56 pages • 1-hour read
Alex AsterA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
In these novellas, heat symbolizes passion and positive emotions while cold represents numbness and negativity. Grim describes the frigid winter palace, such as the “frost-glazed window” of the young Grim’s room, to show how Grim feels trapped in a hopeless situation. Similarly, Oro uses temperature to express the unrelenting bleakness that Oro feels in the centuries after the curses are cast: “My world has become one of night and darkness and cold” (386).
Much of the novellas’ heat imagery centers around Isla, who rekindles both of her love interests’ feelings after ages of emotional blunting. For example, Grim observes, “I’ve always felt cold, as if my emotions and heart had been frozen solid, but around her, I feel alive. I feel everything” (222). Similarly, Oro frequently imagines Isla on his favorite beach, which becomes, in his dreams, a place of sexual passion and physical warmth. Through the duality of heat and cold, Aster offers insight into Grim and Oro’s emotions and develops their romances with Isla.
In Oro, the saying, “Find your fire” signifies autonomy (345). When Oro is a young child, his mother says this to encourage him to look within for peace and strength: “Find your fire. It doesn’t just apply to flames. It means finding the light in the darkness. Finding the calm in the chaos” (345). Centuries after his mother’s death, Isla’s entrance into Oro’s life reminds Oro of his mother’s advice.
The saying’s meaning shifts over the course of the story, such as when Oro links fire to his selfless devotion to Isla, his friends and family, and all the people who depend upon him for their survival: “For them—for them I will find my fire. Every time. Until I am all but extinguished” (472). During the novella’s resolution, he reflects that he’s fulfilled his mother’s wishes for him and found his fire because, with Isla, he’s “burning with every single want and dream [he] long believed could never belong to [him]” (545). Oro’s mother lends a personal nuance to the story’s duality between heat and cold and underscores Isla’s importance as a source of hope for Oro.
Many fantasy narratives, such as Grim and Oro, endow blades with unique properties or make them the center of a quest. Grim and Isla’s search for the sword provides much of Grim’s structure, and gives Aster opportunities for the characters to bond.
The blade emphasizes The Clash Between Duty and Desire. The weapon belonged to Cronan, who founded Nightshade and instituted many of the traditions that cause Grim pain and trauma, including the Gauntlet. Grim shoulders responsibilities as Nightshade’s ruler, even though he longs to break free from expectations and traditions.
Cronan’s sword also pits the two things that Grim is devoted to against each other—his commitment to his realm and his budding love for Isla. Grim believes that wielding Cronan’s sword is the only way to subdue the monsters attacking his people, but he knows that, if Isla recovers the blade for him, it “would kill her, most likely” (89). Over the course of the story, he becomes increasingly reluctant to find the sword, a shift that indicates his deepening desire for her. During the novella’s climax, Isla uses Cronan’s sword to save Grim and the other Nightshades. This helps to resolve The Clash Between Duty and Desire; it gives Grim a solution to his problem that doesn’t require him to give up his feelings for Isla or abandon his obligations to his people.
Cronan’s sword provides structure for Grim’s novella, brings him and Isla together, and illuminates Grim’s inner conflict as he wrestles with the tension between obligation and want.
Isla’s starstick, an object imbued with Grim’s portaling flair, illustrates The Clash Between Duty and Desire. Grim originally created the starstick for Isla’s father, who served as his general before suddenly disappearing. For centuries, Grim believes that the general gave his life in service to his realm: “The only way he would turn his back on his duty was death” (75). However, Grim eventually learns that the man abandoned his people and his mission to find Cronan’s sword, and used the starstick to elope with the woman he loved. This links the starstick to the ways that duty and desire clash in the novella.
The device also illustrates the tension between Grim’s longing for Isla and duty to his realm. He lets Isla, an outsider, keep the starstick, even though it lets her enter Nightshade undetected and potentially poses a risk to his domain. He grants her request because her loneliness and longing for freedom resonate with him: “Could it be her only escape from this room like a cage, not so different from my own? Could this ability be her only chance at life, just like it was for me?” (68).
Grim’s decision to let Isla keep the object shows that, even relatively early in their relationship, he desires her happiness, not just her physicality. Although Grim eventually confiscates Isla’s starstick, he does so to keep her from following him into a deadly battle. His priorities gradually shift from only caring about saving Nightshade to wanting to protect Isla as well.
During Grim’s climax, the love between Grim and Isla allows Isla to access Grim’s flair and come to his aid without the starstick. This illustrates how desire can evolve into a powerful, mutually transformative bond.



Unlock the meaning behind every key symbol & motif
See how recurring imagery, objects, and ideas shape the narrative.