You're Next

Nathaniel “Nate” Essex functions as a deuteragonist and, initially, an antagonistic foil whose internal conflict drives much of the story’s primary tension. A dynamic and round character, Nate is defined by the immense guilt he carries regarding his actions and his family’s history. His initial deception surrounding his argument with Ashley on his birthday directly contributes to her abduction and the group’s vulnerability, making him a key figure in the theme of The Corrosive Power of Secrets in Relationships. He intentionally hides the truth from his friends, believing he is to blame for her disappearance, which isolates him and complicates their rescue efforts. This secrecy stems from a complex mix of jealousy, love for Ashley, and loyalty to his friends, creating a palpable internal struggle. His actions, such as secretly including a medical power of attorney clause in their prenup, are framed as misguided attempts at protection that ultimately backfire, eroding trust and causing significant harm.

Despite his often-abrasive exterior, Nate possesses a powerful protective instinct that motivates his most pivotal actions. While his methods are frequently flawed, his underlying goal is to shield those he cares about from harm. The plan to send Ashley to a secure facility in Switzerland, concocted with her mother, is born from a genuine fear for her safety. His most significant redemptive act is his solo mission to rescue Ashley from Mallard Psychiatric Hospital. Armed with the legal document that broke Ashley’s trust, he confronts the hospital staff and successfully frees her, taking direct responsibility for correcting the situation his earlier actions helped create. This rescue marks a turning point for his character, shifting him from a source of conflict to a vital protector. His relationship with Ashley is further complicated by a unique sexual dynamic in which he derives pleasure from her inflicting pain, which he views as a form of penance for the guilt he feels over hurting her.

Nate undergoes the most significant transformation in the novel regarding his views on relationships, embodying the theme of Redefining Love and Security Beyond Monogamy. He begins the narrative staunchly opposed to sharing Ashley, telling her his rejection is a hard limit. This stance fractures the group and makes them susceptible to Jocelyn’s manipulations. Over the course of the story, his love for Ashley and his deep-seated brotherhood with the other men force him to confront his rigid beliefs. The climax of this journey occurs in the wilderness cabin, where Royce orchestrates a scenario that compels Nate to apologize and admit he was wrong. His subsequent participation in a sexual encounter with both Royce and Ashley signifies his complete acceptance of the polyamorous dynamic. He evolves from the primary obstacle to the relationship’s success to a fully integrated and loving partner, completing his arc from isolation to inclusion.

Royce D’Arenberg serves as the emotional architect of the group’s polyamorous relationship. Possessing a high degree of emotional intelligence, Royce often acts as a catalyst for communication and intimacy. He is the first to sense that Ashley’s text messages are not authentic, prompting the investigation that reveals her abduction. He is a vocal proponent of including Nate in the relationship, understanding that the group can only be whole with all four men united. In the wilderness cabin, he orchestrates a confrontation that forces Nate to admit his feelings, telling Ashley to “Face Nate, so he can see everything he’s turning down” (125). This act is not one of manipulation but of facilitation, designed to heal the fracture within their found family and solidify their bond.

Royce’s character is marked by a compelling duality of playfulness and ferocity. On the surface, he is charming, witty, and often uses humor to navigate difficult situations. He maintains a lighthearted demeanor even while pushing his friends to confront uncomfortable truths. However, this playful exterior conceals a capacity for extreme violence when those he loves are threatened. This is most evident during the confrontation with the Devil’s Backbone elders; when Ashley’s life is in danger, Royce reacts with shocking brutality, single-handedly killing a guard and an elder without hesitation. This violent outburst reveals the depth of his protective instincts and underscores the lengths he will go to for his family. His actions are not those of a cold-blooded killer but of a fiercely loyal man pushed to his absolute limit. This duality makes him both a comforting presence and a formidable protector. His struggle is also shaped by the emotional neglect of his father, Colonel Mike D’Arenberg, which fuels his unwavering devotion to the family he has chosen.

Carter Bassington’s primary role is that of a protector, utilizing his immense wealth and resources to ensure the safety of his loved ones. When Ashley goes missing, he immediately hires private investigators, demonstrating his default method of problem-solving: applying financial power. He later places private security at her workplace and is the one to arrange for her academic absences to be excused, believing his resources can shield her from any negative consequences. This approach, however, sometimes conflicts with Ashley’s desire for independence, creating minor friction in their relationship. Carter’s actions are driven by a deep-seated need to provide a bubble of security for the people he loves, even if his methods are occasionally overbearing.

Characterized by his impulsivity and a fiercely possessive nature, Carter offers overt passion and emotional intensity the group dynamic. He is often the first to resort to aggression or threats when Ashley is in danger, and his temper is quick to ignite on her behalf. This intensity carries over into their sexual relationship, which is often marked by spontaneity and a raw, almost desperate need to connect with her. He initiates sexual encounters in her mother’s kitchen and a funeral home, seizing opportunities to physically reaffirm their bond in moments of high stress. His nickname for her, “Spark,” reflects his view of her as a vibrant, essential force in his life, one he is determined to hold onto at all costs. Despite this aggressive and sometimes domineering exterior, Carter reveals a profound emotional vulnerability, admitting to Ashley after her car crash, “If I lost you, my life wouldn’t be worth living” (253). This confession exposes the tender heart beneath his tough facade, revealing that his greatest fear is losing the woman who has become his entire world.

Heath Briggs functions as the group’s emotional anchor and voice of reason. Having survived Jocelyn’s earlier manipulations, which led to his near-fatal attempt to die by suicide, he possesses a unique and empathetic understanding of the psychological trauma Ashley endures. This shared experience makes him a crucial source of comfort for her. When she is rescued from the hospital, she clings to Heath as proof that her reality is intact. His steady presence is a constant source of stability for the entire group; Nate trusts him enough to send his location before the rescue, and Heath often mediates conflicts between the others. He provides a calm, nurturing counterbalance to the more volatile energies of Carter and Royce.

Heath’s quiet confidence and unwavering support are defining traits. He does not rely on wealth like Carter or overt orchestration like Royce; instead, his love is expressed through consistent, gentle acts of care. After the traumatic lake explosion, he is the one who calmly washes the blood from Ashley’s body, humming to soothe her as she processes the horror. During her subsequent panic attack, he grounds her with breathing exercises and provides the reassurance she needs to overcome her fear. His love is not performative but is deeply integrated into his actions. He is also secure enough in himself and his relationship with Ashley to fully support Nate’s inclusion in their dynamic, recognizing that Nate’s happiness is essential to the well-being of their unconventional family. His steadfast devotion and emotional maturity make him a pillar of strength for everyone in the group.

Jocelyn Reynard, who also operates under the name Dr. Russo, is the novel’s primary antagonist. She is a static but round character, an intelligent scientist whose motivations are a twisted combination of professional ambition and a deep-seated vendetta against her ex-husband, Max Essex, and his wife, Carina. As the architect of the central conflict, Jocelyn weaponizes hypnosis, drugs, and gaslighting to manipulate her targets, viewing them not as people but as “test subjects” in her unethical experiments with mind control. Her methods are cruel and calculated, demonstrating a complete lack of empathy, even toward her own son, Nate, whom she repeatedly endangers and ultimately tries to have killed. Her goal is to prove the success of her research, and she is willing to destroy countless lives to achieve it. Her character remains unchanged throughout the narrative; her motivations of revenge and scientific obsession never waver, making her a consistent and terrifying threat.

Carly is Ashley’s fiercely loyal best friend and serves as a vital supporting character and occasional foil. She often provides an outsider’s perspective and common-sense solutions when the group is entangled in the conspiracies of the Devil’s Backbone Society. Her suggestion to request a police wellness check is a practical strategy that highlights her clear-headedness in moments of crisis. Despite being Heath’s cousin, her unwavering allegiance is to Ashley. She becomes a trusted, integrated member of the unconventional family, providing Ashley with a crucial link to normalcy and female companionship amidst her primary relationships with men.