When God Was a Woman

Merlin Stone

66 pages 2-hour read

Merlin Stone

When God Was a Woman

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 1976

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 6-8Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of gender discrimination, religious discrimination, graphic violence, rape, and death.

Chapter 6 Summary: “If the King Did Not Weep”

In Chapter 6, Stone argues that ancient goddess-worshipping societies operated under a matrilineal system in which high priestesses held ultimate political power, including the authority to select temporary male consorts who served as kings before being ritually sacrificed. Stone contends that this practice originated in Neolithic temple communities where goddess worship was central to economic and social organization.


Stone presents evidence from various ancient civilizations to support her thesis that kingship evolved from the position of male consort to the high priestess. In Sumerian society, temples of goddesses like Inanna controlled vast economic enterprises, managing agricultural activities, crafts, and trade. The high priestess, known as the Entu in Sumer or the Tawawannas in Anatolia, likely served as the nominal leader of these temple communities, though Stone suggests governance was conducted through assemblies of community elders rather than monarchical rule.


The author traces the practice of ritual regicide across multiple cultures, drawing from three types of evidence: ceremonial accounts describing sacred marriages between priestesses and their consorts, ritual documents showing later substitute practices, and mythological legends explaining these customs. Stone cites examples from Africa, particularly Nigerian traditions in which queens took temporary lovers who were strangled after the queen became pregnant, to demonstrate that similar patterns existed beyond the ancient Near East.


Stone examines specific historical examples, including Sumerian accounts of the goddess Inanna and her consort Damuzi. According to these ancient texts, Inanna commanded Damuzi’s death after he behaved arrogantly during her absence, sitting on her throne without permission. This narrative, Stone argues, reveals the true motivation for ritual sacrifice: maintaining the supremacy of the goddess and her earthly representative over male consorts who challenged their authority.


The author analyzes how this system evolved across different civilizations. In Babylon, the goddess Ishtar continued to be described as the dominant partner in sacred marriages, though by this period, actual sacrifice had been replaced with symbolic rituals involving the temporary humiliation of kings. Egyptian mythology preserved similar themes through the stories of Isis and Osiris, while Cretan religion maintained the goddess’s supremacy over male deities until the Indo-European invasions.


Stone explores how the arrival of patrilineal Indo-European tribes gradually transformed these practices. She suggests that the epic of Gilgamesh represents a pivotal moment when male rulers began rejecting the traditional system, refusing to submit to ritual death and establishing permanent kingship. This transition involved strategic marriages to high priestesses to legitimize new rulers in the eyes of populations accustomed to goddess worship.


The chapter concludes by examining the practice of castration as a possible substitute for ritual death. Stone argues that eunuch priests may have emerged as men sought to participate in goddess religion by eliminating their “maleness,” either literally through castration or symbolically through wearing women’s clothing. This development eventually led to male clergy replacing female priestesses in some regions.


Stone’s analysis demonstrates how ancient societies structured around goddess worship operated fundamentally differently from later patriarchal systems, with women holding supreme religious and political authority that men could only access temporarily and at great personal cost.

Chapter 7 Summary: “The Sacred Sexual Customs”

In this chapter, Stone discusses the ancient religious practices surrounding sexuality in pre-Hebrew societies and argues that Hebrew opposition to these customs was politically motivated rather than morally based. Stone contends that understanding these “sacred sexual customs” reveals how patriarchal religious systems deliberately attacked matrilineal social structures to gain control over land and inheritance (199).


Stone begins by addressing how Hebrew prophets and biblical editors condemned Canaanite religious practices, particularly focusing on what they characterized as sexual license associated with goddess-worshipping societies—what they referred to as “fertility cults.” However, Stone argues that this characterization misrepresents the true nature of these ancient customs. In societies throughout Sumer, Babylon, and Canaan, women lived within temple complexes that served as economic and cultural centers of their communities. These sacred women, known as qadishtu (meaning “sanctified” or “holy women”), engaged in sexual relationships with men who came to honor the Goddess, viewing these acts as sacred expressions of divine worship (204).


Stone provides archaeological evidence to support her thesis, including an 8,000-year-old stone plaque from a Neolithic shrine that depicts lovers embracing on one side and a woman holding an infant on the other. She argues that these sexual customs likely developed from early human understanding of the connection between sex and reproduction, knowledge that women probably discovered first and integrated into religious practice.


The author traces documentary evidence from multiple ancient civilizations showing that these customs persisted for thousands of years. Even wealthy and royal women participated freely, and according to ancient sources like Strabo, these women were considered excellent wives when they chose to marry. Stone emphasizes that concepts of shame or impropriety regarding sexuality were later inventions that contradicted ancient attitudes that viewed reproduction as divine.


Stone identifies the critical political motivation behind Hebrew opposition to these practices. Under matrilineal systems supported by the goddess religion, children inherited names, titles, and property from their mothers regardless of paternal identity. The qadishtu, who often owned land and engaged in business activities, would pass their wealth to their children through maternal lines. This system threatened Hebrew patriarchal goals of establishing patrilineal inheritance, which required certain knowledge of paternity.


Stone argues that Levite laws demanding female virginity before marriage and complete marital fidelity were designed specifically to establish paternal certainty and enable patrilineal inheritance. The death penalty for women who violated these laws, including rape victims, demonstrates the Hebrew preoccupation with controlling paternity. By condemning the sacred sexual customs as immoral, Hebrew leaders could simultaneously destroy the economic foundation of matrilineal society and justify their conquest of Canaanite lands.


The chapter concludes by examining how these ancient customs continued even within Hebrew territories, including Jerusalem’s temple, creating ongoing conflict between adherents of the Goddess religion and Hebrew patriarchal authorities. Stone suggests that this religious and social confrontation represented a fundamental struggle over power, property, and the structure of society itself.

Chapter 8 Summary: “They Offered Incense to the Queen of Heaven”

In this chapter, Merlin Stone examines the persistent worship of female deities among Hebrew communities in ancient Canaan, despite official religious doctrine favoring the male god Yahweh. Stone argues that archaeological evidence reveals extensive goddess worship that Hebrew religious authorities worked systematically to suppress.


Stone presents archaeological findings from various excavations in biblical Canaan, including work by Professor Yigael Yadin at Hazor and research by Professor Albright and Kathleen Kenyon. These discoveries include numerous Astarte plaques dating from the Late Bronze Age (1500-1300 BCE) and figurines representing the fertility goddess found throughout the region. The plaques typically depicted the goddess with upraised arms holding lily stalks or serpents, adorned with Egyptian-style ringlets. Stone notes that such artifacts appear consistently across archaeological sites, indicating widespread goddess veneration that continued well into the seventh century BCE.


The chapter traces how the goddess appeared under various names throughout Canaan—as Ashtoreth, Asherah, Astarte, Anath, and others—and held primary importance in major Canaanite cities including Tyre, Sidon, and Byblos. Stone argues that while these deities became associated with male consorts like Baal, the religious practices and rituals remained fundamentally rooted in ancient goddess traditions. She suggests that Hebrew priests deliberately obscured the goddess’s prominence by consistently pairing her name with Baal’s and sometimes mispronouncing her name as “Boseth,” meaning shame.


Stone examines biblical accounts of Hebrew conquest in Canaan, describing systematic campaigns of destruction against existing populations and their religious sites. She cites passages from Joshua detailing the complete annihilation of cities and their inhabitants, arguing that these accounts reveal the violent suppression of goddess-worshipping communities. The chapter suggests that many Hebrew women may have been captured Canaanites who retained memories of their ancestral religious practices.


Despite official prohibition, Stone documents persistent goddess worship among Hebrews themselves. She cites biblical passages showing that Hebrew leaders, including King Solomon and King Ahab, actively participated in goddess veneration. The chapter describes how sacred groves called asherah were repeatedly erected and destroyed throughout Hebrew history, indicating ongoing religious conflict. Stone highlights a particularly revealing passage from Jeremiah, describing Hebrew women in Egypt who openly declared their intention to continue offering incense to the Queen of Heaven, claiming they had prospered when honoring her but suffered since abandoning her worship.


Stone concludes that archaeological evidence and biblical texts themselves demonstrate the extensive influence of goddess religion throughout Hebrew society. She argues that Levite priests engaged in deliberate censorship and propaganda to minimize the goddess’s historical importance but failed to completely erase evidence of her continued veneration among Hebrew communities. The chapter suggests that this religious tension reflected broader conflicts between matrilineal goddess-worshipping traditions and emerging patriarchal systems that sought to establish male religious and social authority.

Chapters 6-8 Analysis

In Chapters 6-8, Stone constructs her argument through extensive archaeological evidence, biblical textual analysis, and cross-cultural documentation. The author traces the evolution from goddess-centered societies to patriarchal religious systems, demonstrating how political motivations shaped theological change. Her analytical framework combines historical methodology with feminist scholarship to reveal patterns of religious and social transformation that traditional scholarship had overlooked or misinterpreted.


The Intentional Destruction of Goddess Worship and the Matrilineal Tradition emerges as Stone’s primary topic throughout these chapters. Stone documents systematic campaigns by Hebrew tribes and Indo-European conquerors to eliminate goddess worship through violent conquest and legislative prohibition. The author presents evidence of deliberate destruction of temples, massacre of populations, and forced conversion that characterized the Hebrew invasion of Canaan. Stone demonstrates how religious transformation served political ends, as conquering groups sought to establish patrilineal inheritance systems that would consolidate their control over land and resources. The documentation reveals that this destruction was not accidental cultural drift but coordinated policy designed to eliminate competing social structures.


Stone’s analysis of women’s status in society reveals the connection between religious belief systems and social organization in ancient cultures. The author demonstrates how goddess-worshipping societies maintained elevated positions for women as high priestesses, business owners, and property holders with significant legal and economic autonomy. Stone documents how these women controlled temple complexes that functioned as centers of economic and political power, owning land, livestock, and conducting trade relationships. The evidence suggests that women in these societies possessed rights and freedoms that would be systematically stripped away as patriarchal religious systems gained dominance. Stone argues that the demotion of female deities directly correlated with the reduction of women’s social, economic, and political status in subsequent civilizations.


The theme of The Shift From Sacred Sexuality to Sexual Morality represents one of Stone’s most detailed examinations of religious and cultural transformation. Stone contrasts the ancient view of sexuality as sacred and divinely blessed with the emergence of restrictive sexual codes designed to establish paternal certainty. The author explains that temple sexual customs served religious, social, and possibly reproductive regulation functions within goddess-centered communities, where “the act of sex was considered to be sacred, so holy and precious that it was enacted within the house of the creators of heaven, earth, and all life” (200). Stone demonstrates how Hebrew law introduced concepts of premarital virginity and marital fidelity specifically for women, creating legal frameworks that enabled patrilineal inheritance by ensuring knowledge of paternity. The transformation from sacred sexuality to sexual morality thus facilitated the broader shift from matrilineal to patrilineal social organization.


The author’s use of primary sources and archaeological evidence strengthens her analytical framework throughout these chapters. Stone draws extensively from cuneiform tablets, biblical texts, classical historians like Herodotus and Strabo, and modern archaeological excavations to support her conclusions. The author incorporates findings from prominent archaeologists and historians while critically examining their interpretations, particularly when previous scholarship dismissed or minimized evidence of goddess worship. Stone’s citations reveal the breadth of available evidence while highlighting how interpretive bias had previously obscured the significance of goddess-centered religious systems. Her integration of multiple source types creates a comprehensive foundation for her thesis about intentional religious transformation.


Stone uses comparison and contrast as primary rhetorical devices to illuminate the magnitude of religious and social change. The author juxtaposes the power and reverence accorded to goddesses in early periods with their later subordination or elimination in patriarchal systems. Stone contrasts the sexual freedom and economic independence of women in goddess-worshipping societies with the restrictive laws and secondary status imposed by later religious codes. These comparative analyses demonstrate not gradual evolution but dramatic reversals in religious and social priorities. The rhetorical effect emphasizes the deliberate nature of these transformations rather than natural cultural development.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 66 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs