The Lost Man

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of gender discrimination, physical abuse, emotional abuse, child abuse, death, death by suicide, and mental illness.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. Harper creates an Australian outback that feels both beautiful and menacing, where a broken car can mean death, and where community rules determine survival. The harsh landscape shapes every aspect of the characters’ lives, from their daily routines to their deepest relationships. Did you find the environmental setting convincing as a driving force behind the family’s dynamics and the central mystery?

2. What similarities did you notice between The Lost Man and Harper’s earlier novel The Dry? Does Harper’s approach to using the Australian landscape as a crucial element in her mysteries feel consistent across her work, or did you find different emphases in how the environment influences the plot?

3. Harper structures her mystery to leave readers uncertain whether Cam was murdered, died by suicide, or died accidentally until the final revelation. How did this ambiguity affect your reading experience and investment in solving the puzzle alongside Nathan?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Nathan’s decade-long exile from Balamara stems from a single moment when he failed to stop and help someone in need. Can you think of times when one poor decision or moment of weakness had lasting consequences in your own life or community?

2. The Bright family maintains a culture of silence around Carl and Cam’s abuse, with each member choosing to look away rather than confront uncomfortable truths. This silence allows the trauma to continue across generations, affecting everyone from Liz to the grandchildren. Have you observed similar patterns in families or communities where difficult topics remain unspoken, and what do you think it takes to break such cycles?

3. Living in complete isolation takes a severe toll on Nathan’s mental health, yet he struggles to reach out for help even when his family expresses concern. What barriers do you think prevent people from seeking support when they’re struggling emotionally?

4. Nathan consciously tries to parent Xander differently than Carl parented him, using his father’s harsh methods as a guide for what not to do. Despite his efforts, he still struggles with distance and communication, showing how difficult it can be to break inherited patterns. Do you think Nathan’s approach of just doing the opposite of his father is effective, or are there better ways to overcome negative family legacies?

5. The unwritten rule that you must stop to help anyone stranded in the outback reflects how harsh environments create strong social bonds and expectations. What unspoken rules or expectations exist in your own community, and how do they reflect the challenges people face together?

6. Confronting long-buried family secrets ultimately brings the Bright family closer together, even though the truth is painful. Do you think families are generally better off knowing difficult truths, or are there times when maintaining some silence might be protective?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Rural communities often develop tight-knit support systems out of necessity, but these same communities can also enforce harsh consequences for those who violate their codes. The Bright family’s story shows how geographic isolation can both protect and imprison people, especially women and children facing abuse. How do you think isolation affects the dynamics of abuse and the ability of victims to seek help in real-world rural or remote communities?

2. The novel explores how cycles of abuse can persist across generations when communities choose not to intervene or acknowledge what’s happening. What role do you think communities should play in addressing domestic violence and protecting vulnerable family members?

3. Isolated environments can amplify gender power imbalances, as seen in how Cam controls Ilse’s access to money, transportation, and communication with the outside world. How do geographic and social isolation intersect to create particular vulnerabilities for women in abusive relationships?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. The stockman’s grave functions as a central landmark that draws multiple characters and stories throughout the novel. How do the different versions of the stockman legend that various characters tell reveal their individual psychological states and relationship to themes of sacrifice, survival, and death?

2. The Australian outback operates almost like a character in the novel, with its own personality, rules, and power over the human characters. Harper uses specific details about survival equipment, radio protocols, and the constant threat of weather to create an environment where nature can kill within hours. Does the setting feel authentic to you, and how does it enhance the themes about human relationships and survival?

3. Cam’s painting dominates the family’s living room, and the strict rule against touching it symbolizes his control over the household even after death. What does Nathan’s decision to take down the painting represent in terms of breaking family patterns and confronting hidden truths?

4. Nathan’s reluctance to use his radio represents his self-imposed isolation and struggle with mental health throughout the novel. How does Harper use this recurring motif to show Nathan’s gradual reconnection with his family and community?

5. The novel employs a third-person limited point of view that keeps readers inside Nathan’s perspective while he investigates his brother’s death and uncovers family secrets. How did this narrow point of view affect your reading experience? How would the novel’s structure and atmosphere have been different if readers could access other characters’ inner thoughts?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. Each character tells a different version of the stockman legend, featuring everything from accidental death to stampede to heroic sacrifice. If you were creating your own version of this local legend, what details would you emphasize, and what would your version reveal about your current state of mind?

2. Liz’s decision to let Cam die represents a desperate mother’s attempt to break a cycle of abuse that has persisted for decades. The novel ends with her confession to Nathan, but he chooses not to report her to the police. If you were writing an alternative ending, would you have Nathan make a different choice about his mother’s confession? How might that change the family’s future trajectory?

3. If you were creating a survival manual specifically for the Bright family’s situation, combining both practical outback safety and strategies for healing from intergenerational trauma, what would be your top five essential guidelines?

Need more conversation starters? Inspire your group with our Discussion Questions tool.