Beautiful Country: A Memoir

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of racism

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. How did Wang’s decision to write from her seven-year-old perspective affect your reading experience? Does this narrative choice remind you of other memoirs that use a younger perspective, such as Jeannette Walls’s The Glass Castle, and if so, how did they compare in their effectiveness?

2. What moments in the memoir surprised you most about the realities of undocumented life in America?

3. What does the title Beautiful Country mean to you after reading Qian’s story?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Have you ever found yourself in a caregiving role that felt too big for your age or circumstances? How did Qian’s experience of protecting and caring for Ma Ma resonate with your own experiences of responsibility?

2. Can you think of a time when you experienced a dramatically different living situation that made you see your own circumstances in a new light? What did Qian’s reaction to staying at Lin Ah Yi’s house reveal about the deprivation she’d been experiencing?

3. What experiences have shaped your sense of identity in ways you didn’t expect? How did reading about Qian’s shifting perception of herself after moving to America resonate with changes you’ve experienced in your own life?

4. Why do you think Qian felt compelled to experiment with different versions of herself at school? Have you ever felt the urge to try on a different identity in a new environment?

5. What role has fear played in your decisions about when to speak up for yourself or others?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. The memoir reveals how fear of deportation shapes every aspect of an undocumented family’s daily life. How do you think this constant anxiety affects children’s development and sense of security?

2. How do the racist encounters Qian faces from people like Mr. Kane reflect broader societal attitudes toward immigrant children? What patterns do you recognize from your own observations of how immigrant students are treated in schools?

3. What does the book suggest about the relationship between economic desperation and vulnerability to exploitation? How do Ma Ma’s experiences in various jobs illustrate the ways poverty and immigration status can trap people in harmful situations?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. How does Wang use the recurring motif of “loss of voice” to connect Qian’s childhood silencing to her eventual decision to write this memoir? What does this pattern reveal about the long-term effects of being forced into silence?

2. What purpose does the role reversal between Qian and her parents serve in developing the memoir’s larger themes? How does Wang show the ways that immigration and poverty disrupt traditional family dynamics?

3. Wang chose “trapdoors” as a metaphor for the dangers Qian faced navigating New York City alone. What makes this image particularly effective for capturing a child’s experience of urban threats?

4. The Chatham Square library serves as more than just a place for Qian to read books. How does Wang use this space to explore themes of belonging, refuge, and self-education?

5. Ba Ba’s experiences during China’s Cultural Revolution created trauma that later affected his entire family in America. How does the memoir illustrate the ways historical violence echoes through generations?

6. Why does the judge’s comment about the power of secrets serve as such an important turning point for Wang? How does this moment tie together the memoir’s exploration of silence and voice?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. What kind of support system would you design for families like the Wangs who are navigating life as undocumented immigrants? How could communities address practical needs while also helping to alleviate the emotional toll of living in constant fear?

2. Which teacher’s approach in the memoir do you think had the most positive impact on Qian, and why? What specific strategies would you implement if you were teaching students who might be facing similar challenges?

3. What public figures or stories have most inspired your own sense of possibility? Describe these figures or stories in terms of their impact on you.

Need more conversation starters? Inspire your group with our Discussion Questions tool.