48 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of illness and death.
Empty of magic and strength, Clarion drags herself to Petra’s side. Milori and Yarrow find her there. Yarrow says that Clarion must be taken back to the warm seasons immediately. Milori insists on carrying her out. Despite warnings that crossing the border will destroy his wings, he’s undeterred. Placing Clarion on Noctua’s back, Milori takes the reins and flies back to the border.
During their journey, Clarion slips in and out of awareness. She asks Milori to speak to her, and he shares a memory of the night he saw her star fall and made a wish for a future in which he wasn’t bound by duty or isolation. Clarion promises to make his wish come true. When they finally arrive at the border, Milori prepares to cross into Spring and beyond to the healers’ field, fully aware that doing so will destroy his wings. Clarion begs him not to, but he refuses to let her die.
Once they enter the warmth of Summer, Milori starts to deteriorate. He begins to overheat, and his wings, made of ice, start melting. He continues to push forward to the Feverfew Fields, where he delivers Clarion to the healers. She continues to have bouts of delirium as they tend to her, and Milori refuses to leave her side despite his failing condition. When Elvina arrives, she isn’t angry but grateful for his sacrifice. As Clarion falls unconscious again, the last thing she hears is Milori saying, “She’s worth protecting” (287).
Clarion wakes in the healing clinic after her battle with the Nightmares. Though still weak, she’s alive. Her thoughts immediately turn to Milori, whose sacrifice haunts her. Elvina arrives, relieved to see her awake, and tells her that Artemis and Petra are alive, though the latter remains trapped in the Nightmares’ spell. Milori returned to Winter.
Elvina confesses that she regrets what she did. Her plan to defeat the Nightmares was flawed, her judgment of Winter was misguided, and her time as queen is ending. Her power is waning, and soon she’ll return to the stars. She finally offers Clarion the maternal love that she had long withheld from her. Clarion realizes that Elvina’s emotional distance was a defense against loss and sees how she, too, was beginning to walk the same path. Moved by Elvina’s confession and Milori’s wish for a better future, she decides to become a queen who carries her people’s hopes with compassion, not detachment.
Three days later, Clarion resolves to face the Nightmares once and for all. With her magic restored and newfound determination, she escapes from the clinic by successfully teleporting for the first time. She then travels to the Winter border and crosses into the snowy woods. When she whistles for Noctua, the owl appears, and Clarion flies on her back to the frozen lake. Upon her arrival, Clarion finds that the magical barrier she and Milori made is shattered. With no other choice, Clarion leaps into the lake.
Plunging into the Nightmares’ prison, Clarion is enveloped in an unnatural darkness. Suspended in the void, she feels like she’s being watched. She glimpses a vision of Milori walking away from her, his form barely visible. Desperate to follow, she finds herself in a shifting, dreamlike space that morphs into a twisted version of Pixie Hollow. She sees the Pixie Dust Tree rotting and the land around it consumed by despair. The fairies, including Petra and Elvina, accuse her of selfishness and failure. Overwhelmed, Clarion nearly gives in to despair, but the sound of Milori’s real voice calling out to her anchors her to reality. Realizing that she’s trapped in a Nightmare-induced illusion, Clarion bites her lip to wake herself up and shatters the hallucination with her magic.
Once she returns to the real prison beneath the lake, she comes face-to-face with the source of the Nightmares: the Queen Nightmare, a dragon that has glowing eyes and is cloaked in purple smoke. The sight nearly paralyzes Clarion, but Milori calls out to her again through the ice above, reminding her of her promise to him to create a better future. Clarion draws on the collective hopes of those who once wished on her falling star and unleashes her full power. Her light floods the prison, unraveling the dragon.
Milori pulls Clarion from the Nightmares’ prison, and the ice seals shut behind them. Under the glimmer of an aurora, Clarion and Milori marvel at their accomplishments and reflect on the future. She formally offers him a place on her court as the reinstated Lord of Winter, forging a political and symbolic bond between their once-divided realms. He accepts, and they briefly dare to dream of a shared future. However, the physical toll of Milori’s border crossing becomes clear as he reveals his broken wing. Though he insists that he has no regrets, Clarion decides to end their romantic relationship and forbid future border crossings to protect others from harm. They share one last, desperate kiss before parting ways.
Clarion solemnly returns to Spring, where the warm fairies greet her as a hero. She reunites with Elvina, who ushers her back into the palace and into bed. Though questions and praise follow her arrival, Clarion feels nothing but exhaustion. She finally allows herself to grieve the loss of Milori and the weight of everything she’s endured. Elvina comforts her, cradling her like a mother would a child and soothing her with fairy tales.
Clarion wakes to find a letter from Elvina with news that the Nightmares’ spell has finally broken, and those cursed are finally waking up. Clarion flies across Pixie Hollow to the Summer Glade and the healers’ clinic. She finds Artemis outside, still recovering from her injuries. Artemis insists on remaining Clarion’s guard, saying that she doesn’t see the position as a punishment anymore and wants to serve out of loyalty to Clarion.
Inside the clinic, Clarion sees the newly awakened fairies reunited with their loved ones. Petra is still asleep. Clarion takes her hand, and Petra stirs. When she wakes, they apologize to each other. Their reunion is cut short when Artemis rushes over. Artemis kisses Petra and demands that she never put herself in danger again. Clarion excuses herself, recognizing that while love might be out of reach for her, she can take comfort in seeing others find it. She goes to see Rowan, who soon wakes and tells her he “always knew [she] could do it” (326).
The day of Clarion’s coronation arrives. The ceremony takes place on the bridge between Winter and Spring, where Elvina formally crowns her, and Clarion gives a speech pledging herself to her people. She formally appoints Milori as Lord of Winter but declares the border permanently closed to prevent future harm to other fairies. After her speech, Milori leads the cheers.
The celebration that follows bridges the divide between the seasonal realms for the first time in living memory. However, as the festivities wind down, Clarion withdraws to prepare for her final farewell to Milori. She finds Milori waiting for her on the bridge. He insists that he’ll always love her, even from afar. Clarion kisses him one last time but asks him to move on. He returns the request before vanishing into the Winter Woods. Clarion remains behind as rain starts to fall, standing alone at the edge of Spring.
The novel reaches its emotional and thematic climax after Milori rescues Clarion after she collapses in Chapter 21 following her overuse of magic. Neither Petra nor Artemis can help Clarion, so Milori must return her to the warm-season healers himself. However, in doing so, he makes the ultimate sacrifice: losing his wings. Because Wings of Starlight is a prequel to the 2012 film Secret of the Wings, his injury and the political aftermath for Pixie Hollow are a foregone conclusion. His willingness to suffer irreversible damage to the most literal representation of his identity as a fairy shows the intensity of his love and desperation. For the rest of the novel, Clarion carries the guilt for being the cause of Milori’s losing his wings. However, his act serves as the catalyst for her return to the Nightmares’ prison to face the Queen Nightmare alone.
When she leaps into the ice, the action draws on mythical storytelling structures, particularly the descent into the underworld. It marks her symbolic death and rebirth: a willing plunge into the unknown, carrying only hope, magic, and the strength of her convictions. The Nightmares themselves are expressions of the Jungian “shadow,” or the aspects of the self that are hidden, repressed, or denied. For Clarion, this includes her yearning to belong, fear of failing, longing for love, and guilt for choices she regrets. When the Nightmares trap her in their illusions, it isn’t an external foreign villain she battles but her shadow self. The Queen Nightmare appears as a dragon, the ultimate shadow figure, embodying everything Clarion has feared becoming or being defeated by. To defeat the Nightmares is not to banish them forever but to accept that they’re part of her. She acknowledges her feelings for Milori, names her guilt and grief, and still chooses to lead. In doing so, she becomes whole. The Nightmares, therefore, aren’t just narrative monsters but necessary teachers for her to take the final step in becoming the ruler she needs to be for the good of her people.
The image of the lake sealing behind her and Milori “like a wound finally healing” (308) functions as a literal closing of the Nightmare prison and metaphorically closes the book on a difficult chapter in Clarion’s life. The primary conflict has ended, yet the personal cost remains unresolved. Her interactions with Elvina are full of dualities: regret and affection, apology and acceptance. Elvina finally confesses to Clarion, “When I saw you rise from that star, I think I understood something of what mothers must feel” (292). This moment complicates Elvina’s earlier role as antagonist and finally provides Clarion with the emotional closure she needs.
Following the Nightmares’ destruction, the formerly silent halls of the clinic are now full of life, community, and celebration. Touch is a recurring motif throughout this section: Clarion holds Petra’s hand, Artemis and Petra kiss, and Elvina gently strokes Clarion’s hair. The moments of physical connection mark reconciliation, grounding, and love, contrasting the physical and emotional distance of the characters in earlier chapters, when fear and isolation reigned.
However, the celebration is bittersweet for Clarion: Though she reconnects with the others, she separates from Milori. While the romantic fantasy genre often portrays love as redemptive, in Saft’s iteration, it’s also destructive. Milori sacrifices his wings for Clarion. She, in turn, sacrifices her heart for Pixie Hollow. If she hadn’t, the damage might have extended beyond either of them alone to all the realms and their people. Clarion experiences romantic love but must ultimately relinquish her heart’s desire to fulfill a higher calling. Her emotional journey parallels the mythical arc of the star from which she was born: brilliant, distant, and destined to carry others’ wishes rather than her own. Milori first sees Clarion’s star falling and makes a wish, not knowing that she would later become the queen who both fulfills and denies that wish. As a result, their relationship becomes the tragic fulcrum upon which the greater unity of the queendom is achieved. This isn’t a fairy tale in which the queen and her lover live happily ever after. Their final parting on the border, framed by the elements of nature, is a symbolic coda for their story: personal sacrifice for the greater good.



Unlock all 48 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.