52 pages 1-hour read

The Better Sister

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2019

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 1, Chapters 7-14Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section includes discussion of substance abuse.

Part 1: “Adam”

Part 1, Chapter 7 Summary

Detective Guidry accompanies Chloe to the Dunhams’ house. Ethan’s expression is blank when he learns his father has been murdered. Guidry asks to speak to Ethan alone.

Part 1, Chapter 8 Summary

A contributor to the online forum Poppit reveals that Chloe is married to her brother-in-law. Another user asks if KurtLoMein can confirm whether this information is true.

Part 1, Chapter 9 Summary

While police officers search the East Hampton house for evidence, Chloe and Ethan move into the pool house. Chloe wonders if she will have to fight Nicky in court for custody of Ethan. Although Adam was awarded sole custody when Ethan was two, Nicky retained some parental rights. Chloe asks Detective Guidry to check if Nicky was in Cleveland at the time of Adam’s murder.

Part 1, Chapter 10 Summary

Detective Guidry questions Kevin Dunham, who claims that he and Ethan spent the previous night driving around and then returned to his house. When Guidry asks if they saw a movie first, Kevin confirms this is correct. Guidry knows Kevin is lying, as Ethan has already revealed that the movie they planned to see was sold out.

Part 1, Chapter 11 Summary

Chloe receives a message from her lover on her burner phone. Leaving the house unobserved, she replies to the message, saying they can no longer see each other. She disposes of the phone in a public trash can.


Catherine arrives after hearing about Adam’s death. She encourages Chloe to control the public’s perception of the event by issuing a press release through Eve.

Part 1, Chapter 12 Summary

Detective Guidry asks Chloe and Ethan to check the main house for any missing items. Their orderly vacation home has been ransacked, and Chloe adjusts three overturned vases. She explains that a friend made the vases to represent herself, Adam, and Ethan. The pieces fit together to create a unified whole.


Chloe observes that Adam’s bank cards and Tag Heuer watch are still on the nightstand, and no other valuables have been taken. However, Ethan declares that his Beats and Rayguns (expensive headphones and trainers) are missing. Chloe recalls Adam’s anger when he learned how much Ethan had paid for the headphones and trainers. She asks Guidry to investigate Adam’s movements on the days before his death. Although he claimed to be meeting a client from the Gentry Group, Chloe sensed he was hiding something.


Chloe and Ethan travel back to Manhattan. On the way, Ethan picks up the backpack that he left at Kevin’s house. Chloe recalls breaking up with her lover, Jake Summer, earlier that day. Jake did not know about Adam’s meeting with the Gentry Group before his death. Chloe wonders if her husband was having an affair.

Part 1, Chapter 13 Summary

Detective Bowen believes that Chloe killed her husband. Guidry reminds her partner that Chloe has an alibi and suggests that Bowen is prejudiced against Chloe because he doesn’t like “what she stands for” (93). She shows her colleague a photograph of the broken bedroom window through which the intruder apparently broke in. Guidry points out that the glass shards are scattered on top of a comforter on the floor and inside an open drawer. This indicates that the window was broken after the room was ransacked to give the false appearance of a break-in. Guidry suspects Ethan.

Part 1, Chapter 14 Summary

Chloe recalls Adam’s rage when he discovered a bag of marijuana in Ethan’s room. Unappeased by Ethan’s claim that it belonged to a friend, he accused his son of paying for his expensive shoes by dealing drugs. While Adam was shouting at Ethan, Chloe disposed of the marijuana, further angering her husband. Afterward, Chloe gave Ethan $500 to compensate his friend for the marijuana.


Chloe looks inside Ethan’s backpack and finds a burner phone. Ethan’s contacts are listed only by their initials. She places the phone in her office drawer.

Part 1, Chapters 7-14 Analysis

Narrative intrigue intensifies as the police investigation of Adam’s murder begins, and suspicion shifts from Chloe to Ethan. Burke creates an atmosphere of distrust and deceit as the secrets of the Macintosh family are gradually unearthed, hinting at The Complexity of Family Dynamics. Burner phones represent secrecy and dishonesty in these chapters, as it emerges that both Chloe and Ethan possess one. Chloe’s admission that she uses the phone to contact her lover, whose presence she had thus far withheld from the reader, signals her unreliability as a narrator. Meanwhile, Ethan’s motivations remain mysterious. Chloe’s suspicion that Adam lied about his whereabouts before his death contributes to the novel’s depiction of a family concealing significant aspects of their lives from one another. Furthermore, Chloe’s suspicion that her sister may be involved in the murder is apparent in her questioning whether Nicky was in Cleveland at the time of Adam’s death.


Chloe’s description of the ransacked state of her formerly idyllic vacation home introduces the symbolic nature of the Hamptons in the novel. The Macintosh family’s possession of a summer retreat in the affluent area reinforces the notion that they have it all. Its orderly state before Adam’s murder, worthy of “a real estate showing” (81), echoes the Macintoshes’ image as the perfect family unit. However, the house’s chaotic state post-murder is a more truthful representation of the family’s dysfunctional dynamics. This point is illustrated as Chloe recalls Adam’s furious outbursts at his son and how they fundamentally disagreed over how best to parent Ethan. Chloe’s impulse to correct the overturned ceramic vases, designed to represent the bond between Chloe, Adam, and Ethan, underlines her desire to maintain the façade of family unity. Although she reunites them to “fit perfectly together in a single form” (82), the fractures in her family are beginning to show.


In the aftermath of the murder, the theme of Public Image Versus Private Truth comes to the fore, as the importance of appearances is emphasized. Ethan becomes Detective Guidry’s prime suspect because he fails “Whatever test she had in mind for how a kid should act when he hears his father’s been murdered” (68). The police officer interprets Ethan’s blank expression as unnatural in the circumstances, pointing to his guilt and raising the intersecting theme of The Corruption of Law and Justice. In addition, Chloe’s background in publishing makes her particularly conscious that both the police and the public will be judging whether her behavior is appropriate for the widow of a recently murdered man. Having cast baseless aspersions on likely murder suspects as a journalist, she understands that “you needed someone who seemed guilty enough to deserve the public’s scornful attention, without quite enough evidence to back up the speculation. A chicken to stew in the pot” (75). Catherine Lancaster’s advice to Chloe, pressuring her to issue a press release about the murder through Eve, illustrates the magazine’s symbolic significance in the novel. Catherine’s suggestion that this is the only way to take charge of the public’s perception of Adam’s death reflects how the magazine allows Chloe to control and project her chosen narrative.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 52 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs