The Book Club for Troublesome Women

Marie Bostwick

58 pages 1-hour read

Marie Bostwick

The Book Club for Troublesome Women

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2025

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 19-28Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of gender discrimination, mental illness, and death by suicide.

Chapter 19 Summary: “Dearly Beloved”

Margaret’s writing is so popular that the magazine asks her to write for every issue instead of monthly. Invigorated, she uses her new income to buy the typewriter she has been renting, which she has named Sylvia. However, as much as she loves her job, Margaret worries that her writing is too frivolous, considering everything going on in the world. Every time she tries to sneak something more meaningful into her writing, Mr. Clement edits it out and subtly threatens to fire her if she doesn’t “stick to the script” (185). Adding to Margaret’s discomfort, he has recently asked her to write a piece featuring diet gelatin, one of their advertisers. Margaret feels she has no choice but to comply.


In June of 1963, the Bettys gather to discuss Dearly Beloved by Anne Morrow Lindbergh. Charlotte is unable to make it as she is busy preparing Denise’s graduation party. Bitsy breaks the double good news that Delilah seems to be recovering, and she might be pregnant. Things with King are okay, too; after their initial fight, he disappeared for five whole days. He returned with roses and an apology, and while Bitsy let him stew for a while, she eventually forgave him. Viv tells them that Tony, too, eventually got over her keeping the pregnancy a secret from him.


Margaret broaches the subject of the book. She privately reflects that one of the scenes featuring the mother of the bride reminded her of her own mother’s final months, filled with “dark rooms and darker moods” (190). The other two sheepishly admit they haven’t read the book yet.

Chapter 20 Summary: “Absent Hosts”

As Bitsy and King arrive at Denise’s graduation party, Bitsy reflects on how solicitous King has been since he returned. While he was contrite and considerate, and she made efforts to forgive him, a part of her is still angry at him for not outright apologizing and admitting that she was right.


The Bettys and their husbands congregate at the party, wondering where Charlotte and Denise are amidst the crowd. Tony congratulates Walt on having a celebrity writer in the family, but to Margaret’s anger and astonishment, Walt dismisses her work, calling it a “jobette” that only brings in pin money. Understanding Margaret’s hurt, Viv takes her and Bitsy away from the men.


Charlotte is on the phone with Ahlgern, trying to secure an introduction to a museum curator. She is interrupted by her mother Patricia, who instructs her to hang up the phone. Patricia doesn’t believe that nothing is going on between her and Ahlgren; she reveals that Charlotte’s father had her followed in New York and knows she met Ahlgren. She threatens Charlotte, saying that if she doesn’t fall in line, they will take her money and her children. She says that a judge would not see her as a fit mother because of her “history of instability” (201), and then she orders Charlotte to join the party.

Chapter 21 Summary: “Click”

Denise has been gifted a camera as a graduation present by her grandparents. Eager to avoid the crowd at her party, she takes candid photographs instead. She looks for Charlotte in the gardens, wanting to take a photograph of her mother; instead, she finds Howard and another woman in an intimate embrace in the bushes and secretly takes photographs of them.

Chapter 22 Summary: “Argument Interrupted”

All the way home, Margaret and Walt fight about his comment about her job. Walt refuses to apologize, and Margaret refuses to back down. When they get home, however, they are interrupted by their daughter Beth, who tells them about an urgent phone call from Walt’s mother. Walt’s father Jerry has had a stroke, and Margaret immediately rushes to help Walt pack for the journey. The argument is forgotten, but Walt half-apologizes before he leaves, telling Margaret he loves her.


Jerry passes away, and Walt stays on to handle affairs. He calls Margaret every night, and their conversations are brief but loving. Eventually, he says he is coming home, and Margaret promises to be ready with a hearty breakfast for him. Meanwhile, Denise leaves for Oxford, and Margaret makes good on her promise to the young girl, checking in on Charlotte every day; so far, Charlotte seems to be doing well.


That night, Margaret has her nightmare again: She walks through a sparkling clean house, the one she grew up in. She opens the refrigerator, which is filled with enough meals for the next week. She climbs the stairs in search of her mother, and when she eventually opens her parents’ bedroom door, she cries out. She is woken up by Walt, who has arrived home in the middle of the night; nevertheless, she cannot shake the grief of having found her mother, who died by suicide. She still feels guilty, as she had promised her father she would watch over her mother, and she believes she failed.


Walt holds her and reassures her, beginning to apologize for what he said at the party. Margaret silences him and pulls him into bed.

Chapter 23 Summary: “The Way Things Are”

In the morning, Margaret makes Walt a homecoming breakfast as promised. As he eats, Walt reflects on how his father was an “angry, bitter, controlling, critical, miserable man” (218), and he worries that he is turning into his father, especially when he drinks. Walt promises to cut back on the alcohol and apologizes again for what he said at Denise’s party. He admits he is jealous of Margaret because she has found a job she loves. Margaret is surprised to discover that Walt hates his job and only does it to provide for his family.


After Walt heads to work, Margaret contemplates how curious, fun-loving Walt eventually settled on a major and a career back in college to fulfill his promise that he would take care of her once they were married. She thinks about an earlier conversation with Viv, in which the latter claimed that some women, like single parents forced to work, were left out of the conversation in The Feminine Mystique; Margaret realizes that this also applies to Walt, who is just as trapped as she is. She suddenly has an idea for a new, meaningful column for the magazine.

Chapter 24 Summary: “Two Places at Once”

At work, Viv meets Earlene Jackson, a patient who reveals that she is a nurse and served in the Army Nurse Corps during the war, just like Viv. However, because she is Black, she wasn’t allowed to be deployed overseas and served at segregated camps in North Carolina, treated injured Black soldiers and German prisoners of war. They discuss how rewarding their work is, but that it is also hard to do while raising kids.


Mrs. Graham brings a friend of hers, Alice Brennan, a professor at University of California Davis’s school of veterinary medicine, to meet Bitsy at the stables. Impressed by Bitsy’s management of Delilah’s laminitis, Alice instructs her to apply to the program. She knows that being a woman in the profession can be lonely and wants to uplift other women with her established presence in the field. Overwhelmed, Bitsy notes she cannot attend veterinary school at the moment because she is pregnant. Alice gives Bitsy her business card in case she reconsiders in the future.


Viv arrives home to find her oldest daughter Andrea in tears; Jenny, Viv’s five-year-old, has climbed the roof and is preparing to jump, convinced by her brothers that she can fly. After chastising her sons, Viv convinces Jenny to “fly” into her arms instead and extracts a promise to never attempt this again.

Chapter 25 Summary: “Not Paid to Think”

Margaret and Walt’s relationship improves substantially after Jerry’s death and Walt’s epiphany. He drinks less, is more attentive and present with Margaret and the children, and is vocally and sincerely appreciative of her job. However, Margaret gets a phone call from Mr. Clement, who berates her for her latest piece: Inspired by her realization about Walt’s life, she penned a light-hearted yet meaningful piece about gender roles. Mr. Clement threatens to fire her if she writes another piece like it.


Margaret remembers an argument between her parents in which her mother said she felt a lack of purpose, and her father, not understanding what more she could possibly want, admonished his wife for her dissatisfaction. Her mother became depressed and died by suicide, leaving no note. Margaret contemplates how the satisfaction she feels from seeing her name in print is too valuable to risk angering Mr. Clement.

Chapter 26 Summary: “Truth-Telling”

Later that night, Margaret gets a call from Charlotte, who is drunk and somewhere in the city. Margaret manages to track her down in a bar, and Charlotte reveals that she met with Ahlgern earlier that day. Ahlgern lured her to his hotel room under the pretext of introducing her to an important curator, but Charlotte refused to sleep with him, even for the sake of her career.


Margaret suggests that Charlotte divorce Howard, but she insists that she cannot, as she will lose her money and her children. She points out that the men in her life hold all the power because they have all the money, and there is nothing she can do. Infuriated, Margaret calls Charlotte out for her cowardice, claiming that her talk about rights and quality is just a thing she plays at, like her painting. She says that Charlotte puts more effort into complaining about the unfairness of the art world than she actually does into painting something original. When she urges Charlotte to take herself more seriously, Charlotte points out that this is hypocritical coming from Margaret, who wants to be a serious writer but never writes anything meaningful. Charlotte steps out to find a cab, spitefully refusing to let Margaret take her home.

Chapter 27 Summary: “Simultaneous Circumstances”

Three days after their fight, Margaret calls Charlotte to apologize, but Charlotte cuts her off mid-apology, claiming she doesn’t have time to talk. Two weeks pass with silence between them. This worries Margaret, but Viv assures her that Charlotte is all right and just needs time to get over her anger.


Margaret meets with Beth’s school principal and convinces him to allow Beth to play the trombone in the school band, despite his reservations that the instrument is too masculine.


Viv resigns from the clinic, bringing Earlene on as her replacement. Viv and Dr. Giordano share a teary goodbye, with the latter hoping that Viv will return someday. At present, Viv wants to savor the last summer she has with all her children at home as her oldest, Vince, plans to enlist after high school.


Charlotte visits Nikolai Fedorov, an elderly Russian gallery owner in Philadelphia. Years ago, she showed him her work, and he hadn’t dismissed it, instead telling her that she was not yet ready. Now, Charlotte intends to show him her work again—the argument with Margaret opened her eyes, and Charlotte had gotten to work painting in the weeks after their argument.


Fedorov examines Charlotte’s work and claims that although she is more serious and has worked hard, she is not talented enough. He takes her around the galley and shows the work he displays, claiming that, like her, he doesn’t have the talent to create, but he can sense it in others.


At home afterward, Charlotte contemplates how she now better understands Denise’s desire to flee to Oxford. Having recently read Virginia Woolf’s work of the same name, she reflects on the need for “a room of one’s own” (265). At home, Charlotte finds an envelope on her doorstep filled with photographs of Howard and another woman caught in a moment of passion.

Chapter 28 Summary: “A Shell of a Man”

King tells Bitsy that he is leaving her. He reveals that in the days following their big fight, he met and had a brief affair with a server named Sally Ann. Although he ended it, Sally Ann has told him that she is pregnant. He wants to do the “right thing” and packs his belongings to leave right away, telling Bitsy she can stay in the house for now. The Bettys arrive for book club, and when King suggests Bitsy tell them it is canceled that day, she retorts that his days of telling her what to do are over.

Chapters 19-28 Analysis

The narrative tension builds rapidly in these chapters as the women are each presented with challenges unique to their particular situation. The tension between Walt and Margaret finally boils over after Denise’s party, and they argue about his disregard for her work. Viv makes a decision regarding her work, recognizing that at the moment, she wants to spend time at home with her children. Bitsy’s marriage unexpectedly falls apart, and Charlotte’s may be headed in the same direction as she faces a reckoning. Momentum gathers on each of the characters’ arcs, leading to a life-changing decision for each respective woman.


Bostwick explores different aspects of The Pervasive Nature of Patriarchy through the different trajectories each of the women’s stories takes. Bitsy’s situation, and to some extent Margaret’s, highlights the overbearing weight of masculine ego that prevents men from acknowledging a woman’s worth or value. Despite returning home after their explosive fight, King still refuses to acknowledge that Bitsy was right about how to treat Delilah’s laminitis; similarly, Walt continues to dismiss and trivialize Margaret’s work as a columnist, calling the position a “jobette.” However, unlike King, Walt does truly love and respect Margaret—he is eventually able to see the error of his ways and apologizes for his remark. By contrasting Walt’s behavior with King’s, Bostwick underlines how, just as the women are all distinct individuals, so are the men. Tony has constantly exemplified the kind of man that all women deserve as a partner in his unfailing support for Viv; through Walt’s character arc, however, Bostwick highlights that men can also be victims of a patriarchal system, but they are also capable of breaking out of the system and exhibiting real change.


Bostwick extends and further explores this idea by highlighting all the different segments of society that were left out of the conversation surrounding feminism at this point in history. Specifically, she leads Margaret to see that Walt, too, is trapped in his own way, led to believe that he must carry out a specific masculine duty: caring for his family. While Walt’s gender affords him more power and control than Margaret’s, it doesn’t change from the limitations that come with his role: He sacrifices his own happiness and curiosity and works a job he hates to provide for his family. Elsewhere, Viv points out that Friedan’s book left out other sections of society as well: single and working parents, and people of color. These musings are Bostwick’s way of reminding the reader that The Feminine Mystique is not a perfect treatise on feminism or patriarchy but rather a step forward in feminist history that is nonetheless firmly grounded in one particular perspective.


Another perspective Bostwick explores with respect to the patriarchy is how women can sometimes perpetrate their own (and other women’s) oppression. King and Howard are both classic examples of men who take away their wives’ freedom and independence; however, in Charlotte’s case, her mother is an equal perpetrator. Patricia threatens consequences if Charlotte doesn’t submit to their expectations, despite the empathy and concern she ought to feel towards Charlotte as her mother and a woman. For all her fieriness and bravado, Charlotte is as afraid of the consequences of rebellion as the next woman. Margaret calls her out on this, pointing out how Charlotte is afraid to leave her husband or take risks with her work; although Charlotte rejects this assertion, this is a very real fear for her, rooted in her experiences of her own family, including her mother, denying her choice and autonomy to uphold the patriarchal demands made of women.


Bostwick contrasts this unhappy scenario with another possibility, speaking to the theme of Community as Sanctuary for Women: women lifting each other up. She juxtaposes Charlotte’s mother with positive examples like Dr. Alice Brennan, who wants to extend to other women the same opportunities and privileges that she enjoys. Thus, she offers Bitsy a place at UC Davis, insisting that Bitsy keep her card even when the young woman refuses. Bostwick underlines the importance of a community of women supporting each other in work spheres, especially, as she points out throughout the novel, with how their contributions are constantly devalued by men.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 58 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs