78 pages 2-hour read

John Gwynne

Malice

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2021

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 38-50Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of graphic violence and death.

Chapter 38 Summary: “Cywen”

Long after Midsummer, Cywen spars with Corban, who has become a skilled fighter and easily defeats her. Later, Princess Edana arrives and reveals that she saw Cywen’s mother, Gwenith, in a secret meeting with the King and Queen.


They find Corban, who knows nothing of the meeting. Edana explains that her father plans to clear the Darkwood of outlaws and has called a gathering of nearby kings at the giants’ stone circle on Midwinter’s Day to discuss the prophecy about the sun going dark.

Chapter 39 Summary: “Veradis”

Nathair, Veradis, Calidus, and the giant Alcyon leave the rest of their men behind and embark on a search for Telassar, a fortress hidden by a magical glamour. At their campfire, Nathair expresses a desire to ride a draig, and Alcyon swears an oath to find him an egg. Calidus describes the Jehar as fanatical warriors awaiting the God-War and suggests that Nathair, as a Giant-Friend and aspiring Draig-Rider, is the prophesied Bright Star, or Seren Disglair, whom they will support.


The next day, they find the passage through the glamour into a hidden vale. A Jehar patrol, stunned when Nathair announces he is the Seren Disglair, escorts them to their lord, Sumur. Nathair’s voice booms with unnatural power as he speaks of the prophecy. Calidus then reveals that he is one of the Ben-Elim, one of Elyon’s battle angels, unfurling great white wings. Awestruck, Sumur kneels and pledges the Jehar’s allegiance.

Chapter 40 Summary: “Kastell”

Feeling ostracized even in his home in Mikil, Kastell learns from Maquin that Jael is spreading rumors that he is behind the theft of the starstone axe. Maquin again urges him to join the Gadrai, the warriors who defend against giants, but Kastell feels obligated to accept King Romar’s request that he co-lead an anti-Hunen campaign with Jael.


Later, Kastell attempts to make peace with Jael, who mocks him and alludes to his father’s past transgressions. When Jael threatens Maquin, Kastell attacks. Jael’s men intervene, and one stabs Kastell in the back. Jael lets Kastell go, certain that King Romar will now deal with him.


Instead, Kastell finds Maquin and announces that he is ready to join the Gadrai. He has already secured a sealed letter from a disappointed Romar for the Gadrai’s leaders.

Chapter 41 Summary: “Corban”

Months after Edana’s revelation, Corban halters his colt for the first time. Vonn, Helfach, and Rafe arrive with Helfach’s hound, Braen. After they taunt Corban, he sends Cywen away with Storm. Enraged, Helfach orders Braen to attack. The hound tackles Corban and bites his arm, but as it lunges for his throat, Corban’s colt charges in, killing the hound with its hooves. Storm rushes back to stand guard over Corban. A devastated Helfach leaves, but Vonn apologizes and advises Corban to see Brina for his wound. Corban names his protective colt Shield.

Chapter 42 Summary: “Veradis”

Veradis and Nathair’s warband return to Jerolin. After an emotional reunion with King Aquilus and Queen Fidele, Nathair is cold toward Aquilus’s battlechief, Peritus.


Three moons later, Nathair arranges a sparring match where Veradis defeats the long-unbeaten weapons-master Armatus, Peritus’s friend. Nathair explains that the match was a political move against Peritus’s influence. Veradis urges Nathair to tell Aquilus he is the Bright Star, but Nathair refuses, fearing that his father won’t believe him.


Queen Fidele confronts Nathair about rumors of him using sorcery, giants, and the Vin Thalun in Tarbesh. He deflects, blaming Peritus, but Fidele sternly warns him to sever his illicit ties before the King discovers the truth.

Chapter 43 Summary: “Corban”

Corban’s party, including Gar, Cywen, Dath, and Brina, travels with King Brenin’s retinue to a Midwinter gathering at the Ardan city of Badun. On the road, two mysterious riders join them.


At the fortress, Edana reports that King Owain of Narvon has arrived, but Queen Rhin of Cambren and King Eremon of Domhain have not. Brenin speaks with Lord Gethin, Evnis’s brother, the leader of Badun. Edana speculates that the newcomers have sought Sanctuary with Brenin.


The next day, Queen Rhin arrives with her champion, followed by a party from Domhain led by the warrior Rath, representing King Eremon.

Chapter 44 Summary: “Evnis”

Evnis sees his brother Gethin and feigns affection. He reflects on the power of his black stone necklace, believing it to be one of the Seven Treasures. He overhears Halion and Conall discussing their need to remain concealed. Evnis decides to inform Queen Rhin that the two people she is hunting have taken Sanctuary with King Brenin’s party.

Chapter 45 Summary: “Corban”

On Midwinter’s Eve, Queen Rhin breaches protocol by insisting her champion, Morcant, sit at the high table. After Lord Gethin announces his daughter Kyla’s betrothal to King Owain’s son Uthan, Rhin confronts Brenin, demanding that he surrender the two people under his protection. Brenin refuses, so Rhin invokes the Court of Swords.


Brenin’s first-sword, Tull, faces Morcant in a long and brutal duel. In the end, Tull throws dirt in Morcant’s face, blinding him long enough to break his ankle. Brenin spares the defeated Morcant’s life, but Tull cuts his cheek as a final lesson.

Chapter 46 Summary: “Veradis”

On Midwinter’s Day, an anxious Veradis joins Nathair, Aquilus, Fidele, Peritus, Counselor Meical, and King Mandros on Jerolin’s battlements to watch the sky for the supposed blotting of the sun. A black shadow moves across the sun, and the air grows dramatically colder. As the sky darkens, Meical staggers and Nathair collapses, unconscious.

Chapter 47 Summary: “Corban”

As the sun darkens, Corban collapses. He finds himself in the Otherworld, a misty, spirit version of the stone circle where they have gathered to watch the sun. A man with yellow eyes appears, asking Corban to help him. Corban fears the man and refuses to fight for him. Enraged, the man summons six dark, winged creatures, but a horn sounds and white-winged warriors descend to battle them.


A white-winged warrior with purple-tinged eyes grabs Corban, touches his temple, and he blacks out. Corban awakens in a cottage, surrounded by his friends and family. He learns he only fainted briefly but retains a fleeting memory of wings and purple eyes. Gar announces that the council is over, and Brenin is preparing to leave.

Chapter 48 Summary: “Veradis”

Nathair recovers, disappointed to have missed the eclipse, and resolves to tell his father he is the Bright Star. Before he can, however, King Aquilus and Meical confront him with the truth of his illicit alliance with the Vin Thalun. Furious, Aquilus declares his trust broken.


Nathair names the Vin Thalun Calidus as his spymaster, horrifying Aquilus and Meical. Aquilus sends Veradis to fetch King Mandros, hoping the prophecy will sway him to ally with them, then dismisses Meical to speak with Nathair alone.


Veradis brings Mandros to the study but is told to wait outside. Mandros soon leaves, pale and shaken. Hearing silence, Veradis bursts in to find Nathair stabbed. Orcus arrives, and they find King Aquilus’s body near the window, his throat cut.

Chapter 49 Summary: “Corban”

On the journey home from Badun, Brina explains that the betrothal of Gethin’s daughter was a power play by him and Evnis to gain an ally. Back at home in Dun Carreg, Corban finds that his parents and Gar are unusually watchful.


While training, he sees Rafe and Crain bullying Farrell and intervenes. Storm’s presence forces the bullies to back down, though Rafe threatens a future reckoning. Farrell angrily rejects Corban’s help. Later, Corban sees Gar speaking with a tall, scarred man.

Chapter 50 Summary: “Veradis”

After Midwinter, Nathair’s army disembarks from Vin Thalun ships in Carnutan, Mandros’s kingdom. Following Aquilus’s murder and Mandros’s flight, Nathair planned a revenge campaign with Peritus in command. Nearly 3,000 warriors land for a surprise attack on Mandros’s fortress, Dun Bagul.


The next day, Veradis leads the vanguard across the river and is ambushed. His warband forms a shield wall, absorbing the charge and pushing to the far bank, but Veradis is wounded. As Mandros’s forces press their advantage, horns sound from a hill. Gundul, Mandros’s son, leads a charge against his own father’s army.

Chapters 38-50 Analysis

This section further explores The Burdens of Lineage and the Trials of Manhood through the contrasting development of Corban, Nathair, and Kastell. While all three young men navigate the path to adulthood, their moral and personal growth diverges based on their relationship with legacy and expectation. Corban’s maturation is depicted as an internal process, defined by empathy and self-awareness rather than noble birthright. His intervention on Farrell’s behalf leads to an important realization. When Farrell angrily rejects his help, Corban reacts with understanding, remembering “how he had felt when Rafe had first hit him during the Spring Fair, how scared, how angry, how ashamed that he’d done nothing” (384). This capacity for empathy, born from his own painful experiences, marks a significant step in his development. Nathair, in contrast, is consumed by the weight of his royal lineage, his actions driven by a need for his father’s approval and a thirst for power. His trials are external—battles and political maneuvering—but they foster arrogance and deceit, not wisdom. Kastell’s journey is framed as a struggle against a toxic lineage, as Jael goads him with allusions to his father’s transgressions. His decision to join the Gadrai represents an attempt to escape this inherited conflict and forge an identity separate from his family’s destructive feud. Through these parallel arcs, the text suggests that genuine maturity involves moral choice and establishing an independent identity.


The manipulation of prophecy is central to the text’s exploration of The Conscious Choice Between Good and Evil. The narrative resists a simple binary, instead illustrating how concepts of destiny and divine will can be weaponized for individual gain. Nathair’s conviction that he is the Bright Star is a belief he is led to by Calidus, who provides a framework of signs for Nathair to inhabit. Calidus tells him, “You are the prophecy, Nathair, living and breathing” (313), reframing the prince’s actions and associations to fit the prophesied criteria of “Giant-Friend” and “Draig-Rider.” This act of interpretation transforms Nathair’s ambition into a divine mandate, justifying his alliance with the Vin Thalun and his defiance of his father. Corban’s spiritual encounter during the eclipse provides a direct counterpoint. In the Otherworld, he confronts a yellow-eyed man who demands his allegiance but instinctively recognizes the figure’s malevolence, refusing him despite the threat of violence. Corban’s choice is internal and instinctual, based on moral intuition rather than external validation. This juxtaposition suggests that in a war defined by gods and prophecies, good and evil are determined by individual agency—one character’s willing submission to a manipulated destiny versus another’s intuitive rejection of a corrupting power.


The Corrupting Influence of Ambition and Power is a pervasive theme in these chapters, manifesting in the political machinations that drive the plot toward open conflict. Nathair’s ambition to prove himself worthy of his father’s legacy and the title of Bright Star leads him down a path of escalating deception, culminating in the confrontation that precipitates King Aquilus’s murder. His assertion to Queen Fidele that he will make decisions “as I see fit” reveals an arrogance that places his personal judgment above filial duty and his kingdom’s long-held principles. This mirrors the subtler ambition of Evnis and his brother Gethin. Brina’s observation that their arrangement of Kyla’s betrothal to Narvon’s heir is part of “[c]ircles within circles” identifies it as a calculated political move to elevate their family’s status (355). The duel between Tull and Morcant likewise transcends a mere contest of skill; it is a political instrument wielded by Queen Rhin to assert her authority and challenge Brenin’s, turning a matter of Sanctuary into a public display of power. In each instance, personal ambition overrides diplomacy, honor, and kinship, demonstrating how the pursuit of power erodes the foundations of social and political order.


The narrative uses parallel structure to heighten tension and underscore its central themes. The climactic events of Midwinter’s Day are juxtaposed across multiple chapters and locations. As Nathair collapses on the battlements of Jerolin, Corban experiences a spiritual vision at the stone circle. This structural choice directly contrasts the two characters at a pivotal moment. While Nathair’s story climaxes in political betrayal, Corban’s culminates in a moment of moral choice and spiritual warfare. The narrative has revealed Nathair’s secret alliances and the manipulative influence of Calidus, creating dramatic irony in his belief that he serves Elyon’s cause. Similarly, the narrative cuts between Corban’s intimate struggles—training his colt, navigating social hierarchies—and Nathair’s epic, world-shaping campaigns. This parallel structure implies that the central battle of the coming God-War is both epic and personal, fought in the heart of a blacksmith’s son as much as in the court of a prince.


A recurring motif of deception as a tool for both victory and manipulation connects the disparate plotlines. This is articulated in Corban’s training, where Halion instructs him that for masters, “[s]wordplay is about deception” (380). This principle is demonstrated in the duel between Tull and Morcant, where Tull defeats his younger, faster opponent by using cunning to create an opening. Deception is framed as a legitimate and necessary martial skill, a form of intelligence that overcomes physical limitations. This portrayal is contrasted with the political and spiritual deception practiced by other characters. Calidus deceives Nathair by selectively interpreting prophecy, while Nathair deceives his own father about the nature of his alliances. Evnis operates entirely through subterfuge, informing Rhin of Brenin’s actions and plotting from the shadows. The narrative distinguishes between tactical deception used to win an honorable fight and manipulative deceit used to achieve corrupt ends, suggesting that the morality of the act is defined by its intent and context.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 78 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs