42 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
When Anna turns nine, Tom sends her to school in Cossethay. She finds it difficult to make friends, and her only strong bonds are with her parents and her brothers, Tom and Fred. A Polish man named Baron Skrebensky moves to Yorkshire. The baron and his wife impress Anna, and she feels he represents the “real world.” As Anna continues growing up, she attends a young ladies’ school in Nottingham. Although she is smart, she has little interest in school, and she still struggles to make friends. Anna feels disappointed that the world outside Marsh Farm does not make her feel the same freedom she feels at home. At the age of 16, Anna finds her relationship with her parents becoming strained. Lydia dislikes Anna’s “gawkiness” but is otherwise indifferent to her. Anna teases Tom about his drinking, but their camaraderie remains strong. Anna comes to prefer her own sense of spirituality over the dogma of most organized religions. When she is 17, Anna dreams of getting away from home.
When Anna turns 18, Tom’s brother Alfred writes that his son William is moving to a town near Marsh Farm to work in the lace factory. William joins Anna for church the first Sunday after he arrives. They continue spending time together, avoiding Tom and Lydia’s suspicious gaze. Will makes a wood-carved butter stamper for Anna, and she uses it to stamp its phoenix on the butter produced by the farm. One night, Will kisses Anna. They see one another in secret, but Tom catches on. He follows them to the barn one night and sees Anna telling Will she loves him.
Will helps Anna harvest corn one night. At one point, he swiftly embraces her, kissing her passionately, and he proposes. When they tell Tom and Lydia their plan to marry, they reject Will for being too poor and too young. Tom and Anna argue about her engagement; she angrily cries, “You are not my father—my father is dead—you are not my father” (118). Tom eventually agrees to Will and Anna’s engagement. He gives Will shares in Marsh Farm worth 2,500 pounds. Will gives them to Anna, and she reconciles with Tom. As the wedding approaches, Tom wonders what his life will be like without Anna and whether he ever truly accomplished anything meaningful. Tom gives Will and Anna the lease to Yew Cottage in Cossethay and buys them many gifts for their new home.
Anna and Will are wed shortly before Christmas. Tom is drunk by the time the ceremony begins; he wonders what old age will be like and when he might die. The wedding party goes to Yew Cottage for a drink, and Tom gives a speech. His brothers Frank and Alfred interrupt him several times to agree with his rambling well-wishes. The party then goes to the family home at the farm, and Tom gives a long, sentimental speech about men, women, marriage, and heaven. The party sings rowdy songs and offers Will innuendo-laden advice for his wedding night with Anna: “Fair and softly does it […] You’re not a bull at a gate” (131).
Will and Anna leave for Yew Cottage. Not long after their departure, Tom and a small group of men decide to walk over to the cottage and sing a carol outside to entertain the couple. The sudden noise startles Anna, but Will calms her. Anna listens to her father singing. Will kisses her and pulls her closer.
Will initially worries about using so much of his holiday leave for the honeymoon, but he overcomes his feeling of guilt for being idle and enjoys the time alone with Anna. When Anna plans a tea party, Will becomes upset—he wishes things could stay as they are, just him and Anna with no responsibilities. Anna sees the disdain in his expression, and it frightens her. He falls into a period of “darkness,” and they become distant from each other. One night, Will finds Anna sobbing in their bed, and he feels his mood softening. He holds her while she cries, and he does his best to comfort her.
Will and Anna’s differing attitudes toward religion become a problem in their marriage. Although Anna likes going to church, she privately thinks this feeling is rooted more in habit than in genuine religious feeling. Will feels devoted to their church, which angers Anna: “In this Church spirit […] he seemed to escape and run free of her,” and she “wanted to destroy it in him” (148). Will is especially fascinated by a stained-glass window depicting a lamb, and after they go home, Anna begins to ridicule the image as “absurd.” Her questioning of Will’s faith turns to cruel mockery, and Will feels ashamed. Their interactions afterward are charged with mutual disdain and anger.
One evening, Anna fails to have tea ready when Will returns home, and he storms out. Will takes a train to Nottingham, where he buys a book about Bamberg Cathedral. At home, Anna is anxious that he left her, and she cries. As time passes, their marriage goes through recurring phases of love and conflict, and Anna realizes they are “opposites, not complements” (157). Anna mocks Will’s assertion that he is master of their house and of her. Will burns a wood carving of Adam and Eve that he had been working on since before they wed. Anna realizes she is pregnant, and she is scared to tell Will. She feels her fear made “such a waste of a beautiful opportunity […] one of the beautiful moments of her life” (162). Anna visits her parents at Marsh Farm and tells them how miserable she is in her marriage. Will stops by the farm at the same time, and Anna tells him of her pregnancy. She cannot tell if he is happy. As the pregnancy progresses, Anna takes to dancing naked while Will is not home. One afternoon, he catches her doing so, and his questions make Anna feel ashamed. Will considers leaving Anna because they hate each other, but he also still loves her too much to leave. Anna gives birth to a girl, whom they name Ursula. Will and Anna’s volatile relationship levels out to a kind of acceptance, and Anna soon becomes pregnant again.
At the start of this section, the narration no longer refers to Anna by Lensky, her late father’s surname, and begins calling her a Brangwen, signifying her full integration into the family unit. The change becomes ironic when Anna rejects Tom as her father when she lashes out at him for refusing to let her marry Will. Although she tries to assert herself as an independent being in an effort to move away and seek freedom, her marriage takes her directly back into the family, since he is a Brangwen. Anna is impressed with Will’s craftsmanship and proudly uses the phoenix butter stamp he carved to mark all the butter shipped out by the farm. The phoenix depicted in the stamp is a visual representation of the novel’s interest in rebirth and regeneration: The phoenix dies and is reborn from its own ashes, much like the Brangwen women aspire to leave one life behind in favor of another.
These chapters explore the novel’s existential concerns. Tom has multiple identity crises, such as when Anna says he is not her father and later, at her wedding, when he contemplates what old age will be like and whether his life will ever amount to anything worthwhile. For Tom, the sense of belonging he always craved seems to have evaded him for his entire life. These chapters also introduce the novel’s religious aspects. Will’s interest in cathedrals and his hobby of crafting wood carvings depicting biblical scenes, such as Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden, contrasts with Anna’s underwhelmed feelings about religion in general. Marsh Farm itself is a kind of natural Eden, although it is already corrupted by industrialization and commercialized labor. Will’s wood carving of Adam and Eve is a work he is incredibly proud of, especially as he thinks of himself and Anna on their honeymoon as a version of Adam and Eve. He views their isolation from the rest of the world as a paradise, one in which they have no responsibilities and are almost always naked.
However, the novel quickly dismantles the notion that such an Eden can endure in reality. Indeed, the couple’s first encounter with the outside world following their wedding creates conflict in their marriage: When Anna plans her tea party, Will rebels against the imminent closure of the Edenic honeymoon period. Anna almost instantly begins to resent him as she prepares for her event, urging him to go find a way to make himself busy. Their marriage quickly sours, and they argue about everything. They pick apart each other’s passions to the point of cruelty, and the novel uses violent imagery to convey how much one’s mockery hurts the other. Anna “strikes” at Will so that he bleeds, and he is determined to “beat” her. Although it is unclear if the language is metaphoric or meant to convey instances of domestic violence, it is clear that they hurt one another intentionally.
The scene of Anna dancing naked while pregnant with their first child is startlingly visceral in its descriptions of her body, particularly the images of her “lifted” belly. Anna dances in defiance of Will and the “Creator.” Thus, she dances in defiance not only of God but also of Will as a participant in the creation of their child. His anger at seeing her naked, pregnant form signals to the reader that after the honeymoon ended and they were no longer perpetually naked together, her nude body was not meant to be seen again apart from the context of sexual intimacy. To see her dancing, naked, in a moment for herself and herself alone, angers Will because of its flagrant defiance and dismissal of unspoken rules about how she should conceal her body and how she ought to behave while pregnant. The couple’s martial conflicts reflect the theme Gender Roles in Domestic Life.



Unlock all 42 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.