These Hollow Vows (2021) is the first installment in a young adult faerie romantasy series by American author Lexi Ryan. Ryan was previously known for writing contemporary romances for adults (in various subgenres); These Hollow Vows is her first novel for young adults. It was nominated as a Readers’ Favorite Young Adult Fantasy and Science Fiction novel in Goodreads’ 2021 Reader’s Choice Awards and has been compared to other young adult fantasy romances like Tricia Levenseller’s The Shadows Between Us.
Ryan subsequently published two other installments in the series. These Twisted Bonds (2022) continues Brie’s narrative as she manages her life in Faerie in the aftermath of being betrayed by Sebastian and Finn. Ryan has a second duology set in the same universe as the first two installments, which are loosely connected to the narrative from the first two books but not directly informed by one another. Beneath These Cursed Stars (2024) follows Brie’s younger sister, Jas, as she seeks to battle a reincarnated Mordeus. The second book in this duology, Between These Broken Hearts, is scheduled for a 2025 release.
These Hollow Vows was well received by readers, who praised the novel for its fast-paced plot, exciting twists and turns, and engaging love triangle. The novel was further praised for its world building and engaging fantasy setting. Some critics commented, however, that they found the love triangle unsatisfying because both of Brie’s potential love interests consistently lie to and manipulate her.
These Hollow Vows draws upon faerie folklore, or legends about mythical creatures, that originate from various European cultures, including Slavic, Germanic, Celtic, and French. These narratives are often anthropomorphic and use different species within the overarching realm of “faerie” as symbolizing different qualities. Different faerie lore presents fae creatures as alternately benevolent or malevolent, though even good-hearted faeries are commonly associated with a love of mischief. Puck from William Shakespeare’s A Midsummer Night’s Dream is sometimes presented as an iconic mischievous faerie figure. Different faerie folklore traditions include figures such as witches, sorcerers, goblins, gnomes, or sprites.
These Hollow Vows pulls particularly from Irish faerie folklore. For example, Brie and Sebastian celebrate the summer solstice; Celtic or pagan feasts including the solstice are considered, in this tradition, times when the fae are more powerful or able to play tricks on humans. The Banshee figure, who presages first Jalek’s death and later Brie’s in the novel, comes from this tradition as a harbinger of death.
Celtic folklore traditions, though passed down for centuries, came into frequent conflict with Christian traditions in Ireland and Scotland. Some fae symbols became taboo anti-Christian imagery, while others were reconsidered and their histories reevaluated (Rainbolt, Dawn. “Irish Folklore, Myth & Legend: The Fairies.” Wilderness Ireland, 20 Jan. 2022). Saint Brigid, the patron saint of Ireland, for example, has been varyingly framed as a faerie, a Catholic saint, and a goddess in her own right. This led her to be removed from the Catholic saint canon in 1969 when Pope Paul VI cited lack of evidence that Saint Brigid of Kildare ever existed (“Brigid, Ireland’s Antiestablishment Saint.” New Lines Magazine, 31 Jan. 2025).



Unlock all 58 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.