17 pages • 34-minute read
William WordsworthA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of child death.
“Threnody” by Ralph Waldo Emerson (1847)
Often compared to “Surprised by Joy,” “Threnody” examines Emerson’s grief over the death of his youngest son from scarlet fever. The poem shares Emerson’s grief and his argument with nature about the inevitability of death.
“We Are Seven” by William Wordsworth (1798)
In this poem, a young girl reveals to the speaker how one by one her family of seven had died leaving her alone. The poem emphasizes the dramatic irony between the adult speaker’s unwillingness to count the child’s dead relatives and her belief that she still has family members.
“Preface to The Lyrical Ballads” by William Wordsworth (1800)
Written to respond to criticism, this introductory essay added to the second edition of his groundbreaking collection lays out Wordsworth’s ideals: the importance of observation of the real world, the need to introduce into poetry the unadorned language of everyday speech, and the centrality of the emotions as the subject matter of serious poetry.
“Wordsworth’s Duty as a Poet in ‘We Are Seven’ and ‘Surprised by Joy’” by James Shokoff (1994)
Shokoff pairs two poems in which Wordsworth examines the psychological impact of grief on a family. The article concludes that the poems reveal the dynamics of loss and how memory both helps and frustrates healing.
“Wordsworth’s Anatomies of Surprise” by Christopher R. Miller (2007)
Miller draws on a Christian reading of surprise as awareness of a reality that transcends the material world. The article underscores Wordsworth’s emotional turmoil as he struggled to understand his grief and how the sudden intrusion of genuine insight could ease his melancholy.
“Surprise: Wordsworth on the Coexistence of Joy and Sorrow” by Inez Tan (2014)
In this philosophical look at the dynamics of grief and happiness, Tan explicates how the poem’s speaker is initially shocked and then hurt that he feels elation despite his grief. Tan argues that the speaker then convinces himself that joy, although a relief, has no place in his mourning yet.
Rebecca Budd reads “Surprised by Joy” by William Wordsworth
Although YouTube offers many recitations of the sonnet, perhaps the presentation that best captures the melancholy mood of the poem and the subtle staccato of Wordsworth’s fractured lines is Rebecca Budd’s reading. The reading is backed by piano and illustrated with desolate images of nature in winter. Budd invites the viewer to join her in the recitation, a complement to Wordsworth’s sense of the power of commiseration.
Budd, who has conducted a virtual reading club on her website for more than a decade, adds introductory commentary that puts the poem within its historical context.



Unlock all 17 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.