62 pages • 2-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of violence.
Tyler’s body has not been found, so despite claims that many students at the party saw him being beheaded with an axe, no one is sure if a murder actually happened. Jonah seems somewhat worried as more of the story is revealed, since he wonders if Aerius could be the culprit.
After Jonah goes to class, Aerius lingers in the garden. He feels too sad to carry out his plan of killing Allan. When Aerius hears the Bunnies entering the garden, he hides. He listens as they discuss their frustrations with being unable to find him and their suspicions that he was the one who murdered Tyler.
Elsinore can sense Aerius’s presence in the garden, and the Bunnies nearly catch him. However, they become distracted by the presence of a rabbit in the garden and decide to try to replicate the process of turning this rabbit into a man. After they leave, Aerius hides again and eavesdrops on Jonah and Sam talking in the garden. He is hurt by Jonah’s obvious crush on Sam and her lack of interest in him.
After the murder, Aerius is confused because he is unable to find the bodies. He notices for the first time a young man who was also sitting in the bar while all these events took place. Aerius leaves the bar. Aerius feels more lost than ever and lies down in a ditch. He hears people approaching and assumes the Bunnies are coming to recapture him; too exhausted to fight back, he lets the people take him.
Aerius realizes he has been abducted by the members of the Poetry cohort, not by the Bunnies. They report that the axe murderer has struck again: A student claims to have seen two men being killed with an axe in a bar, but no bodies have been found.
The Poets want Aerius to act as their muse, since they find him to be a source of strange inspiration. They are also looking forward to a famous poet visiting the campus in a few weeks. The Poets are suspicious of Jonah, since they can tell he has a crush on Sam. Aerius accepts his fate of staying with the Poets.
Several weeks pass as Aerius lives with the Poets. After a few weeks, a group of students unexpectedly shows up at the house where the Poets live. The Poets hurry to hide Aerius, who watches and listens from his hiding place.
The students are campus activists who are frustrated that the police are not doing enough to find the killer after the axe murders. They show images of the suspect to the Poets, but since the sketches are abstract, they are unable to recognize the suspect, and Aerius is relieved. Later, however, Aerius overhears the Poets arguing about whether he could be the killer.
The next day, the famous poet, Leonard Coel (also referred to as “the Immortal”), arrives on campus. Aerius doesn’t want to attend the reading and accompanying dinner but is hopeful that Jonah might be there.
During the dinner with the Poets and the Immortal, Aerius is startled to see the Bunnies enter the restaurant; the Bunnies are accompanied by four young men in matching suits. Aerius panics and flees outside, and the Immortal follows him. The two talk about poetry, and the Immortal refers to himself as “Allen G” (referencing his fondness for Allen Ginsberg).
After killing the Immortal, Aerius realizes that he has once again made a mistake: “I had once more killed a Wrong Allan” (290). Once again, the body mysteriously vanishes after the murder.
Jonah runs into Aerius outside the restaurant and seems happy to see him. Jonah tries to lead Aerius inside, but Aerius refuses because he is afraid of the Bunnies. Jonah and Aerius argue about whether to go inside, and Jonah enters alone; Aerius flees.
Aerius follows a rabbit into a strange garden with a small cottage. He enters the cottage, where an older woman is sitting and cradling the rabbit in her lap. Aerius and the woman speak, but they are interrupted when the woman (who calls herself “Mother”) hears the voices of the young men from the poetry cohort outside the cottage. Mother goes out and speaks with them. The Poets explain that they are looking for Leonard, who disappeared during their dinner. They add that their Muse is also mysteriously missing. Mother reassures them that Leonard Coel has come home safely but does not wish to be interrupted. The poets leave.
Aerius’s violent actions add dramatic tension to the novel since the campus is now in a state of high alert as “the Psycho was on the Loose” (239). Aerius now risks capture by either the Bunnies, if they find him, or anyone who might identify him as the man who killed Tyler. His next set of murders at the bar results from further confusion about language: He takes it at face value when the two men joke, “we are both Allan” (257). These additional murders place Aerius in even more jeopardy.
Aerius chooses to submit to a second captivity, this time with the Poets, because he is frightened and disappointed by the world he has encountered. Aerius exemplifies the theme of The Pain of Unrequited Desire: Since he is so crushed by Jonah not falling in love with him, he merely thinks, “anyway, what had I to live for?” (261) as the Poets are carrying him back to their home. As time passes and autumn transitions into early winter, Awad uses the technique of pathetic fallacy, in which the outer world mirrors a character’s inner state, to embody Aerius’s weary, lovelorn condition. Aerius becomes drained and despondent as the New England setting becomes colder and darker, ushering in a “Time of gray Skies and Snow” (277).
This period of lassitude is interrupted by a visit from the famous poet Leonard Coel, or “the Immortal.” Leonard’s name is likely an allusion to the Canadian musician and poet Leonard Cohen. Leonard and Aerius briefly bond because the famous poet can sense Aerius’s authenticity and is impressed that the latter doesn’t try to flatter him. However, when Leonard uses language figuratively in the poem he is reciting, referring to himself as the reincarnation of the poet Allen Ginsberg (a Beat poet famous for Howl and other works), Aerius commits another murder.
Leonard’s murder is more explicitly positioned as a transformation: Unlike in the other instances where Aerius immediately fled from the scene, he is able in this case to observe that the dead body strangely vanishes. A mysterious rabbit appears, implying that Leonard may have been transformed into an animal. Within the world of the novel, death is not necessarily final but may instead be part of a process of transmutation and even transitioning into a more authentic self.
Although Aerius does not fully understand what he keeps pining for, he feels a longing for a time and place “where you know the Language of the Moon and the Wind and the Grasses” (287). By being placed in a mortal, human body, Aerius has become subject to human emotions and frailties and distanced from a connection to the natural world. Language sometimes helps and sometimes hinders him because he often struggles to find words that can actually express his inner experiences. Aerius’s longing to return to his animal form becomes conflated with a desire to escape from human mortality.
Aerius’s second captivity with the Poets echoes his first captivity with the Bunnies. Like the Bunnies, the Poets see Aerius as something to possess and consume in hopes of fueling their own creativity, once more reflecting Authorial Control and Agency Over Narratives. He observes that the Poets have “a wild Wanting that afeared me. It reminded me of my Keepers, of the Attic Times” (268). The Bunnies, the Poets, and later, Ursula, will all show the same rapacious desire to use Aerius toward their own ends, implying that creativity can become a kind of reckless appetite. Since Aerius is pure and untouched by human experience, they sense a kind of authenticity in him that they long to access and harness for their own means. Aerius does have marginally more freedom during his second captivity and, to some degree, imprisons himself due to his sadness and pining for Jonah, noting, “a kind of heavy Melancholy had overtaken my Spirit” (268). The more of human existence that he experiences, the less free he becomes.
Aerius eventually enters into a third captivity, this time with Ursula. Her cottage, as well as her name, evokes allusions to a witch from fairy tales and folklore. Aerius is mistrustful of her but also feels compelled because Ursula “had a Power greater than the Poets, greater than my Keepers” (303). While Ursula occasionally laments her age, complaining that “she’d felt so dried up, barren” (304), her greater maturity gives her greater power than the young students in the MFA cohort. She can more skillfully take control of Aerius and assert her will over him.



Unlock all 62 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.