance. Andrew confesses that he is considering turning himself in for Kent’s murder. Though Orion is tempted to dissuade him, he withholds his opinion, and Andrew admits that he remains undecided.
Andrew tells Orion that he loves him. Andrew then carries Orion into the ocean so that he can cool off, with Orion reflecting, “father and son, the atheist and the believer, we enter the churning, mysterious sea” (930).
The closing chapters of We Are Water function as a reckoning and recalibration, the choice of narrative voice contributing to this effect. The section unfolds entirely through Orion’s perspective and therefore invites readers to reconsider the reliability of the voice that has shaped so much of the narrative. Earlier sections revealed how anger and wounded pride colored Orion’s interpretation of events and people, particularly Viveca. He now admits, “It was easier to think of myself as Viveca’s victim than to cop to my own culpability” (913). Besides clearing up the ambiguity surrounding Viveca’s characterization, his words engage with Power and Vulnerability in Intimate Relationships; as he explains, his embrace of his perceived victimhood was a way of protecting his ego, not a true reflection of relationship dynamics. His reflection on pitying his absent father—“I pity him his loss, his cowardice. And pitying him robs him of his power over me” (923)—signals a similar shift away from grievance and toward agency.
His growth, however, is partial; Orion’s increased self-awareness does not make him a wholly reliable narrator, at least until the novel’s final pages. This is clear in the novel’s continued interrogation of secrecy. Orion initially condemns Annie for keeping her childhood abuse a secret from him, mostly on the grounds that she instead “made [their] son her confessor” and “ruined his life” (873). Part 5 reveals the hypocrisy of this accusation as Orion now he actively keeps the truth of Andrew’s killing of Kent from Annie. Once again, Andrew is the casualty of this dynamic: Orion recognizes that “what’s eating away at Andrew is another killing. A hidden corpse” (905), but he still rationalizes the concealment, perpetuating the very culture of secrecy he critiques. This tension reinforces Intergenerational Trauma and Secrecy, illustrating how difficult such patterns are to break; his protective instincts become a way of justifying his reluctance to confront the morality of Andrew’s actions. His ultimate recognition that the choice to reveal the truth must be Andrew’s thus signals character growth.
Part 5 also reframes Orion’s understanding of love. Earlier in the novel, Annie struggled to feel safe in loving relationships. Orion’s recognition of his own “hero complex” complements this, as he recognizes that his impulse to protect those he “loves” can mask attempts to control them. He asks himself, “Is that what love is all about for me? Protecting people” (882), and later reflects, “So maybe that’s what love means. Having the capacity to forgive the one who wronged you” (883). This shift suggests that emotional maturity lies in acknowledging the mutual capacity to hurt and be hurt.
Writing, too, becomes therapeutic for Orion, who describes entering “the zone” as a form of imaginative transport that allows him to connect with his grandfather. This underscores art’s broader function as a conduit for connection and self-examination—ideas key to the theme of Creativity and Art in Emotional Healing. The resolution of several other characters’ arcs reinforces this point. Marissa’s phone call frames her as healthy and self-aware: She is sober, thriving professionally as an actress, and processing her childhood feelings of abandonment in therapy. Meanwhile, Jones’s art, once marginalized, has been sold to fund Orion’s rehabilitation, linking artistic creation to survival itself.
Dario’s presence facilitates the shift toward healing, both within the family and in Three Rivers broadly. His existence draws Ariane back to Three Rivers and thus brings together a family that had drifted apart in response to Annie’s affair. Similarly, Orion observes that Andrew’s “lone wolf stuff worries [him]” yet immediately qualifies that concern by noting, “He’s crazy about that nephew of his, and vice versa” (901). Dario tempers Andrew’s isolation while forming an unexpected bond with another character whose presence otherwise highlights the lingering cost of buried trauma: Belinda, whose shared moments with the child temper her grief. In a novel concerned with secrecy, Dario represents openness, future orientation, and the possibility of breaking patterns. He therefore reinforces the novel’s movement away from isolation and toward connection, even if that movement takes generations to complete.
The novel closes with the image of “flexible” yet forceful water. This paradoxical imagery captures the ethical choice that Orion articulates: whether or not to follow the path of least resistance. The conclusion of the novel therefore underscores its framing of responsibility as an ongoing choice to interrupt inherited patterns rather than conceal them.



Unlock all 67 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.