Shelby Tebow sneaks out of her house late at night, pretending to go for a run while heading to a secret meeting.

A girl held in a dark basement stabs her captor Eddie with a sharpened spoon and escapes outside.

A woman on a walk encounters the escaped girl and is shocked when she identifies herself as Delilah Dickey.

Josh Dickey appears at neighbor Kate's door during a storm, frantic that his wife Meredith and daughter Delilah have vanished.

Meredith receives a series of hostile anonymous text messages from an unknown number.

Josh takes his son Leo to the police station, where Detective Rowlings introduces them to the girl believed to be Delilah.

Neighbors gather in Josh's yard and organize a search party to look for Meredith and Delilah.

The search party learns that the body found near the river is Shelby Tebow, not Meredith.

During Shelby's labor, Dr. Feingold uses forceps without her consent, injuring the baby.

Cassandra Hanaka confronts Meredith and admits she has been sending the anonymous threatening texts.

Meredith and Josh run into Kate and Bea at a restaurant celebrating Bea's birthday, and the four spend the night eating and dancing.

Bea's car strikes and kills Shelby on the road; Meredith recognizes the victim and helps Bea hide the body.

Piper shows Leo a childhood photo of Delilah, revealing she has a cleft chin that the girl living with the Dickeys does not have.

Meredith tries to call the police to confess; Bea attacks her with a hammer in the garage as Delilah watches from the doorway.

Police break into Bea's music studio and find Delilah alive in the attic; Bea flees and is later arrested and convicted.

A young woman named Shelby Tebow disappears one night, and weeks later her neighbor Meredith Dickey and Meredith's daughter Delilah vanish as well. Meanwhile, a girl who believes herself to be Delilah escapes captivity and is brought to live with the Dickey family. The mystery of what truly happened to Shelby and Meredith slowly unfolds through multiple timelines, revealing that Meredith's neighbor Bea was responsible for both deaths. A chance discovery — a childhood photograph revealing a physical difference — exposes that the girl living with the Dickeys is not Delilah at all. The hunt for answers leads police directly to Bea's music studio, where the real Delilah has been hidden for eleven years.

The core story of disappearances, murder, and discovery.

Shelby feels she is being followed and crouches to tie her shoe as headlights appear from an oncoming car.

Trapped in a dark basement, a captive girl invents an imaginary friend named Gus to help herself survive.

Detective Rowlings bends protocol and allows Josh to take the girl home before the DNA test results are complete.

Meredith decides not to tell Josh about the threatening texts, wanting to protect her independence as a working doula.

Leo notices the girl living with him pulls out her own hair and speaks with a rural accent unlike anything he or Josh would use.

Meredith meets Shelby Tebow as a potential new doula client; the two immediately get along well.

Shelby texts Meredith late at night saying she is afraid of her husband, but Meredith ultimately decides not to contact the police.

Meredith visits Shelby to check on her and hears an unfamiliar man's voice coming from inside the house.

Kate schedules an appointment at Dr. Feingold's office, pretending to be pregnant in order to investigate him as a suspect.

Shelby decides to sue Dr. Feingold for malpractice, and Feingold calls Meredith directly, threatening to ruin her.

Leo and the girl practice a wall-walking game she invented during her years alone in the basement.

Josh takes the girl to a hypnotist, hoping the sessions will unlock buried memories of her captivity.

Bea visits Meredith the day after the hit-and-run and tells her to act normal, warning her to stay silent.

Meredith tells Bea they should turn themselves in to the police, but Bea firmly refuses.

The girl slips out through a bedroom window and disappears while police are present in the Dickey home.

Before disaster strikes, the suburban world of this story is already filled with small tensions and concealed truths. Meredith quietly protects her professional independence from Josh, befriends a troubled client named Shelby, and ignores warning signs about Shelby's home life. Meanwhile, a girl in captivity invents an imaginary friend named Gus just to survive. After Meredith and Delilah vanish, the investigation moves slowly, with suspects investigated and dismissed and a young detective bending rules to reunite a grieving father with a girl who may not be his daughter. The aftermath of Bea's cover-up plays out in careful, revealing moments — Bea coaching Meredith to act normal, Meredith pushing back, and a final escape through a bedroom window that sets the endgame in motion.

The hidden details and quiet moments behind each disappearance.

A captive girl secretly files a spoon against the toilet tank lid over many days, sharpening it into a weapon.

Josh calls the police to report Meredith and Delilah missing, doing so at Bea's urging.

Meredith is frightened by a figure in a hospital parking lot after a late-night birth, then receives a taunting text saying to get home safe.

Shelby signs the doula contract with Meredith despite her husband Jason's attempt to negotiate a lower price.

Police search Josh's property and find trace amounts of blood inside the garage.

Detective Rowlings tells Josh that the DNA test confirms the girl is his daughter, concealing the true negative result.

Meredith notices an unexplained bruise on Leo while bathing him and calls Charlotte to ask whether he was hurt.

Meredith takes her children to the Hanaka house and discovers that Marty pretended not to know her at a recent neighborhood barbecue.

An unknown car follows Kate and Bea closely on the rain-soaked drive home from Dr. Feingold's office.

Shelby's newborn baby is diagnosed with a brain bleed caused by Dr. Feingold's use of forceps during delivery.

A paternity test reveals that Jason Tebow is not the biological father of Shelby's baby.

Josh explains to Leo that Gus was a survival mechanism rather than a deliberate lie, and Leo apologizes to the girl.

Charlotte calls Meredith to report that a boy at the daycare locked Leo inside a chest for nearly an hour.

Bea drives Meredith to a motel and forces her to write a fake suicide note before killing her and staging the scene.

Jason Tebow is released from prison following Bea's conviction, and the girl is confirmed as Carly Byrd and reunited with her real family.

Every catastrophe in this story is the result of a turning point — a decision made or a truth revealed at the wrong moment. A girl in captivity chooses survival over starvation and quietly prepares her escape. A detective lies to a grieving father to protect his feelings, and a neighbor learns that the person she loved has been concealing a violent secret for over a decade. Between these extremes, smaller revelations ripple outward: a bruise on a child, a paternity test result, a photograph of two people who pretended not to know each other. Each discovery pushes the story toward its climax, until the final truths about Meredith's death and Delilah's whereabouts can no longer be hidden. Justice arrives not through careful investigation, but through a chain of accidents set off by Bea's original act of self-preservation.