Bob is walking to the barbershop when his lawyer Brad calls about Stacy’s case. Bob informs him of his suspicion that Sarah hired Stacy to sleep with him. He insists that Brad doesn’t really know Sarah. He ends the call when he arrives at Cuts by Carissa. During the haircut and shave, Bob notices that Carissa seems jumpy. Then she knicks his neck with the blade. She suggests giving him the haircut on the house.

While she’s at work, Sarah calls her lawyer Jess. She wants to go after Bob in the divorce before he can go after her. Afterward, she texts Alejandro about meeting up. Then two police officers stop by to question her.

Marcus and Pam tell Sarah about Ryan’s murder and question her. Sarah barely reacts, unsurprised that someone wanted him dead. They also ask her about her whereabouts on the night of Kelly’s murder and about her and Bob’s divorce. Marcus gets a call on his police radio that interrupts the interrogation. He is wanted at a salon downtown. After he and Pam leave, they discuss Sarah’s interview, curious as to why she seemed unaffected by Ryan’s death.

Bob meets with his boss Kent, who confronts him for letting his personal life distract him from his work. The conversation makes Bob realize that Kent told Sarah about Stacy. Kent doesn’t deny it, insisting that he was protecting Sarah (who was formerly a partner there with them) by informing her of Bob’s infidelity. He suspends Bob and tells him to use the time off to pull himself back together.

Marcus and Pam report to Cuts by Carissa. The salon is covered in blood and hair, but Carissa’s body isn’t there. They plan to file a missing person’s report, as they’ve determined that the blood is Carissa’s. They think her case might be related to Stacy’s and Stevens’s cases.

Sarah and Bob have dinner with Summer and tell her about the divorce. Sarah tries to explain that they can’t be together anymore but still love her. Upset, Summer storms out. Sarah accuses Bob of creating the mess by cheating on her. Bob threatens to hurt Sarah if she doesn’t free Stacy. Watching Bob eat, Sarah wishes she’d killed him.

The unknown woman wakes up in the dark to the sound of whimpering and crying. She realizes another woman is in the basement with her. The two victims introduce themselves as Stacy and Carissa.

Bob returns to the sheriff’s office for questioning in the Carissa case. He tells them about his haircut but swears nothing strange happened. When he learns that she’s gone missing, he admits that Carissa seemed anxious and cut his neck by accident. The police speculate about Carissa’s whereabouts. Her abusive ex-boyfriend George had just gotten out of prison, and they wonder if he was after her.

Then they pivot the interrogation back to Stacy. They show Bob a text exchange between himself and Stacy in which Stacy tried to extort Bob. They ask if he hurt Stacy to get revenge and if he did the same to Carissa when she nicked him. Bob denies the claims and leaves to talk to Brad.

Bob tells Brad he thinks Sarah is framing him. He reveals the truth about Kelly’s murder: Sarah killed her. He and Sarah planned the murder because she was angry that Adam cheated on her, and he was angry that Kelly killed Greg. He then says he has evidence that can prove the crime.

Marcus and Pam study Stacy’s and Carissa’s missing photos and try to make sense of their fates. They speculate about Carissa’s ex-boyfriend and Stacy’s extortion history. Finally, they bring George in for questioning; He admits that he and Carissa were in contact but insists he didn’t hurt her. He won’t say anything else without a lawyer.

Sarah presses through the reporters on her way into work. Inside, she talks to Anne about the Kelly Summers case and Stevens’s murder. Anne is sympathetic to Sarah’s situation, and Sarah plays along.

Marcus returns and starts questioning Sarah about Carissa and George; he says that the foundation “helped Carissa get a protective order” against George (201). Sarah feigns shock and demands that the police find George immediately. After Marcus leaves, Sarah and Alejandro make plans to have dinner at Sarah’s.

Bob brings Brad the knife that Sarah used to kill Kelly. He explains that Sarah gave it to him to dispose of, but he’s held onto it all these years just in case he ever needed something on Sarah. Brad promises to handle the evidence appropriately and warns Bob not to go near Sarah or Summer until the case is resolved.

Afterward, Bob unearths a burner phone from his car and texts Alejandro about meeting up at a hotel the next morning. He turns off the phone, relieved that he’ll finally be able to end Sarah.