The Better Sister

Alafair Burke

52 pages 1-hour read

Alafair Burke

The Better Sister

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2019

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Prologue-Part 1, Chapter 6Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section includes discussion of physical abuse, death, and sexual violence and harassment.

Part 1: “Adam”

Prologue Summary: “Fourteen Years Earlier”

Chloe Taylor reveals that 14 years earlier, she “betrayed” her sister by agreeing to help her brother-in-law, Adam Macintosh, get custody after Nicky almost drowned their baby son. Four years later, Chloe married Adam. Ten years after that, she discovered Adam’s dead body.

Part 1, Chapter 1 Summary: “Fourteen Years Later”

Chloe is the chief editor of the successful “feminist-oriented” magazine Eve and is about to receive an award for her “#Them Too” publishing campaign. Inspired by the #MeToo movement, the series of articles exposed the sexual abuse and harassment that many ordinary women face in the workplace.


Chloe’s attorney husband, Adam, joins her for an interview. Chloe is uncomfortable when the reporter asks Adam how it feels to be married to such a successful wife, but her husband talks glowingly of her achievements. When they get home, Chloe expresses her gratitude to Adam and calls the interview “stupid.” Although exhausted, she does not object when Adam initiates sex, recalling how she once wrote an article presenting twice-weekly sex as the best way to preserve a marriage. Adam tells Chloe that he may be late for the awards ceremony the following evening, as he needs to meet with a client from the Gentry Group near JFK Airport.

Part 1, Chapter 2 Summary

Chloe checks her social media accounts, including online forum Poppit, before the awards ceremony. Alongside positive comments from her followers are the usual misogynistic posts, insulting, threatening, and objectifying Chloe. Some of the comments express rape fantasies. One contributor, “KurtLoMein,” states that Chloe is a “hypocrite” and “a coward” who “cares more about her picture-perfect image than actual reality” (21).

Part 1, Chapter 3 Summary

Chloe attends the awards ceremony with her 16-year-old stepson, Ethan. Adam is late, but Chloe is pleased to see her “octogenarian” friend, Bill Braddock, and his colleague, Jake Summer. Both men are partners at Rives & Braddock, the law firm where Adam is also a partner, due to Chloe’s influence with Bill. Bill claims to know nothing about Adam’s meeting with a client from the Gentry Group. Adam arrives just as Chloe goes up to get her award.

Part 1, Chapter 4 Summary

When Adam left Nicky and moved to Manhattan, Chloe recommended him to a friend in the US Attorney’s Office, where he became a federal prosecutor. She also helped him apartment-hunt and babysat Ethan. A year later, Chloe planned a formal dinner party for her birthday and asked her boyfriend Matt to buy her a serving platter for the occasion. However, Matt ended the relationship, critiquing Chloe for lacking spontaneity and planning every aspect of their life. Adam bought Chloe the platter, attending the party in Matt’s place, and they finally became a couple.

Part 1, Chapter 5 Summary

Chloe has secured a multi-million-dollar publishing deal for her memoir and earns more than Adam. She suspects that Adam is resentful of this disparity, although he denies it. After graduating from law school, Adam chose to become a government prosecutor rather than take a role with a private law firm. His desire to be on the right side of justice was motivated by his upbringing. Adam was determined to distinguish himself from his father, who was physically abusive to his wife and son and served prison time.


Chloe recalls how Adam once asked if she minded him working in a less lucrative field than private law. She assured her husband that she wanted him to be happy, while also pointing out that he could easily become a partner in a “big law firm” (39). To prove her point, she called Bill Braddock, and shortly afterward, Adam joined Rives & Braddock. Later in their marriage, Adam claimed that Chloe had pressured him into leaving a job he loved for one that better suited her lifestyle. Adam hates working for Rives & Braddock.


The day after the awards ceremony, Chloe, Adam, and Ethan plan to travel from New York to their second home in East Hampton. Adam claims to have another meeting with his clients from the Gentry Group, assuring Chloe that he will join them by late evening. He sends his apologies to Catherine Lancaster, Chloe’s friend and professional mentor, who is holding a party at her Sag Harbor home to celebrate Chloe’s achievements.

Part 1, Chapter 6 Summary

After Catherine’s party, Chloe comes home to discover Adam’s body in their East Hampton house. He has been stabbed to death.


At the police station, Chloe is questioned by Detective Jennifer Guidry and her male colleague, Detective Bowen. When Guidry asks why Adam failed to set their security alarm before going to bed, Chloe claims they rarely used the security system. She senses that the detectives see her as a prime suspect.


Chloe tells the detectives that Ethan spent the night at his friend Kevin Dunham’s house after seeing a movie. Detective Bowen notes that, as Chloe is Ethan’s stepmother, they need to call Ethan’s biological mother. Chloe reveals that Ethan’s birth mother is Nicky Macintosh, her sister.

Prologue-Part 1, Chapter 6 Analysis

The Prologue immediately establishes Adam Macintosh’s murder as the incident that drives the narrative, and Burke creates an undercurrent of tension by foreshadowing Adam’s murder before it occurs. Chloe Taylor’s revelation that she is estranged from her sister, Nicky, introduces emotional conflict. The Complexity of Family Dynamics is emphasized as Chloe admits that she not only sided with her brother-in-law in a custody battle but also eventually became “the second Mrs. Adam Macintosh” (6). The chapters that follow, describing Chloe’s receipt of a prestigious award, emphasize the impending impact of Adam’s violent death. Burke presents Chloe’s character at the peak of her achievements to illustrate how quickly her carefully constructed life will fall apart.


Chloe emerges as a multi-faceted protagonist with contradictory traits. A strong woman, she has earned her status as a feminist icon by championing women and publicly opposing misogyny and sexism. The attributes that make Chloe a role model to many women attract the hatred of misogynists, illustrated by the disturbing, sexually violent threats and abuse aimed at her on the online forum Poppit. Burke represents this abuse, fueled by male insecurity, as a testament to Chloe’s power and influence. However, the revelation that she betrayed her sister and appropriated Nicky’s husband and son in the process sits uncomfortably with these professional achievements. Thus, the narrative intimates that Chloe’s commitment to “sisterhood” does not extend to all areas of her life.


While the tone of the protagonist’s first-person narrative is frank, Burke signals that Chloe’s account is shaped by a desire to control the reader’s perception of her. Chloe’s desire to present herself as an ethical person is evident in her frequent self-justifications, particularly when she recognizes that her behavior reflects poorly on her. Relating how she encouraged Adam to move to Manhattan, 500 miles away from Nicky, she asserts he would “never really be able to protect Ethan while he was still in Cleveland” (33). Meanwhile, her declaration that becoming romantically entangled with Adam “was inevitable” suggests the role of destiny (36), minimizing her own agency. Similarly, Chloe’s claim that she supported Adam’s wish to remain a federal prosecutor is undercut by the revelation that she used her friendship with Bill Braddock to gain her husband a role in the private law firm. Chloe’s preoccupation with how others perceive her hints that there may be truth in KurtLoMein’s online claim that she “cares more about her picture-perfect image than actual reality” (21).


The theme of Public Image Versus Private Truth is also introduced through Chloe’s depiction of her marriage. While she and Adam appear to be the perfect couple when interviewed by a reporter, the narrative suggests that Adam’s professed pride in his wife’s achievements does not accurately reflect the dynamic of their relationship. Chloe’s discomfort when the reporter points out that she is the more successful partner in the marriage signals that the subject is a private source of conflict. Afterward, Chloe displays appeasing behavior with Adam. In addition to expressing gratitude for his public praise of her and agreeing to sex, she diminishes her own importance by referring to the interview as “stupid.” Burke depicts an unsettling contrast between Chloe’s fearless feminist persona and the placatory tactics she employs to ensure her husband does not feel emasculated. This insight into the uneasy balance of power between the couple is typical of the domestic noir genre, hinting at a darker aspect of their relationship that is yet to be revealed.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 52 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs