47 pages • 1-hour read
Eric PuchnerA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of illness, death, death by suicide, and addiction.
Cece is hiking one day and gets lost. A ranger directs her, and when she returns home just as it is getting dark, Garrett is worried. She does not tell him that she has been hearing a strange, whispering voice, but Garrett has noticed that she has been mixed up as of late. He insists that Cece see a doctor.
The doctor gives Cece a cognitive test. Part of the test requires that she draw a clock, and Cece cannot. The doctor wants Cece to see a neurologist for further testing and gives her a pamphlet with instructions on ways to stave off Alzheimer’s disease.
Over the next few days, Cece remains angry and embarrassed at failing the test. She calls Lana, but Lana is too busy to talk. Cece stops at her bookstore, but it is quiet, and she tells her clerk to close early. One day, she culls unsold used books from the shelves, which she and Garrett box up to donate to a nearby nursing home. At the nursing home, Cece insists on peeking into the memory care unit. Residents sit in a circle, hitting a balloon with foam pool noodles. Many cannot make contact with the balloon. On the car ride home, Cece studies the Alzheimer’s pamphlet, determined to follow all its mandates to sharpen her cognitive abilities.
Garrett and Charlie hike together in an area in Montana where they used to ski. Charlie, at 74, has had some kidney issues, and Garrett has had some skin cancer removed, but they are both generally healthy. A few of their friends have died; Jasper, too, has died of an overdose—Charlie has never been sure if it was intentional or accidental. They talk a bit about Elias, whose death Garrett finally feels less at fault for. Then, for the first time, they talk about Garrett’s marriage to Cece. Charlie insists that Cece is happier with Garrett than she would have ever been with him, though Garrett argues that she would have been equally happy with either man.
They head back to the Margolis cottage, where Lana is caring for Cece, whose Alzheimer’s has advanced. Garrett talks with her constantly, though he knows that she is merely playing along with what he is saying. He takes her for a walk out to Salish Lake, which is shrinking due to the effects of climate change. He reminds her of the day they first met, telling her that she was swimming at the time. Impulsively, he wades into the cold water.
The narrative briefly shifts to Cece’s point of view: She is searching for Garrett, though she cannot remember his name.
The narrative returns to Garrett’s point of view: While he waded into the water, Cece wandered off the dock where he had left her. As he ran off in search of her, Garrett tripped and cut his knee. In the cottage, Lana cleans his wound. Cece was located outside by Charlie. Cece is cheerful, as if nothing has happened, humming to herself as she often does. Before Garrett and Cece head home, Charlie shows Garrett a small box: In it is the wedding ring that Cece gave him years ago.
Much of the town of Salish is destroyed by a wildfire, including the Margolis cottage. Lana, now a successful documentarian, arrives there with her cameras and latest girlfriend to take shots for a film she hopes to make as a kind of tribute to Jasper. Cece has been admitted to a care facility, and though she does not know Garrett’s name, she is agitated when he is not there.
The final chapter depicts the wedding ceremony of Cece and Charlie, primarily from Cece’s point of view. Garrett, while officiating, speaks extemporaneously, inviting the guests to envision Charlie and Cece’s future. He paints a picture of what it might look like, emphasizing scenes from Salish Lake as a key element.
By the time the reception is well underway, Charlie escapes to bed, too sick to be among the guests. At the end of the night, the guests begin jumping into the lake, and Cece joins them.
The final section brings closure to many of the key conflicts throughout the novel. Cece’s dementia cannot be staved off, but in an ironic twist, it brings her closer to Garrett. Despite her cognitive decline and frequent confusion, she still loves and trusts Garrett. Though she cannot recall his name, she knows him in an instinctive way and is truly content and unagitated only when she is in his presence. This is a reversal of the years that Garrett spent away from Cece doing fieldwork. It is, in a sense, as though she is both regaining the connection they lost to physical distance in those years and affirming her choice of a marriage partner. Their closeness in this period resolves The Evolving Purpose of Marriage: Their love and marriage have been imperfect, but it has been meaningful and satisfying, nonetheless. Commitment and Its Costs caused Cece to place Garrett’s career above her own professional pursuits and personal endeavors in many cases, but in the end, she is content with the life she’s had.
Importantly, the novel’s ending brings about a kind of resolution to the tension between Charlie and Garrett. Throughout their adult lives, Garrett has been tormented by the sense that he betrayed his friend by “stealing” Cece from him. He has paradoxically longed to talk openly about this with Charlie and dreaded the possibility of Charlie broaching the subject. When Charlie finally does so at age 74, the topic of Cece dovetails with the topic of Elias’s death. Garrett has spent a lifetime berating himself for both incidents, blaming himself for the harmful repercussions of events that were largely beyond his control. Charlie forgives Garrett, though not in so many words, assuring Garrett that Cece made the right choice. By finally discussing this matter, Garrett frees himself from the burden of Elias’s death and the harm he has done to his friendship with Charlie.
Charlie, too, finds a kind of peace with the way his life has turned out, content with friendship instead of marriage. That he has kept the wedding ring that Cece gave him decades earlier suggests that he will never truly “get over” Cece. He will always love her more than he can ever love another woman, but he has accepted this, and in doing so, he has found peace and contentment. Accepting that he will always love Cece and conveying this truth to Garrett is freeing for Charlie.
Lana also experiences complicated thoughts about marriage in this section—these largely come as she observes her parents’ marriage, not unlike what Garrett did at her age. As her father was then, she is skeptical about marriage, unwittingly reiterating his disdain for the institution. She is filled with compassion for the way her parents’ marriage has directly and indirectly caused pain for others—namely Charlie and Jasper. She cares greatly for Jasper, as evident in her decision to make a documentary about the destruction of Salish by wildfire. Both the fire itself and the film dramatize Human Impacts on the Environment, and this environmental destruction also symbolizes the emotional fallout of individual choices, such as Cece’s choice to marry Garrett. Lana recognizes, in ways that her parents do not, that much of Jasper’s pain stemmed indirectly from a kind of emotional abandonment. Jasper felt abandoned by his father, Charlie, who unintentionally directed his love toward Cece. Lana, importantly, has seen the love that Charlie has for Jasper and has witnessed his deep desire to help him, and she understands that Charlie is not to blame for Jasper’s death.
The destruction of the Margolis cottage by wildfire brings an end to an era, as if to close the door on the friendship between Charlie, Garrett, and Cece. The fire proves the certainty that Garrett has professed throughout his life that human interference negatively impacts the natural world. It is as though the natural world is both reclaiming the land from humans and wiping away the damage that humans have done, as if to erase the past and start fresh. This serves as a parallel for the renewed relationship between Charlie and Garrett.



Unlock all 47 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.