59 pages • 1-hour read
Ron ChernowA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Chapter 55 traces Washington’s attempt to remain above faction as Jefferson and Madison organized opposition to Hamilton’s expanding federal program. Jefferson installed Philip Freneau and the National Gazette to attack administration policies; financial frenzies (“scrippomania,” “bancomania”) and the Duer crash fueled partisan suspicion. Washington contemplated retirement and had Madison draft a farewell, then labored to mediate the Hamilton–Jefferson feud through pointed private letters. Despite growing Virginia criticism and Jefferson’s charges, counsel (notably from Eliza Powel) helped persuade Washington to serve a second term to stabilize the young government.
Washington, unanimously reelected, began a contentious second term marked by partisan newspapers and the European war’s shockwaves. He asserted executive authority with the April 1793 neutrality proclamation, aiming to keep the US out of Britain–France hostilities. The new French minister, Citizen Genet, inflamed opinion by arming privateers, recruiting Americans, and threatening an appeal over Washington’s head; Washington demanded his recall but later granted him asylum. Lafayette fell into Austrian captivity; Jefferson wavered on resignation but stayed briefly. The crisis spawned Democratic Republican Societies and intensified attacks on Washington, even as he maintained neutrality and a pared-down public style.
Washington’s second term was jolted by Philadelphia’s 1793 yellow fever epidemic, which emptied the capital, killed thousands, and briefly muted partisan agitation. After evacuating to Germantown and ensuring constitutional continuity, Washington returned to deliver his annual address, defend neutrality, and urge preparedness. He presided over cornerstone ceremonies for the Capitol and advanced designs for the President’s House while using enslaved labor for its construction. Simultaneously, Mount Vernon reeled from mismanagement and deaths; Washington issued blistering directives to overseers and devised a rental scheme that, he told Tobias Lear, would enable him to free enslaved people and rehire them as paid labor.
Washington’s second term opened with Jefferson’s resignation and a reshaped cabinet (Randolph at State, Bradford as Attorney General), while Congress authorized six frigates, launching the US Navy. Abroad, the Terror raged in France; Britain seized American ships, prompting Washington to send Chief Justice Jay to negotiate. At home, Anthony Wayne’s victory at Fallen Timbers broke Indigenous resistance in the Northwest. The chief crisis became the Whiskey Rebellion: Washington issued a proclamation, called up militia from multiple states, and—accompanied by Hamilton—personally advanced west to enforce the excise law and affirm federal authority.
Washington rode west to Carlisle and Bedford to oversee the federal response to the Whiskey Rebellion, conferred with emissaries William Findley and David Redick, enforced discipline, and then returned to Philadelphia while Hamilton directed operations. He defended the crackdown in his 6th Annual Address and condemned “self-created societies.” The show of force quelled resistance; Washington later pardoned two condemned rebels.
The episode widened the partisan rift with Madison and Jefferson, while cabinet shifts followed: Hamilton resigned (succeeded by Oliver Wolcott Jr.), Knox resigned (replaced by Timothy Pickering). Washington longed for retirement.
Washington received John Jay’s treaty, found it flawed but peace-preserving, and sent it to the Senate under strict secrecy; with Article XII dropped, the Senate narrowly approved it. A leak triggered nationwide fury; Hamilton’s “Camillus” essays defended the pact as Washington decided to sign. Amid the uproar, a captured French dispatch (Fauchet) implicated Secretary of State Edmund Randolph, leading to his resignation and a bruising pamphlet war. Washington reshuffled the cabinet (Pickering to State; McHenry to War; Charles Lee as Attorney General) and appointed Oliver Ellsworth chief justice. He discreetly sheltered George Washington Lafayette while pressing for Lafayette’s release.
Washington secured Pinckney’s Treaty with Spain, opening the Mississippi and New Orleans and fixing the western boundary. At home, he resisted the House’s demand for Jay Treaty papers, asserting constitutional limits and executive confidentiality; after a bruising debate, appropriations for the treaty passed narrowly. The fight ruptured relations with Madison and further estranged Jefferson; Washington recalled Monroe from France, while Paine attacked him in print. Amid the rancor, he sat for portraits, managed family matters, and grappled with finances, refining plans that anticipated manumitting those he enslaved and reorganizing Mount Vernon.
In 1796 Washington resolved to retire, asking Hamilton to draft (and refine) his “Farewell Address,” which was published on September 19. The message stressed national unity, warned against faction, urged fiscal responsibility, and advocated interest-based neutrality rather than partisan attachment abroad. Republicans bristled at its veiled rebukes, while many Americans praised it; authorship remained secret. Washington’s departure effectively established the two‑term precedent. Absent from the address was enslavement: Simultaneously, the Washingtons pursued the recapture of the fugitives Ona Judge and Hercules, revealing the contradiction between public ideals and private bondage.
In his final months, Washington delivered a last annual message (December 1796), celebrated a round of farewell festivities, and presided over the first contested presidential election: John Adams won (71 electoral votes) and Thomas Jefferson became vice president (68). The press—especially the Aurora—assailed Washington even as public ceremonies honored him. On March 4, 1797, an emotional inauguration marked his orderly transfer of power. He returned to Mount Vernon amid reflections on his presidential legacy: strengthening the executive, securing peace and credit, expanding the Union—while leaving unresolved enslavement and conflicts with Indigenous peoples.
As Washington entered his second term, his posture shifted from reluctant executive to increasingly embattled figurehead caught between public expectation and private weariness. Chernow presents a man determined to maintain national stability but buffeted by unprecedented domestic and foreign pressures. The author traces Washington’s changing rhetorical stance as a marker of that strain—his language grows sharper, more defensive, and more symbolic as opposition hardens. From his condemnation of “certain self-created societies” (750) to his reference to Jay Treaty protestors as a “mad dog” mob (756), Washington’s tone departs from earlier reserved statesmanship. Chernow uses these phrases to reveal how Washington’s control of symbolic language was a tool of governance, allowing him to project authority even as his control waned.
The Whiskey Rebellion and Jay Treaty uproar foreground how Washington deployed strength while also using Strategic Restraint as a Form of Power. By taking the field during the rebellion, Washington became the only sitting president to lead troops in battle—a move Chernow frames through Hamilton’s metaphor of “Hercules.” That classical image casts executive authority as mythical in proportion and moral in its purpose: Strength not for domination but deterrence. This tension between power and restraint deepens the portrait of Washington’s governance. Rather than react punitively to the rebellion’s leaders, Washington issued pardons. Throughout this section, Chernow’s narration underscores how Washington balanced visibility with measured action, using his stature to protect the fledgling republic from dissolution.
Chernow also illustrates how The Construction and Control of Public Image during Washington’s presidency became increasingly fraught. The “Farewell Address,” crafted in concert with Hamilton, functions as personal defense. Washington’s warning that “habitual hatred or…fondness” (780) toward foreign nations could enslave public will is both political advice and self-justification. In casting emotion as antithetical to liberty, he deflects partisan accusations that he favored Britain. The address, like the earlier neutrality proclamation and his refusal to hand over Jay Treaty documents, reveals how Washington used public communication to define the moral and constitutional limits of the presidency itself. Chernow shows how the Farewell becomes the final movement in a years-long campaign to preserve both personal legacy and institutional coherence.
Amid these maneuvers, Washington’s evolving stance on Enslavement and Moral Evolution in the Early Republic remains a subdued but significant undercurrent. His letter to Tobias Lear expressing a desire to lease Mount Vernon farms in a way that could lead to manumission—though justified in terms of financial necessity—reveals a quiet shift. Chernow emphasizes that Washington’s decisions here are incremental and pragmatic rather than demonstrating an ideological commitment to Enlightenment values. The juxtaposition of this private reckoning with the public spectacle of the “Farewell” subtly underscores the enduring gap between national ideals and foundational contradictions.



Unlock all 59 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.