105 pages 3-hour read

Wind and Truth

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2024

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 4Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 4: “Day Four”

Part 4, Chapter 43 Summary: “The Origin of Songs”

There are six days remaining until the contest of champions.


With their anchors to the Physical Realm severed, Navani and Dalinar are adrift in the Spiritual Realm. Dalinar experiences an overwhelming onslaught of visions from his past. He takes from his pocket the rock that Wit provided as a touchpoint to get them to the vision of humanity’s arrival on Roshar.


In each of the visions that Dalinar and Navani experience, they occupy the bodies of individuals who were present when the event originally took place. In this vision, Dalinar is in the body of a Parshendi man. Navani appears as well. She tells Dalinar that she feels a “tugging” (422), as if someone else is in the Spiritual Realm with them. Soon, they will discover that Gavinor has accidentally been pulled into the Spiritual Realm along with them.

Part 4, Chapter 44 Summary: “A Semblance of Reality”

Shallan was pulled into the Spiritual Realm when the Ghostbloods attacked Dalinar’s portal. Now, she finds Renarin and Rlain waiting for her. They are all inhabiting a vision of Renarin’s childhood bedroom. In order to locate Ba-Ado Mishram’s prison before Mraize can, they decide to find Dalinar and Navani, whom the Ghostbloods will likely be following.

Part 4, Chapter 45 Summary: “Self-Mastery and Control”

Kaladin and Szeth continue to discuss self-forgiveness and the importance of personal autonomy. They arrive at the next monastery. This one is surrounded by a large settlement and protected by fortifications. Inside the monastery, they find the corpse of Sivi, the Willshaper Honorbearer. She appears to have resisted the corrupting force that is at play elsewhere.

Part 4, Chapter 46 Summary: “Alaswha”

In the Spiritual Realm, Navani and Dalinar witness a portal opening from humanity’s home planet, Ashyn. Ishar the Herald—currently still a mortal man—controls the portal. He holds it open with great effort as refugees pour through. The sky is on fire in the world behind them. Humans destroyed that world by using their unfettered access to power Surges. As Dalinar and Navani watch, the other Heralds (and Wit) appear with the crowds of people.

Part 4, Chapter 47 Summary: “Failure Points”

Adolin and the Azish Shardbearer, Neziham, hold off the 11th wave of attacks. From time to time, Adolin pulls back from the battle to take a rest. While he is resting, one of a few specially trained soldiers wears his Shardplate.


Sigzil arrives on the Shattered Plains, where he commands the forces defending Narak. His forces are badly outnumbered. He develops a clever plan to draw attacks in strategic places by making his defenses look especially weak in specific areas.

Part 4, Chapter 48 Summary: “A Talent”

This chapter continues the flashback to Szeth’s past.


Szeth’s parents are heartbroken to discover that Szeth has killed a man. They recognize that this act was done in self-defense, but Shinovar culture holds that only certain kinds of people are capable of violence. Now that Szeth has revealed himself to be such a person, he must travel to one of the monasteries to train as a soldier. His father vows that the whole family will go with him in a show of support and solidarity. This decision eventually tears their family apart, as Szeth’s mother and sister begrudge the hardships that befall them.

Part 4, Chapter 49 Summary: “A Realm of Possibilities”

Shallan, Rlain, and Renarin arrive in the vision where Dalinar and Navani are, just in time to witness the arrival of humans on Roshar. Shallan finds Mraize hiding in the body of a human refugee and swings her knife at him, but Mraize deflects her blow.


One of Shallan’s alter-egos, Formless, appears. Shallan thought that she had fully done away with Formless, who is the embodiment of Shallan’s avoidance of her darkest memories. (Later in the novel, it will be revealed that Iyatil, Mraize’s companion, is masquerading as Formless.)


The Stormfather does not want Dalinar to see these visions of the past because he does not want Dalinar to discover the truth of Honor’s past betrayals and oath-breaking. The Stormfather yells at Dalinar and refuses to help him return to the Physical Realm

Part 4, Chapter 50 Summary: “The Price of Peace”

While Dalinar speaks with the Stormfather, Navani continues to sense that someone watching: someone with whom she has a connection. She is likely feeling either Renarin (her nephew and stepson) or Gavinor (her grandson), both of whom are in the Spiritual Realm with her.


Navani realizes that she and Dalinar will need objects that will anchor them to each vision that they want to visit. Just as their current vision is dissolving, she snags a hair ribbon from a person in the vision: young Shalash, who will be present at the founding of the Oathpact and will become a Herald.


In Azimir, Adolin receives news that the reinforcement army marching toward them has been delayed, harried by unseen forces. (These unknown forces will later be revealed to be portions of the coalition army that have changed sides after their governments agreed to work with Odium.)


Adolin visits with injured soldiers in the field hospital. There, he finds the Heralds Shalash and Taln. Taln is barely conscious and mutters to himself incoherently.

Part 4, Chapter 51 Summary: “Test”

This chapter continues the flashback to Szeth’s past.


Szeth and his family arrive at the soldier camp. Szeth’s mother gives him a toy sheep that she made from a scrap of Molli’s wool. He keeps it despite orders to destroy all belongings from his former life.


Szeth hears the voice in his head again. Under its direction, he impresses his superiors and becomes a candidate for officer training. The voice lies to Szeth, claiming to be the spren of the stone that he used to kill the soldier. (In reality, the voice is Ishar, but this fact will not be revealed until Part 10.)

Part 4, Chapter 52 Summary: “A Perfect Moment”

Adolin lets Yanagawn try on his Shardplate. The magical armor gives the wearer superhuman strength and speed, so using it effectively requires training.

Part 4, Chapter 53 Summary: “Makari Sin”

While Szeth and Kaladin are between monasteries, Szeth is caught unawares and pulled into Shadesmar by two Honorbearers. One is Pozen, the Elsecaller Honorbearer who was also one of Szeth’s closest mentors. The other is the Edgedancer Honorbearer.


Szeth fights first the Edgedancer and then Pozen in the next duels of his pilgrimage. They have violated the rules of the traditional duels by pulling him into Shadesmar, where he is at a distinct disadvantage. Even so, Szeth manages to conquer them both by wielding Nightblood. In Shadesmar, Szeth sees his spren’s true form; he is surprised and disappointed to see that his spren is afraid, confused, and rather helpless. After this, Szeth feels more confidence around his spren and is less willing to follow the spren’s orders blindly.

Part 4, Chapter 54 Summary: “A Friend”

Rlain and Renarin’s spren take their group into another vision, where they see glimpses of Ba-Ado-Mishram’s angry face appearing in the rocks and clouds.


Shallan grapples with the pain of seeing Formless again; she thought that she had done away with that harmful alter-ego.


Adolin is exhausted after another bout of attacks by Odium’s forces.

Part 4, Interlude 7 Summary: “Moash”

Moash, one of the original members of Kaladin’s bridge crew who has since switched sides, wrestles with pain and guilt before Odium comes to him. Odium shows Moash an alluring vision of a possible future, enlisting Moash’s allegiance. Odium then embeds crystals in Moash’s eyes, granting him magical sight.

Part 4, Interlude 8 Summary: “The Only Way”

Taravangian shifts to allow his emotions to rule. He visits the city of Kharbranth. He resolves that absolute control—achieved through conquering the planet—is the only way to completely protect his family and the city he loves.

Part 4 Analysis

In Part 4, Dalinar and Navani witness the first in a series of visions that they will experience in the days leading up to the contest of champions. Their motivation for seeking out these visions is to understand the long-buried truth about humanity’s arrival on Roshar, the creation of the Heralds, and Honor’s demise. These visions function as literary devices, just as the flashbacks to Szeth’s past do, providing vital information about a time that precedes the main events of the narrative. However, the visions that Dalinar, Navani, and the others experience are not technically flashbacks because the characters are seeing these visions for the first time themselves. By contrast, the more traditional flashbacks of Szeth’s past reveal events that Szeth has already experienced himself. Sanderson’s use of both visions and flashbacks emphasizes the novel’s focus on how the past influences the present. Both devices therefore support the thematic exploration of The Lasting Effects of Trauma on both a personal and a collective scale. In the case of Dalinar’s visions, it is clear that humanity’s arrival on Roshar as refugees has resulted in the centuries-long war with the Parshendi.


Within this broader context, Sanderson continues to develop Shallan’s character arc, and Chapter 49 foreshadows her eventual victory in her battle with Mraize and Iyatil. With Iyatil’s choice to masquerade as Formless, the unhealthy alter-ego that Shallan believed she had banished, Sanderson provides a glimpse into the darker aspects of Shallan’s interiority and alludes to the difficult personal battles that she has already fought in her quest for personal growth. In this chapter, Formless appears, urging Shallan to kill Mraize and claiming, “You cannot reject me forever. I am you” (469).


Shallan’s belief that she has already banished Formless indicates the healing that she has already achieved over the trajectory of the series. Formless—an alter-ego that embodies Shallan’s most unpleasant memories and the harshest possible outcomes from her traumatic experiences—is essentially a personification of Shallan’s internal struggles, just as all her alter-egos are. The seeming appearance of Formless at this juncture in the novel indicates that Shallan has not yet succeeded in fully embracing Self-Acceptance and Forgiveness as Cornerstones of Mental Health. The scene also foreshadows Shallan’s climactic fight with Iyatil and Mraize in Part 10. In reality, Shallan has indeed banished Formless from existence, and she will realize that in this particular instance, what she believes to be Formless is really Iyatil in disguise. When Shallan eventually conquers this false manifestation of her darkest memories, she will achieve a symbolic victory that mirrors her internal journey.


Throughout the flashbacks of Szeth’s early life, Molli the sheep functions as a symbol of Szeth’s youthful innocence. His affection for Molli reflects his deep-seated yearning for a world unburdened by moral ambiguity. The connection of the sheep to this yearning is implicitly demonstrated in Szeth’s attachment to the small toy sheep that his mother makes from Molli’s wool. Even though he is charged with relinquishing all personal effects, his determination to keep this childhood treasure solidifies Molli’s role as a symbol of Szeth’s lost innocence and of his longing for the perceived simplicity and straightforward morality of his youth. The stuffed toy of Molli comforts Szeth, allowing him to hold onto his childhood even as the outside world demands that he leave that simple existence behind and learn to become a soldier. Eventually, Szeth will be forced to leave the toy and its symbolic meaning behind. However, Kaladin will later retrieve the toy in a further symbolic act that illustrates Kaladin’s belief in Szeth’s ability to recover his lost self.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 105 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs