An 18-year-old Amish girl whose accusation of murder serves as the central conflict, struggling between her community's values and a hidden life.

Katie's mother, who embodies the quiet strength of an Amish wife, deeply protective of her children amidst family turmoil.

The patriarch of the Fisher family, representing the rigidity of Old Order Amish faith and grappling with maintaining his family's standing.

Katie's loyal suitor who represents the traditional Amish path and whose love for Katie is tested through the novel's events.

Katie's excommunicated brother, bridging the gap between the Amish and "English" worlds, whose choices impact Katie's journey.

A psychiatrist involved in Katie's case and Ellie’s former college boyfriend, offering insights into trauma and memory.

Detective-Sergeant whose investigation into the infant's death prompts the legal challenges that Ellie faces in the case.