Wolf Hall

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of child abuse and illness or death.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. What surprised you most about Mantel’s portrayal of Thomas Cromwell in Wolf Hall? How did this characterization compare to your previous understanding of this historical figure or to other fictional portrayals of controversial historical figures, such as Robert Graves’ sympathetic depiction of Emperor Claudius in I, Claudius?

2. Mantel chose Wolf Hall as her title, referring to the Seymour family residence that barely appears in the novel. Did this choice feel puzzling or meaningful to you as you read? How did the metaphorical significance of wolves and predatory behavior throughout the story connect to this title?

3. Mantel creates an immersive Tudor world filled with sensory details about food, clothing, living conditions, and daily life. Which aspects of her historical recreation struck you as most vivid or surprising?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Have you ever encountered situations where your background affected how others perceived your abilities or worth, similar to Thomas Cromwell’s experience with the aristocracy constantly reminding him of his “low birth”?

2. Throughout the novel, we see Cromwell’s deep loyalty to Cardinal Wolsey even after his fall from grace. How do you balance loyalty to mentors or friends with professional ambitions or changing circumstances?

3. Memory plays a crucial role in shaping Cromwell’s character, from his abusive childhood to the loss of his wife and daughters. How have your own formative memories influenced your decisions and worldview? In what ways do you find yourself, like Cromwell, either embracing or running from your past?

4. Cromwell’s pragmatic approach to solving problems often conflicts with the idealism of characters like Thomas More. In your own life, have you faced similar choices between practical solutions and idealistic principles? Which approach do you typically favor?

5. The constant threat of disease in Tudor England forces characters to confront mortality in immediate ways. How has your awareness of life’s fragility shaped your priorities?

6. Many characters in Wolf Hall reinvent themselves, from Cromwell’s transformation from blacksmith’s son to royal counselor, to Anne Boleyn’s evolution from courtier to queen. Have you ever reinvented yourself or witnessed someone else do so? What prompted the change, and what remained constant beneath the new exterior?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. How does Mantel’s depiction of the English Reformation reveal the complex relationship between political power and religious authority? What parallels do you see between this historical upheaval and contemporary tensions between government and religious institutions?

2. Public perception and rumor dramatically affect political outcomes throughout the novel, from Cardinal Wolsey’s fall to Anne Boleyn’s coronation. How do these historical examples of “public opinion” compare to the role of media in today’s political landscape?

3. In Wolf Hall, a person’s family connections largely determine their opportunities and position. Despite the emphasis on meritocracy in many of today’s societies, how do family background and connections continue to influence career advancement and social mobility?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. Mantel’s distinctive use of present tense and the ambiguous pronoun “he” creates a unique reading experience. What effect did this narrative technique have on your understanding of Cromwell’s character? How does it differ from more traditional approaches to historical fiction?

2. Plays and theatrical performances appear throughout the novel as both entertainment and political metaphor. What insights does this recurring motif provide into the nature of power and performance at Henry’s court? How do characters like Anne Boleyn and Thomas More “perform” their roles?

3. Wolves serve as a central symbol in the novel, from the title to the phrase “man is wolf to man” (531). What does this imagery suggest about human nature and the political environment of Tudor England?

4. The literary rivalry between Thomas Cromwell and Thomas More creates a complex relationship between antagonists. How does this dynamic compare to other famous fictional feuds, such as the conflict between Javert and Jean Valjean in Victor Hugo’s Les Misérables?

5. Female characters in Wolf Hall navigate the severe constraints placed on women in Tudor society. How do women like Anne Boleyn, Katherine of Aragon, and Jane Seymour exercise power despite their limited formal authority?

6. Historical narratives appear as malleable and subjective throughout the novel. How does Mantel illustrate this theme through Cromwell’s observations and actions? What does she suggest about our own understanding of historical “truth”?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. Imagine you’re Thomas Cromwell writing a letter of advice to his son Gregory about navigating court politics. What wisdom would he impart based on his own experiences? How would his tone and guidance differ from the advice he might have received from his own father?

2. If you were to create a modern adaptation of Wolf Hall, which contemporary setting would provide the most interesting parallel to Henry VIII’s court? Describe the modern professions or institutions that would best capture the power dynamics Mantel portrays?

3. As the novel concludes, Thomas plans a visit to the Seymour family at Wolf Hall. Write a paragraph about what happens during this visit and how it sets up the events of the next book in Mantel’s trilogy, Bring Up the Bodies. What do you imagine Thomas hopes to accomplish?

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources.