57 pages 1-hour read

Murder by Cheesecake

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2025

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Symbols & Motifs

Food, Meals, and Celebrations

Food in Murder by Cheesecake functions as a symbol of community, comfort, and conflict, reflecting both the traditions of St. Olaf and the sustaining bond among the four protagonists. Cheesecake in particular, imported from the television series, represents the women’s shared ritual of processing hardship together. It is both a domestic comfort and a stage on which conflict plays out. The fact that Morty’s corpse is discovered in a freezer full of cheesecakes literalizes this dual symbolism—turning a familiar emblem of safety into a grotesque reminder of mortality.


Meals and celebrations consistently carry this doubleness. Rose’s St. Olaf’s Kiss cheesecake highlights her determination to uphold tradition, while the Corzons’ Cuban restaurant wedding shower integrates Miami culture, illustrating the possibility of blending old and new. Cookies after Nettie’s near-kidnapping symbolize healing and survival, suggesting that food restores emotional balance after danger. Even acts of betrayal are framed through food, as Chip uses cheesecake and a “rehearsal dinner” to lure the women into his trap, showing how hospitality can mask menace. The novel closes by restoring food to its original role, as Sophia comforts Dorothy with cheesecake, reasserting that shared meals are not only traditions but also emotional lifelines, affirming the theme of Friendship as a Source of Strength and Security.

Clothing

Clothing functions throughout the novel as a motif of identity, insecurity, and adaptation, highlighting how characters negotiate age, gender expectations, and cultural traditions. Dorothy’s anxious preparations for her date with Henry reflect her vulnerability, as clothing becomes a test of desirability and femininity. In contrast, Blanche’s flamboyant wardrobe affirms her confidence but also reveals her refusal to relinquish youthful attention. Clothing thus externalizes the theme of Agency in Later Life and Overcoming Stereotypes, as the women’s outfits signal both their anxieties about aging and their insistence on expressing individuality despite cultural judgment.


Wedding rituals further emphasize clothing as symbolic. Rose notices her relatives’ braids and milkmaid styles, contrasting with her more sophisticated look shaped by life in Miami, underscoring her tension between tradition and modernity. Disguises during the hotel stakeout highlight this motif, as Dorothy’s tight jeans and heavy makeup feel alien to her, symbolizing the discomfort of adopting roles that clash with authentic self-expression. Finally, the wedding attire fuses these threads. Jason wears a bunad vest in Miami’s colors, while Nettie dons Rose’s re-fashioned wedding gown. These garments embody cultural blending and generational continuity, symbolizing reconciliation between old traditions and new identities. Clothing thus operates as a visual shorthand for the novel’s central question of how individuals can honor their past while asserting their own agency in the present.

Performance and Disguise

Performance and disguise function as a motif of deception, adaptation, and revelation, highlighting how characters navigate identity and trust. Dorothy and Sophia’s hotel stakeout, complete with wigs, makeup, and invented backstories, demonstrates the role-playing inherent in both mystery work and social survival. These comic disguises also underline the theme of Agency in Later Life and Overcoming Stereotypes. Rather than fading into invisibility, the women actively manipulate appearances to gain power.


The motif also appears in more unsettling contexts. Morty impersonates Henry to facilitate his schemes, making mistaken identity a central engine of the mystery. Chip likewise performs respectability for Jason and Rose while secretly conducting smuggling operations. Even lighthearted performances, such as the clown hired for Nettie’s bachelorette, transform unexpectedly into discomfort or danger. Across these examples, performance blurs sincerity and duplicity, forcing characters to question appearances.


Ultimately, the motif reinforces the novel’s central concerns: Tradition itself is revealed as a kind of performance, a set of roles and costumes characters adopt to reassure others of belonging. The question becomes not whether performance is authentic, but whether it builds community or conceals betrayal.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock the meaning behind every key symbol & motif

See how recurring imagery, objects, and ideas shape the narrative.

  • Explore how the author builds meaning through symbolism
  • Understand what symbols & motifs represent in the text
  • Connect recurring ideas to themes, characters, and events