Madison wakes in a roadside ditch covered in blood with no memory of who she is or how she got there.

Wayne Boone arrives at the police station claiming the amnesiac young woman is his missing teenage daughter, Mary.

Drew walks through his hostile town making missing person fliers for his disappeared girlfriend, Lola.

Persuaded by Wayne's documents and exhausted by her amnesia, Madison agrees to stay with Wayne at his remote cabin.

Drew finds the word 'Murderer' written on his school locker, deepening his sense of community hostility.

Madison has a dangerous allergic reaction to a strawberry smoothie at a diner in Waybrooke.

Drew confesses to Lola's best friend Autumn that he broke up with Lola on the night she disappeared.

Drew sneaks into the sheriff's office and downloads recordings from the department's tip line onto a USB drive.

A neighbor named Ben Hooper stops by the cabin to introduce himself, and Wayne abruptly sends Madison inside.

Drew discovers a tip line recording from a woman who spotted a young girl in a floral jacket in Waybrooke.

Madison finds Ben Hooper's body buried in a hole dug near the cabin woodpile.

Wayne catches Madison just before she reaches a neighbor's cabin and chokes her until she loses consciousness.

Drew enters the basement of Wayne's cabin and discovers Madison chained to the floor by her ankle.

Madison uses a fireplace poker to kill Wayne during a brutal basement fight, and she and Drew escape.

Madison visits Drew at the boat launch on what would have been Lola's birthday and helps him find peace.

A teenage girl with amnesia is discovered on a rural Oregon roadside and taken in by a man who claims to be her father, placing her in grave danger she cannot yet recognize. While she struggles to accept her supposed identity as Mary Boone, high school senior Drew Carter-Diaz desperately searches for his missing girlfriend, Lola, while his entire community treats him as the prime suspect. Drew and his friends risk arrest to steal tip line recordings from the sheriff's office, uncovering evidence that points toward the remote cabin where the girl is being held. As the girl's suspicions about her captor grow, she makes a horrifying discovery in the woods and attempts to escape, only to be caught and imprisoned in the cabin basement. Drew arrives just in time, and together he and the girl fight and kill their captor in a brutal final confrontation. Months later, the girl—revealed to be Madison Perkins—visits a grieving Drew and helps him begin to heal on what would have been Lola's birthday.

The headline events of Madison's kidnapping and Drew's search for Lola.

A paramedic examines Madison at the roadside and determines her injuries are consistent with a recent accident.

Drew's cousin Max finds him at the library making fliers and urges him to consider that Lola may be dead.

Drew and Max go to the river where police are searching, and Lola's parents refuse to acknowledge Drew.

Officer Bowman leaves his contact card with Madison before departing the cabin on her first night there.

Sheriff Roane seizes Drew's SUV as evidence in Lola's disappearance while Drew is at school.

Roane drives Drew to the Willamette boat launch and pressures him to admit he harmed Lola.

Wayne buys Madison a bag of clothes that are far too small and insists she prefers florals and bright colors.

Autumn plays a voicemail Lola left the night she vanished, in which Lola calls Drew a monster.

Drew bluffs his way out of the sheriff's office by pretending he has simply been sitting and waiting.

Drew, Max, and Autumn drive to Waybrooke to meet the witness who claims she saw Lola recently.

Max slips into a closet at the Waybrooke diner and secretly photographs security footage showing Madison and Wayne.

Wayne discovers Madison standing over Ben Hooper's grave and tells her she always ruins everything.

Officer Bowman confidently tells Drew and his friends that the girl living at the cabin is not Lola Scott.

Madison regains consciousness in the cabin basement and, amid flooding memories, finally remembers her real name.

A newspaper article reveals that Wayne Boone was a serial killer who had already murdered his own daughter, Mary.

After Madison is found injured on the road, a paramedic assesses her wounds and Officer Bowman carefully establishes her in Wayne Boone's cabin before leaving her a lifeline in the form of his card. Meanwhile, Drew faces mounting pressure as the sheriff seizes his vehicle and his community closes ranks against him. A pivotal night brings Drew, Autumn, and Max together in Drew's bedroom, where a voicemail from Lola shifts Autumn's suspicions and the three agree to pursue the investigation themselves. Following leads to the town of Waybrooke, the trio uncovers witness accounts and illicitly captured security footage linking Madison to a dangerous stranger. Despite Officer Bowman's confident insistence that the girl at the cabin is not Lola, events in the basement quickly prove that appearances have deceived everyone. When the dust finally settles, a newspaper article lays bare the full horrifying truth of Wayne Boone's years of crimes.

The supporting moments that shape both investigations.

Before police find her, Madison has a flash of memory of large hands reaching for her at a mailbox.

Wayne shows Madison photos on his phone and an old school ID as proof that she is Mary Boone.

Drew's fathers tell him that police have found an unidentified body, deepening his fear for Lola.

Madison notices that the cheerful decor and Christian books in her supposed bedroom feel completely foreign to her.

While shopping at a thrift store, Madison has a sudden flash of memory of a cat resting on a red sofa.

While watching the film Ever After with Wayne, Madison has a vivid memory of watching it with her dark-haired mother.

Madison dreams about playing on a school softball team and celebrating her birthday with her mother, restoring her memories.

Wayne enters Madison's darkened bedroom and sits silently at the foot of her bed, watching her sleep.

Officer Bowman visits the cabin to ask about missing neighbor Ben Hooper, and Wayne lies about ever knowing him.

Madison retrieves a crumpled flier Wayne discarded and discovers that their neighbor Ben Hooper has been reported missing.

Drew drives to the Boone cabin and spots Wayne carrying an unconscious young woman toward the basement door.

Wayne tells Madison in the basement that he genuinely believes she is his daughter Mary and that he is saving her.

Madison finds a list of names scratched into the basement floor in different handwriting by Wayne's previous victims.

Drew realizes the most recent name scratched into the basement wall is Lola's and that she is dead.

Drew, Autumn, and Max sit together at the boat launch telling stories about Lola until nightfall.

From the moment Madison regains consciousness, small flashes of memory hint at a truth her captor is desperate to suppress, but with no identity to anchor her she remains dangerously vulnerable to his manipulation. Wayne constructs an elaborate fiction around her, yet details in the cabin and his contradictions about her tastes begin to crack the illusion from the start. A vivid dream about softball and her mother finally restores Madison's full memories, confirming she is not Mary Boone and steeling her courage to act. While Madison uncovers the terrifying truth about Wayne's nature through a crumpled flier and a watching figure in the dark, Drew races toward a confrontation that will answer the most devastating question of his search. The revelation of a name scratched into the basement floor destroys Drew's last hope for Lola, yet his moral courage keeps him from walking away. The story closes not with the fight but with quiet healing, as Drew's friends gather at the river to remember Lola together.